41 ms·
Where do these critical thinking skills to detect bullshit come from? Look at all the bullshit we inherited from Aristotle. No one even thought to think it was
by taylodl 9y ago
Where do these critical thinking skills to detect bullshit come from? Look at all the bullshit we inherited from Aristotle. No one even thought to think it was bullshit until people came along and said "let's see" and actually started performing experiments and thus introducing the Scientific Age. Ask any small child which will object will fall faster: a 10 Kg weight or a 5 Kg weight and they'll unanimously say the 10 Kg weight.
So not only are we dealing with anthropological biases we're also dealing with logic: not all bullshit can be shown to be bullshit. One of the most famous examples is my assertion there's a teapot orbiting the Sun between the orbits of Earth and Mars. You say that's bullshit. Now I say prove it's bullshit, prove there isn't a teapot orbiting the Sun between the orbit of Earth and Mars! You can't. You can't prove that's bullshit.
It's at this point you may realize the tables have been subtly turned against you. You see, I made the assertion there's a teapot orbiting the Sun between Earth and Mars. It's not on you to prove that's bullshit, it's on me to provide evidence of my assertion.
So, if you are 100% confident that it is bullshit, what is there to lose? Everything.
Edit: changed 'You say' to 'You see'
- babyrainbow 9y agoYou are entirely missing the point. The point is that both sides are prone to spouting bullshit (or selective truths) (for what ever reasons), so no side should be forced to silence...
- Oletros 9y ago> The point is that both sides are prone to spouting bullshit I expect that you can provide examples of this. Until now, the ones spouting bullshit is the anti science one.
- babyrainbow 9y ago>I expect that you can provide examples of this http://www.latimes.com/science/sciencenow/la-sci-sn-fda-drugs-safety-20170509-story.html http://www.latimes.com/science/sciencenow/la-sci-sn-fda-drug... So when an authority says that something is safe, and later turn out not to be so, isn't the original claim just bullshit? Or is it not bullshit because that is the best we could have done, but we still sold it as legit, without saying about the flaws in our process, which is why I mentioned selectively saying the truth... I am pretty sure one can come up with other serious cases where "science" of today turned out to be bullshit later. The famous study that both ant and pro vaxxers tout are a very good example. Pretty sure that have been similar issues recently regarding diet, pesticide use, use of plastics and stuff like that... EDIT: Ultimately, I think the majority of what we consider as "science" today (except maths/physics) is a somewhat grey area and is prone to various kinds of manipulation should not be really accepted without any sort of challenge. And just because something is peer reviewed does not make it the word of god...
- Oletros 9y ago> So when an authority says that something is safe, and later turn out not to be so, isn't the original claim just bullshit? No, it is not bullshit. > The famous study that both ant and pro vaxxers tout are a very good example Are you talking about the study that the people that has passed this bill would be glad to use? Yes, that study was bullshit and a fraud, and no, the pro vaccination people didn't did ant bullshit. > EDIT: Ultimately, I think the majority of what we consider as "science" today (except maths/physics) is a somewhat grey area and is prone to various kinds of manipulation should not be really accepted without any sort of challenge. And just because something is peer reviewed does not make it the word of god... No, it is not the word of god, but when a topic has been proved for decades and innumerable experiments it is fairly sure that the science is sound. And yes, I'm talking about the Theory of Evolution and Climate Change basis. The TWO topics that this bill will be against. By the way, one is a physics topic.
- secstate 9y agoThere's an entire discipline regarding how and when science switches paradigms, to borrow a Kuhnian word. I think the best guard against any of this is the old Feynman test. Can you explain the idea sufficiently to a lay person that they can understand the idea? Then we understand it. Until then, there's more work to do and you cannot malign anyone for disbelieving you.
- Oletros 9y ago> There's an entire discipline regarding how and when science switches paradigms, to borrow a Kuhnian word. Thing that has nothing to do with this bill > I think the best guard against any of this is the old Feynman test. And this has nothing to do with this bill. Theory of Evolution and Climate change has been explained sufficiently in laymen terms to be comprehended by anyone. What this bill does is trying to negate the science without having anything to do if it has been tested or explained in simple terms
- secstate 9y ago