4 ms·
Galois Theory for Beginners (2010) [pdf]
- kdamica 9y agoFun fact: Evariste Galois made major contributions to math in his teens, before dying in a duel at age 20. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89variste_Galois https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89variste_Galois
- schoen 9y agoWikipedia reminds me that the version of his death (staying up all night before the duel to frantically write down his mathematical ideas at the last possible moment) that I read in Men of Mathematics may have been overdramatized, apparently like a number of the stories in that book.
- DonbunEf7 9y agoWhat definitely did happen is that Galois was worried that he might not win the duel and that he might never get the chance to redeem himself in front of his mathematical peers. We know this because of the letter he wrote before he died; we actually have it, and WP has a scan of a page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:E._Galois_Letter.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:E._Galois_Letter.jpg It is hard to overdramatize the events of Galois' life. He lived during a revolution, he went out into the streets to protest and fight, he was arrested multiple times for his outrageous political speech, and he laid down his life for his political beliefs. A friend of mine who survived a chronic and often-fatal disease in his teens used to quip, "Well, if I were Galois, I'd have already made my best contributions and died by now." Galois indeed burned fast and bright.
- bikenaga 9y agoTony Rothman wrote an article in the American Mathematical Monthly which helped to separate a lot of the fact from the fiction in accounts of Galois's life. Highly recommended: https://www.maa.org/sites/default/files/pdf/upload_library/22/Ford/Rothman84-106.pdf https://www.maa.org/sites/default/files/pdf/upload_library/2...
- tnecniv 9y agoHe was also a political firebrand at the time and did much of his writing in prison as a result.
- logingone 9y agoThat's fantastic. Not him dying, but you're not likely to hear a story like that these days.
- mdevere 9y agothis guy was AMAZING at maths
- ktta 9y agoGalois fields are used in crypto a bit, and I recommend this lecture to understand it in the context of crypto https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1v2tX4_dkQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1v2tX4_dkQ PS: He has an entire series of lectures on his channel. Highly recommend.
- drevet 9y agoThanks ;)
- monfrere 9y agoCan anyone help me understand what is happening at the bottom of page 23 (page 3 of the PDF)? It says any permutation sigma of x_1, ..., x_n can be extended to a bijection of Q(x_1, ..., x_n) defined by sigma f(x_1, ..., x_n) = f(sigma x_1, ..., sigma x_n). But I don't see how this definition can be consistent. For example, let f(a, b) = a - b g(a, b) = a/a + b/b = 2 x_1 = 5 x_2 = 3 sigma x_1 = x_2 sigma x_2 = x_1 Then according to the formula: sigma f(5, 3) = sigma (5 - 3) = sigma 2 = f(3, 5) = -2 But sigma g(5, 3) = sigma 2 = g(3, 5) = 2 Contradiction?
- topynate 9y agoYour sigma is a bijection on rational functions of a, b, not on the evaluations of those functions at particular values of a and b. In lambda notation:* sigma f = \a b -> f (sigma a) (sigma b) = f b a That means sigma f = \a b -> b - a. On the other hand, g := \a b -> 2. So sigma g = g. Looking again at your equality: > sigma f(5, 3) = sigma (5 - 3) = sigma 2 = f(3, 5) = -2 We should read sigma f(5, 3) as (sigma f)(5,3) = (3 - 5) = -2. Note: sigma f is not equal to sigma (5 - 3), because f is not the same rational function as "5 - 3"! * This is an abuse of notation, because a and b are bound variables inside the lambda. In this case, being more precise would probably be less clear.
- monfrere 9y ago> Your sigma is a bijection on rational functions of a, b, not on the evaluations of those functions at particular values of a and b. I see, this is the key point I was missing. But now I am confused as to whether Q(x_1, x_2) is supposed to be a subfield of the real numbers or a field of rational functions of x_1, x_2.
- netvarun 9y agoThis document was also mentioned yesterday on the 'Why is the quintic unsolvable?'[1] post. The post also has some additional interesting references in the comments. Worth checking out! [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14685466 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14685466
- empath75 9y agoBeginners?
- Ceezy 9y agoGalois theory without functor... Without fundamental theorem of algebra. Are you kidding?
- stablemap 9y agoIt's a five page article in the Monthly, but I'd hesitate to include either topic even in a book.
- Ceezy 9y agoWhy? Whitout a clear explanation Galois functors you miss everything... And without the fundamental theorem of algebra, it's going to be very hard to have any real life example.
- JadeNB 9y ago> Galois theory without functor... The category-theoretic accretion to Galois theory is a much later addition; Galois certainly didn't think in those terms, and I think that it is not obligatory for an expository (or even a mathematical!) treatment of the subject to do so.
- gerbilly 9y agoGalois had an insight that I always seemed particularly deep to me: that problems should be classified not by topic area (analysis, theory of equations, geometry) but by their underlying form. Galois was ahead of his time.[1] [1] You could say he was ahead by a century, to quote a famous song.
- ManyEthers 9y agoI have never studied group theory, so this is way beyond what I'm ready for. But I scanned over a few sections and read to the point that I got lost. The part that surprised me is that it seems to focus on rational numbers. I always assumed that Galois Groups were focused on more abstract concepts of sets. Is Galois Theory mostly about rational number (or even real numbers), or is the author just using the rationals to keep the paper focused on beginners?