6 ms·
Is this a parody or for real?
by ww520 16y ago
Is this a parody or for real?
- acangiano 16y agoIt's real (see my blog post about it: http://math-blog.com/2010/06/28/forget-pi-here-comes-tau/ http://math-blog.com/2010/06/28/forget-pi-here-comes-tau/).
- JadeNB 16y agoNote that your equality \(e^{i\tau} = 1\) implies only that \(e^{i\pi} = \pm1\), hence is strictly weaker than Euler's equality (which picks a sign). I think that you might have meant \(e^{i\tau/2} = -1\). (Is there a way to do LaTeX properly here?)
- acangiano 16y agoI was actually reporting the equality as expressed by the manifesto. See here: http://tauday.com/#sec:euler_s_formula http://tauday.com/#sec:euler_s_formula
- camiller 16y agoI think real. Although I didn't read all of the article I think the main thrust was that since 2pi appears in so many places in math that a constant based on the ratio of circumference to radius rather than diameter would be more appropriate. Realistically I think there are better ways to spend your time but ....
- ww520 16y agoIs it like converting from Queen's system to metric system in U.S.?
- techiferous 16y agoNot exactly, since there is only one constant to convert (not many units) and the conversion factor is very straightforward (2 pi = 1 tau instead of 39.37 inches = 1 meter). But yes in that many people would have to change their ways.
- whyenot 16y agoLike Jonathan Swift's proposal for ending poverty and hunger in Ireland, I am sure this "modest proposal" is entirely serious.
- mhartl 16y agoThough it shares some elements of propagandistic tone, the Tau Manifesto is unlike Swift's proposal in the most important sense, in that it's perfectly serious. Using the phrase "a modest proposal" in this context was a dubious choice (to say the least). I've changed the section name for clarity.
- mhartl 16y agoI should have anticipated this confusion, which resulted from my infelicitous use of the phrase "A modest proposal". The Tau Manifesto is meant to be fun, but it's definitely not a parody. For clarity, I've changed the name of the section in question.