10 ms·
Differentiating laptops: How about a decent keyboard? (2015)
- JeremyBanks 9y agoKeyboards and trackpads were a differentiator for the MacBook, during its rise. They might not stand out today, but ten years ago they were exceptional compared with almost all of their competitor's laptop keyboards. The layout may not have been optimal, but at least the keys didn't feel like they were going to fall off at every press.
- wmichelin 9y agoI think they're still better than anything on the market. It could be at the software level, but I've never once seen or used a Windows laptop with decent two finger scrolling.
- dingo_bat 9y agoI think most windows laptops today do two finger scrolling really well. The pinch and zoom is shit though.
- akurilin 9y agoAgreed. As someone who regularly gets "Linux laptops" for work, their keyboards flex inwards and their touchpads are miserable. I often carry a wireless mouse with me to meetings because using those things ends up being such a pain. Never had that issue with Macs.
- leeoniya 9y ago2015
- waiseristy 9y agoHow about going one further and asking for some decent processors? Why is it so difficult to find <= 14 inch laptop with a quad core?
- eropple 9y agoI was under the impression that at that size it's starting to get into heat dissipation territory, but I couldn't say for sure.
- raingrove 9y agoBattery life mostly
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoI thought more cores running slower was supposed to be more power efficient?
- waiseristy 9y agoLenovo makes the T4xxP series laptops with Quad cores, I'm running one right now. But I would rather not be stuck buying the same model every time I go laptop shopping =\
- gkop 9y agoUnfortunately I think this model bundles dedicated graphics, which I have no need for. I have yet to find a Linux-friendly PC laptop with quad-core and integrated graphics only.
- waiseristy 9y agoYou are correct, it also lacks thunderbolt!! There really is no good option for us at the moment
- eikenberry 9y agoWith the current T470p you can get a quad-core i5 (7300HQ or 7440HQ) with the integrated graphics. So you can get a quad-core. You just can't get the i7 w/o the nvidia graphics.
- woodandsteel 9y agoI agree 100%. Laptop keyboards are terrible.
- jseliger 9y agoOLED displays might also be nice. I think Dell/Alienware is the only company offering them in a somewhat mainstream configuration: https://hothardware.com/reviews/alienware-13-with-oled-review?page=7 https://hothardware.com/reviews/alienware-13-with-oled-revie...
- robin_reala 9y agoLenovo has an OLED for their X1 as an option, and you can get an HP Spectre with OLED as well.
- tikhonj 9y agoI got a ThinkPad X1 Yoga with an OLED display last year. It's pretty incredible, especially at rendering black and dark colors. The form-factor is also incredible: very light and thin and just slightly larger than a 13" laptop. This means it fits in my small laptop bag (designed for 13" models) but has a 14" screen and a great keyboard with full-size keys. The touchpad is also pretty large and top-notch and it comes with the traditional ThinkPad trackpoint pointer if you're into that. It's not super cheap but if you can afford it, I highly recommend it.
- old-gregg 9y ago> keyboard ... for most people it is the main way they interact with their machines The answer is right there: no, most people barely touch the keyboard. Most people are not using laptops as tools to create anything. Most people do nothing but look at Reddit/Facebook endless stream of entertainment and scroll, scroll, scroll. Apple understood this early on and they made the perfect laptop for scrolling, which is now available in Air, Pro and Regular flavors. These aren't for typing. As long as majority of laptop buyers are content consumers, this is not going to change. However... It will change. The content consumption has been shifting to mobile: the phones and tablets are taking over. Once a laptop once again becomes primarily a _tool_, decent keyboards (and maybe even tall screens!) will come back, just look at the desktops. As traditional desktops have been 100% abandoned by consumers, the mechanical keyboards and high quality IPS monitors made a smashing comeback, the power users (remaining audience) is willing to pay for nice tools.
- threeseed 9y agoNot sure what you mean about Apple. Their second generation, butterfly keyboards are amazing once you get used to it and aren't some indication that they are abandoning content creators.
- nickpeterson 9y agoHow about their dedicated emoji bar instead of control keys?
- threeseed 9y ago1. It's not a dedicated emoji bar. 2. You can set it to permanently show control keys. 3. It's optional. You can buy the model without it. 4. Some of us actually like it. I use IntelliJ every day and it's great to be able to have dedicated refactor/debug keys instead of having to remember arcane key commands.
- JoshTriplett 9y ago
- ValentineC 9y agoIt's surprising how no laptop manufacturer has managed to come up with a trackpad that comes close to being a decent competitor to Apple's. I'd love for a non-Apple laptop to have the (older) MacBook trackpad and keyboards — not the huge trackpads or butterfly switches that come with the current generation ones.
- jdc0589 9y agothe circa 2012 to 2015 keyboards and trackpads on MacBooks were PERFECT. the new keyboards feel like typing on a hard table top
- threeseed 9y agoYou really do get used to it after a while and I am actually far more accurate on it than the 2015 MacBook Pro. Also might want to be clear which MacBook you are talking about. The 2017 model has the second generation keyboard which is significantly better than the 2016.
- ValentineC 9y ago> The 2017 model has the second generation keyboard which is significantly better than the 2016. I thought both the 2016 and 2017 MacBook Pros had the second-generation butterfly switches. Wasn't the first iteration of the butterfly switch only in the first generation 12" MacBook (the one with one USB-C port)?
- interpol_p 9y agoI love the new keyboards. They feel so solid and strangely "direct" compared to the old ones (which now feel like typing on marshmallows by comparison). Same goes for the iPad Pro smart keyboard cover. The stability and "clickiness" of the keys outweighs the depth of travel for me.
- vvanders 9y agoI'd argue that the Surface Book is of the similar quality and the keyboard is certainly light-years ahead. I've got a mac pro at work that's nothing but a pile of squishy keys.
- gkop 9y agoBetween T520 and T550, there was T530, which had basically the chiclet version of the T520 keyboard, and it was just as good if not better than the T520 keyboard. Indeed, Lenovo really screwed up with the T540 and beyond - the useless numeric pad shifts the rest of the keyboard way off center. Fortunately, there's the T4XX series, that has a very good keyboard still.
- rhizome 9y agoI recently did a little bit of research and as far as I could find, currently there are exactly two 15" laptops with tenkey-less keyboards: Apple's and (now) the Dell XPS 15.
- zzalpha 9y agoI can attest, the keyboard on the 5th gen X1 Carbon is also excellent. Remarkably, they actually managed to improve on previous generations (which, for the record, have Backspace, Delete, PgUp, and PgDown keys) by increasing key travel. About its only fault is the Ctrl/Fn key position, but you can swap them via configuration for those who have trouble adapting. As an aside, I much prefer Fn key mappings for thing like media keys over dedicated buttons: fewer things that actuate means fewer things to break, fewer things that'll get crumbs or liquid under them, etc. The 5th gen carbon has one button aside from what's on the keyboard: the power button. The result is a much simpler, cleaner layout.
- Clubber 9y agoI had a W500 and the keyboard was amazing (as was the whole laptop). I replaced the screen, the hard drive, memory, etc. I've bought Thinkpads since IBM sold them because of their keyboards and nub. I hate the numeric keypad. It throws the balance off and I feel like I have to shift the laptop to the right to type. Is the demographic that wants the numeric keyboard that large? They used to sell a separate one for accounting types, now they all have them and I hate it. They also switched to the chicklet style like Apple. I like the chicklet style on the Macs but I don't think I'd like it on a Thinkpad. I believe they took a row off the keyboard and jammed them together in some jacked up configuration. The home/end/pageup/down isn't in a position that resembles a 101/104. That aggravates me too. I'm ready to buy a new laptop. My 2013 rMBP is getting old. I've had to repair the trackpad and now it's complaining about a memory module. I looked at the P51s and P71s, but that damn keypad. Come back to us old Thinkpad keyboard, it was a real differentiator.
- wolfgke 9y agoAnother feature laptop makers could differentiate is easy repairability. I mean: Make the laptop as easy to repair as it is to repair a (self-built) desktop PC. This is an ideal that can never be reached completely due to the (e.g. space) constraints - but it can serve as an ideal to strive for. And either provide your modified GPU drivers with regular updates for the whole lifetime of the device (i.e. 3-5 years) or let the GPU vendor do the job. But don't make it hard/impossible to install the GPU vendor's drivers if you cannot regularly provide updates. Make it easy to find the drivers that you need to install when one sets up the OS newly. I've seen driver websites of laptop vendors where just the complete list of drivers is shown for hardware that might be used in some laptops of the family. Not fun. :-( Negatiate hard with Microsoft whether you can also provide Windows 10 Enterprise to your customers, where a lot more surveillance functions can be blocked (a large reason why a lot of German companies don't update to Windows 10 - only Enterprise allows decent blocking of the surveillance, but is hard to get).
- colejohnson66 9y agoFor the “surveillance” (as you put it), can’t that be turned off with Group Policies? There’s a setting in there to disable the telemetry.
- Spooky23 9y agoNot really. Depending on the edition and branch you are using you cannot disable telemetry. If you have high assurance environment that use O365, the best path right now is Windows 8.1, which takes care of you until 2023. After that, assume that you'll use another platform and make appropriate application decisions.
- walterbell 9y agoCan Win 10 LTSB be configured with equivalent assurance to Win 8.1 (or Win 7) minus telemetry updates? How realistic is application migration for the 2023 timeframe? MacOS requires a hardware change and the macOS/iOS landscape may be very different in six years. If applications wcan afford to invest in migration to Qt/wxWidgets, they can support all three of Windows, macOS and Linux. Electron-based (web) applications are consistent across platforms but memory/resource intensive. This might be improved with WebAssembly. The most efficient cross-platform app architectures are used by games, which combine a fast garbage-collected runtime (e.g. Lua) with native graphics rendering libraries. The downside is a complete absence of "native" widgets or semi-standard "web widgets". What could be the options for a high-assurance desktop application architecture of 2023? Let's assume that high-assurance and "cloud/SaaS" are separate markets. Even VDI solutions require an OS to run applications. OpenBSD + Qt? Qubes + unikernels + graphics compositing? Linux + Qt? A fusion of macOS and iOS? A reversal of Microsoft on Windows telemetry and data collection business model? The challenge is for any platform to achieve the scale needed to attract developers, an advantage which Microsoft is throwing away.
- dingo_bat 9y agoHow about you use a decent keyboard connected to your desk dock? The only time I need to use the keyboard seriously is when I'm sitting at my office desk or the work desk at my home. And both places have a dock with an awesome keyboard and display connected. I don't even care how the in built keyboard works as long as it's enough for the random Facebook post.
- Viper007Bond 9y agoHint: Many people use laptops when traveling or when not at home or the office. Infact that's the only thing I use mine for. I have a significantly more powerful desktop in my home office.
- exabrial 9y agoHow about an Ethernet Jack? More ports? Replaceable batteries? Not soldered ram?
- makecheck 9y agoConsidering that desktop keyboards are essentially tied to the computer only by a cable (or nothing), it is kind of amazing that laptop keyboards are so integrated. Something like a standard rectangle that can snap in/out or slide in/out different keyboards would sure be nice.
- throwanem 9y agoThe actual mechanics are mostly standard among manufacturers lately. The shapes are all that's not, and getting laptop manufacturers to design around a fixed range of form factors seems like a tall order.
- Clubber 9y agoThat's a great idea. The keyboard is the most important part of a laptop for me, and most of them are shite.
- shams93 9y agoIts hard to pack a decent keyboard into a super slim profile. My thinkpad t420 is really fat by today's standards but the keyboard on this types like a dream.
- dsparkman 9y agoActually, give us an IBM ThinkPad 701 with modern internals.Throw in a really large battery with an OLED display, and you have a great machine. :)
- rcpt 9y agoI have one of those T5*0s that he's talking about and he's right - the keyboard is awful. Not only those surprise pgup pgdn next to the arrow keys but take a look at PrintScreen jammed in between alt and ctrl! Then I've got the fact that the keycaps are so easy to remove that my 2-year-old has made a game of popping them off and stashing them around the house. The laptop is basically unusable.
- post_break 9y agoTrackpads on devices that aren’t macs are the work of the devil. Why are they so touchy or non responsive? Why are they so small? Why are they not centered?
- nothis 9y agoIt's bizarre. What's also bizarre is that, apparently, it's the new thing to hate modern MacBooks not having physical buttons. I have absolutely _zero_ problems with that, never "accidentally" clicked anything in my life, it's perfectly balanced for just the right amount of pressure. As for the other things, I've been wondering, too! > Why are they so small? Probably because they're afraid people accidentally touch them? I think if Apple dares to make them this big, that's probably an irrational fear. >Why are they not centered? After a _long_ time thinking of it, I got an idea: Maybe they're centered on the space bar to be between your hands when typing? That, however, would also mean that they acknowledge that you're usually holding your hands off-center to reach around the number pad. Has anyone used a laptop number pad in the past 20 years? I agree that they should go in favor of a more sensible overall layout.
- rubatuga 9y agoMost people are satisfied with their current setup, things like off centre trackpads are of little concern to the public
- michaelmrose 9y agoPeople aren't just bad at life they are bad at understanding their own relationship with things and predicting what will satisfy them. People will be subtley dissatisfied with things without examination of why or attempting to alleviate this dissatisfaction. It is meaningless to posit people are satisfied with the state of things as if this said anything about the value of the current state of things or how people would react to an improvement. People could have been said to be as satisfied with pocket pcs back around win ce. After being exposed to a touch screen interface that wasn't completely garbage they overwhelming preferred them and voted with their wallets.
- nothis 9y ago>Laptop makers complain they can’t differentiate Wait, what, lol? As someone having been looking for laptops quite a few times in the past few years, I find it ridiculous how hard it is to find something with a) the exact hardware you want/need and b) not having a super shitty case/design. It's bizarre! You'd think you go to a website, pick a CPU, RAM, GPU, harddisk, screen and case. Hey, maybe you have to pay $100 extra for someone screwing that shit together in half an hour, I'd do that!
- michaelmrose 9y agoI'm still waiting for swappable gpu wherein a) you can actually buy the gpu and b) future generations support the same standards without different cooling and power requirements
- Godel_unicode 9y agoWhy not ask for 20 hour battery life while gaming in a lighter chassis? If we're playing the "design a device with no thought to the physical realities" game, let's get creative! Although on a more serious note, you can have this today as long as thunderbolt is okay.
- michaelmrose 9y agoI owned a computer with this about 9 years ago in theory. In reality it was only within a small range of gpu wherein price wise it made little sense to go with anything but the best of I think 2 or 3 possibilities. Unfortunately while you could select from multiple options at purchase you couldn't actually buy even those options after the fact so nobody could have upgraded after the fact. Future editions had different thermal characteristics and didn't fit. I heard anecdotal evidence that at least some had physically modified the heat sink and made a original generation + 1 gpu work but couldn't confirm and I have no idea where they were supposed to have actually bought such a thing. I will have to check out what is being done with external gpu recently it certainly seemed like an interesting idea.
- achikin 9y agoI used to own IBM model M when I was 15 and I was very happy to throw it away and buy an ordinal keyboard when they appeared in Russia. Being a part of "keyboard cult" for several years, I owned several "ergonomic" keyboards including Ergodox(which I have sold several days ago) and can say that it's a hype. Laptop keyboards are good enough for touch typing. Two things I'd like to have - non-staggered layout and split groups for each hand. Everything else above this does not add any usability at all.
- porker 9y agoInteresting feedback, as I have been considering an Ergodox. All I want is a split keyboard with 10+cm between the two sides, but the build quality of split normal keyboards (like Goldtouch, Kinesis Freestyle 2, Matias Ergo Pro) is shocking. I don't want something zany or a 60% keyboard (I like arrow keys, dedicated page up/down, home/end and function keys) but... the choices aren't there.
- achikin 9y agoI damaged my wrists a while ago so I'm very sensitive to the wrong wrist position. Unfortunately, I could not position Ergodox so doesn't cause me wrist pain. Also I find the travel distance of mechanical keys way too long. Otherwise Ergodox is one of the best keyboards in terms of layout and customizability. You can try Microsoft Sculpt. Not the latest version with numpad, but a previous version. It is split, has good enough scissor switches and has the best wrist support on the market which is built in the keyboard.
- userbinator 9y agoI blame the "thin, light, cheap" trend. Flat, island-style keys with an equally thin switch mechanism are easier to manufacture, thinner, and lighter than the traditional design. Other keys that are seldom used and could probably be done without are: Scroll Lock, Insert, SysReq, Home, and End. Removing unnecessary keys would free up space and improve usability. I strongly disagree. Scroll Lock causes the viewpoint to scroll instead of the cursor in a few programs I use. Insert/Home/End are essential for text editing. SysRq doesn't sound so useful until you realise that it's also known as the Print Screen key, and if you use Linux extensively then the actual SysRq function also becomes invaluable ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic_SysRq_key https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic_SysRq_key ). On the other hand, I've found "media/multimedia keys" pretty useless, and F-keys defaulted to something else is extremely irritating. I also disagree that the numpad is "useless": it's very effective for entering numbers, such as when you need to calculate something (of course, this is probably a minority opinion as most people seem to find maths mostly useless in general...) Personally, I'd be happy if laptop makers would stop trying to change keyboard layouts around and just keep all 10x standard keys as found on the IBM desktop PC keyboard (omitting the numpad is acceptable if the laptop is not wide enough), and go back to the traditional taller switch mechanism with curved, area-filling keys. The T60/X60 comes close.
- twhb 9y agoKeep in mind that these functions aren't being removed, just shifted to keyboard shortcuts. Do you really hit Print Screen more often, or more impatiently, than Ctrl+S? Besides, shortcuts are sometimes faster, by virtue of keeping your fingers near the home row.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> Insert/Home/End are essential for text editing I manage to edit text without these buttons so they are demonstrably not essential.
- Godel_unicode 9y ago> so they are demonstrably not essential. ... for you. For GP they obviously are.
- aetherspawn 9y agoMacbook Pros need a spring-loaded drop out ethernet jack, the thunderbolt doodad gets really hot, isn't as easy as ethernet to plug/unplug and is annoying to have on your desk to say the least.
- sand500 9y agoUSB C isn't easy to uplug?? On a side note, I wonder if they make Ethernet cables with the adapter built in.
- ValentineC 9y ago> USB C isn't easy to uplug?? I find the smooth texture (on at least the Apple cables) to be a pain to grip. It's easier for me with USB type-A cables as there's more surface area.
- ValentineC 9y agoI have a USB 3.0 type-A to Ethernet adapter and it's a pleasure to use with my old MacBook Pro. I wish they'd solve the grip issue on USB-C (and Thunderbolt/mini-DP).
- nayuki 9y agoI was strongly agreeing with the article until the last part where he went on a crusade to remove keys. > For example, the large Caps Lock key is a waste of space on a crowded keyboard. I never use it, but often hit it by mistake CAUSING ALL LETTERS TO BE CAPITALISED. Some people remap this to Ctrl. Anyway, users are so accustomed to a physical key in this position (regardless of what function they map it to) that it would be a disservice to remove it. > Other keys that are seldom used and could probably be done without are: Scroll Lock, Insert, SysReq, Home, and End. Removing unnecessary keys would free up space and improve usability. Are you kidding about not using Home and End? They are the lifeblood of text editing on Windows. Have you never selected a line with Shift+Home? Jumped to the end of the text with Ctrl+End? Or do you always mouse-select text? One of my laptop keyboards did not have dedicated Home+End keys, and had to access them with Fn+PgUp/PgDn. It was inconvenient to use, and was glad to switch to a ThinkPad that had real Home+End keys! > Google took some steps in this direction when they introduced Chromebooks in 2011. They removed the Caps Lock key, all the F1 to F12 keys, Home, End, Delete, Page Up/Down and the entire number pad. You can't seriously be approving the removal of F1 to F12 keys. Do you not use F2 to rename a file? F3 to find next? Alt+F4 to close a window? F5 to reload a webpage? F11 to full-screen the browser? F12 to open the web development pane? > Apple have removed some of the more peripheral keys, including Page Up/Down [...] Removing Caps Lock would be great but I find the Page Up/Down keys to be very useful Glad to see that you don't agree with the removal of PgUp/PgDn.
- Clubber 9y agoI agree. The closer a laptop keyboard is to a 101/104 layout (minus numeric keypad) the better. That's what made Thinkpad so great. I could switch from the desktop to the laptop without hesitation.
- exergy 9y agoI don't think the idea is the removal of the functionality, just the physical keys. Any half decent laptop will have home, end, page up and page down mapped to Fn+Arrows which to me is a smarter solution.
- mmozeiko 9y ago
- codefreakxff 9y agoI don't normally comment, but this author and I strongly disagree on the ideal keyboard on almost .every. .single. .point., in fact there is no need to enumerate them because I disagree with all of them. But, the most glaring problem is the idealized keyboard for a laptop being one with a 10 key area. When you sit down at a desktop you can position the external keyboard to center the G/H keys in the middle of your monitor and type comfortably. If you shift the G/H to the left it makes you move your arms to the left for 99.9999% of your typing - unless you still do 10-key data entry for some reason. The second overall problem I have is the idea that you need dozens of keys that are not essential to the function of your ability to TYPE on the laptop. Sure, you could have a button to disable the wireless on your laptop - but this is exactly the kind of key that SHOULDN'T be on a laptop. I have had to "fix" so many laptops by re-pressing the wireless toggle key that I have been tempted to physically break the key. I'm only ranting here just incase any keyboard designers think this article has any merit and tries to design a laptop-keyboard-from-hell like this. Just don't.
- Terretta 9y agoAlso if you mouse, a vestigial numeric keypad makes you reach much farther right. Pointless unless you’re a data entry clerk.
- slantyyz 9y ago>> Pointless unless you’re a data entry clerk. A lot of heavy Excel users would disagree. You might make the argument that using Excel is like being a data entry clerk, but having actually having had a job as a data entry clerk in the 80s, I can tell you it is not the same thing.
- skykooler 9y agoOr a Blender user.
- devwastaken 9y agohttps://youtu.be/doEZMNXz1JY https://youtu.be/doEZMNXz1JY Louis did a nice video on the older keyboard/trackpad vs the newer ones, which I agree with. Modern keyboards actually aren't bad, but the trackpads are terrible. The entire design of having left and right click as just one big flat button causes so many issues.
- nerdponx 9y agoI just want a non-Apple laptop that is as sturdy as an Apple laptop. Yes, I know they aren't impact-resistant, but those unibody aluminum cases last forever.
- slantyyz 9y agoI have an ASUS Zenbook UX501VW laptop, and the build/construction is very similar to my old 2011 15" MBP (unibody). My model has a numeric keypad (but no End key, wtf) but its successor for 2017 got rid of the numpad.
- nerdponx 9y agoLast time I checked these out (2014) they were pretty flimsy. Thin flexible plastic everywhere. I guess they got better?
- slantyyz 9y agoThe 2016 model that I have has an aluminum chassis and glass screen. It's pretty much like my 2011 unibody MBP except that it's a little wider (because of the numpad). AFAIK, the 2017 model is just less wide but same build.
- mnm1 9y agoA number pad on a laptop that sets the keyboard/trackpad off-center is inexcusable. Completely unergonomic. It's the manufacturer not giving a second thought to their product. It's the sign of a terrible laptop. At that point, what goes under the hood is irrelevant.
- chx 9y agoDo you mean http://blog.lenovo.com/en/blog/retro-thinkpad-its-alive/ http://blog.lenovo.com/en/blog/retro-thinkpad-its-alive/ the Retro ThinkPad? It's coming, I am waiting and if it sports the old seven row keyboard and Thunderbolt then I am buying and not asking the price. Do yo know why? Let's run some numbers! If I charge 130 USD / hr as a consultant (as consultants handle their own taxes as such, it's the equivalent of a 130K yearly which is not crazy high for a sr sw architect/developer) and this machine makes me 1 percent more effective than the second best then it's earning me 10 bucks a day. An 5000 dollar machine will earn itself back in two short years. And this is at 1% while I believe the difference to be much, much bigger. I am ready to invest but there's no product since the T420 family which would be worth investing in. It also gives us an idea of the lifespan of these machines: the T420 family is from 2011 and it's not like they are on their last legs six years later. Also, read the https://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=73419.0 https://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=73419.0 Matias Ergo Pro review on some interesting design decision that went into that particular keyboard. (And yes, it's the one I use vertically and can only recommend doing the same.) Interestingly enough, some gaming laptops are the ones that at least attempt to have a semi decent keyboard by using mechanical switches.
- cryptonector 9y agoWhat's the point? If you want a decent keyboard then you have to carry one. There's no way that using a laptop on your lap can be healthy for you (neck pain), while raising the laptop to improve the strain on your neck... can't help your hands. Anyways, that's what I do: travel with a compact wired keyboard. And that's my advice. As for differentiating laptops, lots of other things seem like better characteristics to compare: freedom, privacy (mechanical webcam and mic disable switches), mic quality, speaker quality, RAM, battery life, GPU, SSD vs. HDD, weight, ... One thing I hate is the bevelling on Macs: it actually hurts my fingers, but then again, I carry an external keyboard (and mouse) anyways, so this wouldn't stop me from buying a Mac.
- M2Ys4U 9y agoI completely disagree about having a number pad. I chose my laptop (in part) because it had a numpad. I also use a macbook at work and the lack of a numpad frustrates me.
- Theodores 9y agoIMHO high end Chromebooks now have the best keyboards. Typing this right now on a Chromebook Pixel (2013). My workmates have those Thinkpad keyboards with all of the extra features - mouse buttons, nipple thing and what seems like 1-2 extra rows of keys compared to the Chromebook layout. Again, 'IMHO', these keyboards are way too complicated and a bit old-fashioned looking. The cruft-free Chromebook keyboard is vastly superior. I also have low-end Chromebooks (just two of them) without the superb feel of the Pixel or the back-lighting. I don't type on these keyboards, instead I use 'Synergy' and a Logitech K810 portable keyboard: http://www.logitech.com/en-gb/product/bluetooth-illuminated-keyboard-k810?crid=27 http://www.logitech.com/en-gb/product/bluetooth-illuminated-... I carry the Logitech K810 everywhere, I would be lost without it. It also comes with a 'delete' key (as well as backspace), this omission of a 'delete' key is a mild deficiency of the Chromebook layout. I can remember the introduction of the special Windows keys that crept in between the CTRL, ALT and SPACE keys. At the time I thought these were a bit silly as you don't really need a choice of buttons to get to the Windows 'Start' menu. What I like about the Chromebook keyboard layout is that those silly keys have gone away. The aforementioned Logitech keyboard also trims down on the amount of useless Windows keys, they are still there, on the left, but not the right. If you are left-handed then the requirements get more interesting. I don't punch numbers in to the keypad with the dexterity of my friends in accounts, I wish I could but it isn't going to happen. Therefore those laptops with the number pad - or even full keyboards with the number pad - are just not for me, best avoided at all cost. Another benefit of the carry-along Logitech keyboard is that I can also use it with my phones. Rather than peck away at a message I can type eloquent messages with things like punctuation. For the day job I use a Lenovo Yoga consumer grade laptop instead of a Thinkpad. IMHO these keyboards - chicklet with backlight - are better than those legacy-style Thinkpad keyboards. I still use the portable Logitech keyboard with it though. This amuses my colleagues, I take them through some tutorial on something and there is this inevitable question about how come I use the same keyboard/mouse with so many screens/computers. My only feature request is that Logitech (or other) make their Bluetooth keyboards/mice work as USB keyboards when plugged in with a micro-USB lead, as happens for charging. This would enable me to get rid of my wired keyboard, the one I use after rebooting my desktop PC to log in and get 'synergy' started. As for Synergy, it is not entirely perfect as there are times when keys get 'stuck' in between the keypress down state and the keypress up. This is probably not a problem for most users however I have the repeat rate set to massively fast in order to move cursors around extra quick. https://symless.com/synergy#purchase-pro https://symless.com/synergy#purchase-pro
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoThe keyboard is how I chose my most recent laptop. My only requirement was non-multiplexed edit keys. It's incredibly hard to find this despite the abundance of space available on modern laptops. The only ones I could find were two Lenovo models. One of which is already discontinued.
- georgebarnett 9y agoI lost interest when the model M was described as ergonomic. It really isn't. For one, the keys are still diagonal which is an oddity from old typewriters and causes many issues. Another issue is the key placement on the IBM is traditional and causes much wrist strain. If you're going to compare ergonomic keyboards, at least get your shit together and start with abase mode that's actually ergonomic, such as a Kinesis Advantage.
- c3d 9y agoSome things are a metter of taste. That guy prefers wasting space for trackpad buttons, I largely prefer the MacBook Pro larger trackpad with tactile feedback. I also prefer monochrome keyboards. And just yesterday, I was marvelling at the sound I was getting from my laptop speakers. They are all but wasted keyboard space. The article seems to consider the author's personal preferences as facts.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yellowapple 9y agoIf laptop makers really want to differentiate, they can start by getting rid of 1366x768. It's fucking 2017; laptops really have no business shipping with anything less than 1920x1080. Also, the complaints about the numpad are certainly a matter of personal preference. I personally find a built-in numpad to be a significant plus when laptop-shopping.
- ValentineC 9y agoSpeaking of legacy tech, I wonder why some laptop manufacturers (System76, I'm looking at you) continue to ship with USB 2.0 ports.
- decasia 9y agoI suspect I am in the extreme minority here, but since I get wrist pain within minutes of typing on a regular laptop keyboard, I have just resigned myself to carrying around a portable Bluetooth ergonomic keyboard.[1] This sounds exceptionally nerdy but it is less of a nuisance than I had expected, my hands are much happier, and as a weird bonus, every day or two someone comes up to me in a coffeeshop and asks about "that really cool looking keyboard." The day that a laptop manufacturer figures out how to integrate this sort of gear into their product will be a good day... [1] fwiw after a bit of research I ended up with the one made by Goldtouch; http://www.goldtouch.com/ergonomic-keyboards/ http://www.goldtouch.com/ergonomic-keyboards/
- ScottBurson 9y agoSurprised that no one has pointed out the obvious factor driving the poorer keyboards: the drive to make laptops thinner and lighter. With less space to work with, laptop designers have to make compromises. The market has spoken. Thinness and lightness is more important than a good keyboard. (Still hanging on to my 6-year-old 17" MBP. I can see the point of something thinner and lighter, but it's just not my highest priority.)
- eecc 9y agoI gave up and bought a Filco (actually I have two, but that's because I'm an idiot) tenkeyless mehanical keyboard that I leave at my clients desk. I only use the MacBook one when I'm on the couch or working at a cafe and value the portability
- flatfilefan 9y agoI like the keyboard on the dell xps13, what i'd really want to know is why have they dropped Home,End,PgUp,PgDn buttons but left Print and Insert ones.
- roesel 9y agoHow about differentiating by making a laptop which doesn't sound like a helicopter taking off when 50 % or more of the CPU is used? Now that would be something.
- lukaszkups 9y agoThis keyboard (Drevo Gramr 84): https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/71fy58ykIaL.jpg https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/71fy58ykIaL... has the best key placement design of all time. Just take a look at most-right keys - home,del,page up/down, end they're all placed like to tap on them without using Your eyes easily. I'm just very disappointed that this layout is not so popular so I can't get very different new keycaps for it (have 2 of these keyboards already and started writing totally without looking after something like 3 weeks of using them) - I totally recommend these models, especially with brown switches
- Yizahi 9y agoIf anyone cared about keyboards they would first ditch stupid typewriter row shift. Also, as an observation, I work with a hundred of IT guys, none of them uses ergonomic keyboard or even with "kinda ergonomic", more classic shape. There is just no demand for good keyboards, at most people want "mechanical" KB, without any other improvements.
- Qub3d 9y agoMech + Colemak layout. More similar to QWERTY than Dvorak, but much more efficient.