25 ms·
> The problem was sticking to it when a clearly superior alternative emerged - reminds me of the "not invented here" problem. One of the issues here is that th
by masklinn 9y ago
> The problem was sticking to it when a clearly superior alternative emerged - reminds me of the "not invented here" problem.
One of the issues here is that the internet was not "a clearly superior alternative" as it had some aspects which were (and still are) significant downgrades.
Monetisation is a big one, Minitel had use-time payment very early on ("kiosk" services with a 4:2 split between the service and the network operator, with multiple price points) and in the early 90s added secure standardised CC payment (new models had a CC reader/terminal built in).
- danmaz74 9y agoWell, if you prefer, let's say "an alternative that was obviously going to win on the market". PS As a consumer I find it very hard to say that use-time payment is better than flat access cost + many different ways to pay depending on what you use.
- bigbugbag 9y agoIt was not obvious that internet was going to win the market, there were barely any home computers in France vs a few millions minitel, there were pretty much no commercial ISP but local non profit ISPs and the national phone operator was raking in huge profit from the minitel and had no incentive to upgrade its inadequate infrastructure.
- user5994461 9y agoYou seem to assume that the internet is flat fee, that is historically not the case. The internet was pay by the hour or pay by the kB for a very long time. The flat free subscriptions only emerged around the 00's.
- danmaz74 9y agoMy first internet connection was through a 28.8k modem, I know very well that it wasn't flat at the time, and that's exactly why I said that "pay per minute of use" is terrible for consumers compared to today's situation, while the OP said: "...as it had some aspects which were (and still are) significant downgrades. Monetisation is a big one, Minitel had use-time payment very early on"
- vertex-four 9y agoI'd say the Internet still doesn't have a very good monetisation system. Card payment is several times too much effort to use, takes a good couple of minutes, and isn't reasonable for a one-off service. PayPal and similar services are a mess, and not much better. The point wasn't that use-time is good, it's that there was monetisation integrated into the design of the system, and it was easy for the customer to use.