4 ms·
We've seen this article before: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=156177 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=156177 It was crap then and it's crap now. Karel
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
We've seen this article before: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=156177 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=156177
It was crap then and it's crap now. Karelis doesn't understand econ, but criticizes it because econ disagrees with his thought experiments and political leanings. His theory is nothing but traditional econ with a modified utility function. It has rather perverse implications (i.e., we should tax the poor but not the rich), and as the article notes it does not agree with experiment.
The best reason for completely ignoring Karelis: "ultimately, he believes, the strength of his arguments is less in how they fit with the economic work that's been done to date on poverty - much of which he is suspicious of anyway - but in how familiar they feel to all of us, rich or poor."
- powrtoch 16y agoAmen. Since when do we accept arguments just because they sound nice? Hasn't a whole lot of work gone into avoiding this black hole of rationality? Hey, maybe supposedly being able see Russia from her house really DOES give Ms. Palin foreign policy experience. If a theory sounds promising, then go gather some data. If it still looks good after careful scrutiny, then go write your book.
- anamax 16y ago> Hey, maybe supposedly being able see Russia from her house really DOES give Ms. Palin foreign policy experience. You do know that that's from SNL, not Palin. (Since you're suggesting, correctly, that one should go with data, it's curious that you used fiction as supporting evidence.) Border state governors do negotiate with neighboring countries, just as other governors negotiate with neighboring states. Alaska mostly deals with Canada, but there's some stuff with Russia for the Bering Strait. (Palin's house isn't near the strait so she can't see Russia from her house.)
- studer 16y agoYou do know that the SNL thing was a riff on something she actually said, right?
- guelo 16y agoActual quote, http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/Vote2008/Story?id=5782924&page=2 http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/Vote2008/Story?id=5782924&...: GIBSON: What insight into Russian actions, particularly in the last couple of weeks, does the proximity of the state give you? PALIN: They're our next door neighbors and you can actually see Russia from land here in Alaska, from an island in Alaska. GIBSON: What insight does that give you into what they're doing in Georgia? PALIN: Well, I'm giving you that perspective of how small our world is and how important it is that we work with our allies to keep good relation with all of these countries, especially Russia. We will not repeat a Cold War. We must have good relationship with our allies, pressuring, also, helping us to remind Russia that it's in their benefit, also, a mutually beneficial relationship for us all to be getting along.
- btilly 16y agoThis claim is true. http://www.slate.com/id/2200155 http://www.slate.com/id/2200155
- anamax 16y agoYup, and what she said was true. The riff, not so much. Governors do deal with neighboring countries and states. What part of that do you find scorn-worthy? Senators may be asked by the president to deal with other countries but have no formal role in foreign policy beyond voting on legislation and overseeing the state department.
- powrtoch 16y agoI concede the point. Though upon looking it up, she did make a similarly bogus statement. I watched her first big address and thought that I remembered this statement from it, but it looks like in fact Tina Fey was really that convincing.
- lotharbot 16y agoHer first big televised address -- the one that had the related statement -- actually had the middle of the statement edited out. The statement, as aired, was pretty bogus, but it makes a lot more sense when you read the whole transcript.
- ewjordan 16y agoKarelis doesn't understand econ, but criticizes it because econ disagrees with his thought experiments and political leanings. Sounds like a model economist to me - because of his political leanings, he doesn't like what the oversimplified toy models of the more mainstream theories tell him, so he invents another toy model with different oversimplifications, and claims that it's more fundamental. Surprise, surprise, it happens to reinforce his pre-existing beliefs! Isn't this the way the game is always played in the soft sciences, where we can't actually figure anything out for reals?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI say he doesn't understand econ, simply because he says "traditional economics doesn't apply" and then describes a theory which is traditional econ with a simple mathematical modification. Also, the theory of diminishing marginal utility has been tested empirically many times. While quite a lot of econ is the theory spinning you describe, DMU is pretty solid and accepted by economists of all political stripes (it's the primary argument for progressive taxation, among other things).
- jRoden 16y ago"In many cases, Karelis says, diminishing marginal utility certainly does apply:" Either way, I'd like to know why exactly he and the article are crap. I'm not completely sold on it myself, but you've really only managed to appeal to authority so far.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe main reason his theory is crap is it just doesn't agree with experiment. The article mentions several, all of which tend to encompass the income regime Karelis is presumably talking about. One example is the negative income tax experiment of the 70's, another is welfare to work. If Karelis has evidence of his theory, he should present it. But as it stands, he is pushing thought experiments and analogies, and telling us to ignore the empirical evidence when it disagrees with his theory.
- 16y ago
- loumf 16y agoI thought his main policy suggestion was just solving poor people's problems without strings attached (has the same effect and is cheaper to run with no bureaucracy).
- yummyfajitas 16y agoHis main theory is that poor people's utility function is flat. The policy implications are more nuanced than he says. We should do one of two things: 1.) give the poor so much money that they get into the region with an upward sloping utility function, assuming such a region exists. 2.) Tax the poor, since taking some of their money will not make them worse off (what's one more bee sting?). Mysteriously, he never mentions 2).
- archgoon 16y agoBecause 2 doesn't solve the problem the problem of poverty. I don't find that particularly mysterious or dishonest.
- CountSessine 16y ago1.) The Bee Sting model doesn't imply that the poor have a completely flat utility function - just a huge drop-off at some point and then a gradually decreasing plateau from there on. Indeed, the poor do seek to improve their utility functions - with booze and drugs and short-term gratification - in ways that would never allow them to overcome that seemingly insurmountable drop-off. The initial drop-off is the chief characteristic of the Bee Sting model. 2.) Utility functions are mathematical tools, and our interpretations of and use for them don't exist in a moral vacuum. Why should tax policy seek to minimize it's effect on our utility functions at all? Why not take $40000 from Warren Buffet AND the primary school teacher? Local movement on one's utility function is important, but so is absolute position, with all of the attendant moral implications.
- yummyfajitas 16y ago1.) If the utility function of the poor wasn't flat, they would make some effort to cure a few bee stings. 2) Tax policy should minimize impact on our utility because the goal is (in principle) to harm people as little as possible. This is why we consider it fair to take $1 million from Buffet but nothing from a poor person - the loss of $1 million will harm Buffet less than the loss of $50 would hurt a poor person. If Karelis is right, taking $50 from a poor person won't hurt them at all - what's one more bee sting?