3 ms·
>> We can't reproduce those events, But they can be reproduced, it's just that nobody wants to reproduce toxic contamination or something similar. In any case,
by yorwba 9y ago
>> We can't reproduce those events,
But they can be reproduced, it's just that nobody wants to reproduce toxic contamination or something similar. In any case, whenever a new contamination event happens, it should be possible to reproduce all the methods applied in the paper, so long as the situations are sufficiently similar.
- thatcat 9y agoHow will a scientist reproduce a study when the original study is not public?
- yorwba 9y agoI thought the argument was that the research could not be reproduced because the studies were about one-time events that could not be repeated, not because they were simply not publicly available. If the latter case is true, then I support disallowing these studies for policy decisions, since how can you use something for support if others can't even look at it to verify that it says what you say it does?
- thatcat 9y agoYou cant look at it because "its not repeatable" and therefore not publically available so cannot be repeated indefinitely. Seems like a political levee to hold back the sea of environmental data.