4 ms·
So, first, I'm no expert in this (and defer to rbehrends's excellent comments in this thread). The law seems to have problematic parts, as mentioned in the arti
by FabHK 9y ago
So, first, I'm no expert in this (and defer to rbehrends's excellent comments in this thread). The law seems to have problematic parts, as mentioned in the article: "the statute gives companies incentives to remove content, and it lacks a procedure for users to appeal removals."
Yet, the issue is not clear cut. There are legitimate limitations on free speech - the famous "screaming fire in a crowded theatre" thing.
So, in Germany (with a history of institutionalised genocide), the lines are drawn a bit differently.
The notion that the ruling party will use it against views they don't like seems far fetched, though again, I grant you that it's a slippery slope - Principiis obsta ("resist the beginnings").
But, I object to the notion that freedom of political speech is fundamentally under attack here.
[As for the Abrahamic texts, there is case to be made that they ought to be banned, though I grant that that wouldn't help much. As for your "reductio ad absurdum" (tabs/spaces): again, there's unproblematic speech, and there's legitimately prohibited speech, and then there's a grey area, and that's what we're discussing here - where in the grey to draw the line.]
- olegkikin 9y agoIt's just amazing that you can talk about banning the religious texts and at the same time claim the speech is not under attack. That's some olympic-level mental gymnastics.
- FabHK 9y agoI am saying that this law discussed in the article constitutes no attack on free speech. By implication, hypothetical stricter laws might be defensible, even. Next, the Abrahamic texts do contain truly awful prescriptions (genocide, killing people for all sorts of silly reasons, such as blasphemy, apostasy, homosexuality, eating the wrong food, etc.), which one ought to argue against vigorously, and which could be illegal under (hypothetical, stricter) laws (insofar, for example, as quoting specific sections could be understood as a 'call for action' to murder people). I don't see the mental gymnastics there?
- didgeoridoo 9y agoThe "fire in a crowded theater" standard is considered a legal joke these days. It has been superseded since the 1960s by FAR more stringent tests on speech limits. Expunge this saying from your vocabulary — it has zero relevance in modern case law.
- FabHK 9y agoGood to know. (As I said, I am no expert here, but (as I know from other areas) that does not prevent people from having an opinion...) Do I understand you correctly in saying "more stringent tests" that more types of speech (beyond that) are considered off limits today?
- didgeoridoo 9y agoPrecisely the opposite. "More stringent tests" mean that any law that tries to limit speech must pass an exceedingly high bar — higher than ever before. The "clear and present danger" test used by Oliver Wendell Holmes in his "crowded theater" opinion basically says that any speech that could cause dangerous effects could be outlawed. Modern 1st Amendment jurisprudence, by contrast, has evolved toward the "fighting words" standard, which basically limits restrictions on speech to outlawing "true threats"; e.g. me saying I'm going to kill you.
- rdtsc 9y agoOh that's interesting. First time I heard about. I keep always hearing about "fire in a crowded theater" in "free speech" arguments and discussion. So what's the new thing then?
- petre 9y agoInstitutional genocide was enabled by the Reichstag Fire and by the restrictions on free speech that followed.