4 ms·
I wouldn't be so quick to make that translation. I think a more useful way to think about it is "Know your users, and your channel." There are some user popul
by nostrademons 9y ago
I wouldn't be so quick to make that translation.
I think a more useful way to think about it is "Know your users, and your channel." There are some user populations - and developers are usually one of them - that are virulently anti-advertising. Any paid channel usually earns instant distrust from them. Putting money into marketing spending can have a negative ROI for them, because it has a signaling effect on the brand that says "Our product quality isn't good enough for us to get users without paying for them."
Then there are other user populations - most e-commerce is like this - where there is no such signaling effect, and they are happy to check out new products, regardless of how they hear about the product. For these markets, it's silly to ignore paid channels; you're just leaving money on the table.
- davidivadavid 9y agoThey're anti-advertising on paper. Are you telling me no one's ever run a successful ad campaign targeted at developers? I don't believe that for a minute.
- nostrademons 9y agoI wouldn't go so far as "never", but historically, developer tools with lasting growth tend to spread via word of mouth & community recommendations rather than ad campaigns. See eg. Ruby/Rails, Python and supporting ecosystem, JQuery, Node.js, Express, Postgres, Vue.js, GitHub before they took VC, Parse before they were acquired by Facebook, etc. Even Google - they had distribution deals starting early on, but they were very reluctant to spend money on advertising up until about 2010 (I remember watching the first Google SuperBowl commercials at TGIF, and hearing a lot of questions about why were spending money on advertising and what it meant for organic growth). When ad campaigns are run, they usually work by targeting programmers' bosses, encouraging the organization to purchase & standardize on one solution and then forcing developers to adopt it via management fiat. That's the route taken by Java, MongoDB, Oracle, .NET, many of the companies in the Hadoop ecosystem, etc. It certainly works - these are big companies - but it requires a consultative enterprise sales team that can work to get the solution deployed across the whole enterprise. The author obviously doesn't have the resources for that. The middle ground, where you provide a developer tool with $100-200/year CLTV and hope to get it distributed via paid advertising, is a very difficult place to occupy. That's the area occupied by FogBugz and RethinkDB and Sandstorm and many analytics providers. Most of them go the community-building route, and it's still very difficult. Only company I can think of that's thrived here is GitHub, and they went the word-of-mouth, community-building route first. Companies like Jetbrains, Atlassian, Rational, etc. thrive as well, but they've got large enterprise sales teams that standardize a whole organization on their products.
- davidivadavid 9y agoBut you're looking at a very narrow set of products used by developers. What about, say, Aeron chairs?
- nostrademons 9y agoSold to the boss, not the developer. The best devs I know actually get very suspicious when they see a startup full of Aerons, because it means that management is more focused on appearances than frugality. They look for chairs that are comfy but cheap, like something you'd get used off Craigslist, or if you do have Aerons, they'd like to hear that you picked them up from a bankruptcy auction of another startup.
- quickthrower 9y agoOr maybe it's like a profitable established company with Aerons.
- davidivadavid 9y agoThat was just an example. Besides, I'm not sure what you can infer about developers from the beliefs of the "best devs", considering they're only a fraction of the whole. The point is that developers don't just buy software. They're marketed stuff constantly, like everybody else. To suggest they're immune to it seems a little naive to me.
- losteric 9y agoWhat about them? I just learned they exist, from you. Do they have a history of running ads targeting developers? Why is a chair worth $500?
- billmalarky 9y ago>Why is a chair worth $500? Same reason a good mattress is worth $1k+. You spend a lot of time in it, and quality product greatly increases your quality of life (back pain etc). Note: I have no idea if Aeron chairs are good or not.
- sturgill 9y agoI think Apple's paid marketing efforts are a counter example to your argument. Ineffective advertising is ineffective. As a tautology this statement is pretty unremarkable. I first found out about ipinfo from a Google search looking to solve this problem. Haven't pulled the trigger on using it, but it's been on the back of my mind for awhile now. For me, their marketing happened to be their placement on Google. I don't really know how you'd pursue paid channels on this one (outside of SEM and SEO). It's a solution to a known problem. Unlike, say, the Apple Watch which has to first convince you have a problem... (This coming from a guy who's very interested in buying a watch as I train for a marathon.)
- nostrademons 9y agoFor developer tools? Apple certainly spends a ton on brand advertising for consumers, but most developers I know develop for Apple because they want to reach Apple consumers. (I spend a year doing smartwatch apps before giving up on the platform...the only reason I was developing for Apple Watch is because that's where the users were.)
- sturgill 9y agoAs a single example that immediately came to mind: WWDC. If that isn't a massive marketing channel directly targeted at developers I don't know what is.