3 ms·
Very interesting take on the problem. While everyone is clamoring for goal-line refs or technical solutions, he proposes changing the rules somehow to enable m
by SkyMarshal 16y ago
Very interesting take on the problem. While everyone is clamoring for goal-line refs or technical solutions, he proposes changing the rules somehow to enable more scoring, which would reduce the consequences of wrongfully allowed or disallowed goals.
I've always wondered what the game would be like if you simplified it even more and removed goal keepers, so that no player on the field could touch the ball with their hands. Replace goalies with another defender, or not.
That would likely open up scoring, as long-range shots would have a realistic chance to score, and short-range shots would be almost guaranteed if they were on-goal.
I'm sure there would be cons as well, but can't think what they might be.
Edit: One con would be more breaks in play, though they could probably mitigate that by allowing the scored-on team to restart with a quick goal-kick instead of a center kick-off. Center kick-offs often end up pushed back to the defensive line anyway, to open up the other team.
- barrkel 16y agoRemoving goalkeepers wouldn't have the kind of effect you think it would, I feel. I can see two possible dynamics: * The game would turn into a boring series of attempted long-distance lobs. You'd probably have to reduce the goal size significantly to prevent scoring from anywhere on the pitch. * Teams with very good defenses actually have goalkeepers that don't see a lot of action. This change would promote even stronger defense, with a more negative outlook, and still result in low-scoring games - possibly even lower scoring than is currently the case. The goalkeeper is key to what gives back-line players the confidence and permission to move forward and help with attacks.
- GFischer 16y agoThere are already casual variants with no goalie. This variant is called "Richard" over here, it's played on a 5-football field(1), and you can't shoot from after the midfield (otherwise it would be far too easy). The thing is, it's far less skill-challenging than having to beat a goalie. If you've never played football/soccer, you can't know the thrill of having just that one chance (unless you're a striker), the frustration of missing it (more often than not), and the pure bliss of making it. As a defender (most of the time) I'd say that football is more frustrating if you're a defender or goalie than as a forward, since you get so few chances to show off (and strikers are the heroes more often than not). As an example, the best player on the field for Uruguay's win over Korea was defensive midfielder Diego Pérez, but the most lauded player is striker Luis Suárez (which made two goals with a huge level of difficulty to be fair), since goals are so hard to come by. (1): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five-a-side_football http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five-a-side_football
- sandipagr 16y agocan't believe people are suggesting to change how the world's most popular and most watched game is played
- eru 16y agoI am OK with experiments---or how do you think people came up with football in the first place? Just make sure you fork the game, instead of changing the original.
- sandipagr 16y agotrue but that applies more when you are starting off, no? I mean minor changes are understandable but suggestions like not having a goal keeper, goalkeeper not using hands are well..
- eru 16y ago> true but that applies more when you are starting off, no? Maybe. But I am uncomfortable with an argument, that could just as well have been used in favour of, say, Microsoft sticking to Windows 95. It was the most popular operating system in its time after all.