2 ms·
It is credited amongst Austrian economists That is clearly uncharacteristic of the Austrian school. I never heard of an Austrian economist saying that's the re
by kiba 16y ago
It is credited amongst Austrian economists
That is clearly uncharacteristic of the Austrian school. I never heard of an Austrian economist saying that's the reason we got out of the depression. I have heard the Austrians arguing just the opposite.
You will need to produce your claim that Austrian economists believe it to be so.
Beside, nobody can detect sarcasm on the internet. There's no body language to detect.
Addendum: Argument from authority is what you're arguing for getting out of the depression? The Keynesian and Austrians believe that World War 2 got us out of the depression therefore it is true is what you're arguing. That's unconvincing.
- yequalsx 16y agoYou do not understand the fallacy of argument from authority. I did not engage in this. If you think what I did was an example of the fallacy of argument from authority then you must think that people who insist that the person who performs their heart surgery be a heart surgeon are also engaging in this fallacy.
- kiba 16y agoYou do not understand the fallacy of argument from authority. I did not engage in this. Mere assertions is not going help you there. You have to explain why I am wrong.
- yequalsx 16y agoFor someone who made statements like this: "Spending money on education is all well and good, but what about the dead GIs that we can't bring back to life? How many Einsteins, Teslas, and Neumanns die in that war anyway? We probably lost some of them in that war." and "Heard of the broken window fallacy?" it's a bit too much to read this latest statement from you. A number of your statements on WWII were not relevant to my comments. You also made a number of unsubstantiated assertions. Also, the third sentence in my previous remark addresses your present question. I believe a review of logical fallacies would be beneficial to you.
- kiba 16y agoI merely point out the opportunity cost of lost human capitals due to wars. I also pointed out the rationing and economic hardship of civilians at home. Don't tell me that you don't think a dead soldier is not a capital loss. Don't tell me that economic scarcity in time of wars is economic prosperity.