6 ms·
Is the Universe Made of Math?
- kazinator 9y agoI firmly believe it. No evidence contradicts it and it is the simplest possible explanation for everything: no hidden variables.
- pron 9y agoA map may be detailed enough not to leave out any detail, but the simplest explanation for that still wouldn't be that the map is the territory.
- akvadrako 9y agoThat's circular logic. Under the mathematical universe hypotheses, a map, being isomorphic to the territory, would be equivalent.
- pron 9y agoRight, but the claim that mathematical isomorphism is the same thing as physical equivalence is a non-obvious claim at all.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoThe original claim is circular. Physics may be mathematical, but that doesn't mean you can start from the Big Bang and use mathematical physics to predict the contents of this particular thread on Hacker News. So you immediately have the problem that mathematical physics cannot possibly be a complete description of the universe. Of course you can argue that we simply don't know the math yet, and if we did we'd be able to start from the primordial singularity and predict the existence of Max Tegmark, Y Combinator, and me and you. But that's a very strong claim, and I'm not aware of any evidence that comes close to supporting it. Even if you make a much looser claim - that mathematical physics can predict classes of phenomena like Max Tegmark, etc - there's still no math around at the moment that even begins to pretend it can formally prove that assertion. Worse - strong claims about mathematical provability immediately fall apart because of Godel. How can you have an abstract formal system running the universe if that system can't possibly be complete, provable, and formally consistent in its own terms?
- akvadrako 9y agoWhich has nothing to do with my point, which was that the grandparent was assuming the MUH wasn't true as evidence that it isn't.
- pron 9y agoI didn't assume it is not true nor claimed it is not true, simply pointed out that it is not obviously justified as the simplest explanation to the fact that that math can explain the universe.
- posterboy 9y ago> Worse - strong claims about mathematical provability immediately fall apart because of Godel incompleteness means true but unprovable propositions in specific forms of higher order logic, but Kurt also proved the completeness of first order logic. However, the scheme of induction used to lower peano arithmetic to first order logic (Presburger Arithmetic e.g.). Likewise, an incomplete higher order logic can (ostensibly - I couldn't) be proved in a logic of even higher degree, which is again incomplete, so again that's an argument ad infinitum. Obviously that's abstract nonsense, but the question shouldn't be whether the universe can be predicted up to infinity. The question at face value is rather, whether quantitative analysis can solve any given qualitative problem. It's the syntax semantics duality - what comes first?
- pron 9y agoFor someone who's on a first-name basis with Gödel, you should review your logic. The incompleteness theorems hold for any formal system whatsoever, regardless of order. They are simple corrolaries of the halting theorem. First order logic is indeed complete in the following sense: A sentence of FOL is provable iff it's valid, i.e. true in all interpretations. But according to the incompleteness theorem, logical theories (sets of axioms) of a certain richness would always yield sentences that are true in some interpretations and false in others, or, alternatively, that are neither provable nor disprovable (and first-order Pano arithmetics and obviously all formal set theories are among them). Order and other particulars of a formal system are irrelevant, and indeed Gödel was only fully satisfied with his incompleteness theorems after he read Turing's famous paper on computability, and regarded it a "miracle" (as it applies to any formal system, and depends on none). Obviously, many quantitative problems are unsolvable as a direct result of the halting theorem, and more generally the time-hierarchy theorem (which states that there are problems of any arbitrary difficulty), as many decidable problems are still unsolvable due to intractibility.
- rocqua 9y agoA map that leaves out no details is, by definition, equivalent or 'isomorphic' to the territory. Equivalence is a weird concept though. Is the factor group O(3)/SO(3) equivalent to Z/2Z? As a group, the answer is yes. As transformations of R^3, most definitely not.
- Retra 9y agoA map can have details left out of it, while a territory cannot.
- kazinator 9y agoDifferent maps with different levels of detail can all be separate universes.
- pron 9y agoNo definition could equate mathematical isomorphism with physical equivalence. That is part of the philosophical claim of the monist Platonist.
- kazinator 9y agoIf a map is not the same as the territory, then it's just another territory. Tegmark doesn't postulate that there is just one universe, remember.
- sgt101 9y agoThis is a matter of belief then? Interestingly the philosophy of preferring simplicity came from the need to characterize the holy trinity ! As a small thing that lives on a small planet that orbits a small star in no particular place at no particular time what imagination makes you think that things won't be hidden from you?
- kazinator 9y agoI, ahem, believe so because: - If you have no access to other universes, how can you design an experiment which positively confirms their existence? - The situation without hidden variables is indistinguishable experimentally with a situation that does have hidden variables. The latter is precisely why we can make a virtual machine which makes the kernel believe that it's running in a PC chassis with an Intel EEPro 100 ethernet card. In fact, based on Tegmark's hypothesis, I have to suspect that even the universe I'm apparently in doesn't just exist stand-alone; it's also embedded/contained an infinite number of times in more complex universes (which virtualize so perfectly, that there is no way to tell). One of those universes is the simplest one, not embedded in anything; for all intents and purposes, we can proceed as if we are in that one.
- kansface 9y agoOccam's Razor does not apply here.
- kazinator 9y agoIt applies in the sense that an explanation that doesn't postulate hidden variables is simpler than one which does. The razor cleaves away the hidden variables.
- lisa_henderson 9y agoThis is fundamentally a religious question. There is nothing wrong with religion, but you should be aware when you step into the realm of religion. Whether you think the universe is made of math, or God's will, or it's turtles all the way down, the presumption contains an element of Faith.
- pron 9y agoPhilosphical, certainly, but why religious? Not all faith is religious. There are many definitions of religion[1], but, AFAIK, none equate unprovable philosophical beliefs with religion. Normally, a religion requires at least some moral or normative elements (i.e., it should relate in some way to how humans behave or should behave), which this philosophy lacks. I've read that the author may have some opinions regarding AI that may be considered religious, but this particular subject so far seems purely philosophical to me. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Definition_of_religion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Definition_of_religion
- akvadrako 9y agoWell, it's even stronger than most religions in specifying how humans will behave, which of course includes should. That's because a mathematical universe is deterministic and more so, that anything mathematically possible (self-consistent and so forth) will happen infinite times. I consider it perfectly justifiable to call it physics, but at this level of abstraction, it's hard to differentiate it from religion too.
- JadeNB 9y ago> Well, it's even stronger than most religions in specifying how humans will behave, which of course includes should. I think that the 'of course' here is not at all obvious. Economics, for example, seeks to describe how people will behave, but neither makes nor, I think, is perceived to offer any description of how they should behave (at least not in any moral sense).
- 9y ago
- pron 9y agoThe philosophy of mathematics[1] is a deep and interesting subject, with a long history of important contributions by people like Hilbert, Brouwer, Russel, Wittgenstein, Turing, Quine and Putnam among others. It's very hard to tell from this short piece whether the author simply subscribes to one of the famous old positions or makes any new claims, and if so, where those claims are positioned relative to all the old ones. EDIT: A quick read of the relevant Wikipedia entry shows that Tegmark's view is basically good-old mathematical Platonism, with a radical, monistic twist. EDIT2: A question I would pose to a mathematical Platonist monist like Tegmark would then be, what is the cardinality of the collection of universes? Brouwer could reject large infinities only because he insisted that mathematics is limited by the physical, but if the physical and the mathematical are the same, I can see no justification for rejecting a large set of universes. [1]: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/philosophy-mathematics/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/philosophy-mathematics/ [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_universe_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_universe_hypothes...
- tpeo 9y ago>[...] that our reality isn't just described by mathematics – it is mathematics, in a very specific sense. Not just aspects of it, but all of it, including you. Cue to Whitehead's "a series of footnotes to Plato" quip. Though I think he was a bit off the mark. People aren't merely talking about Plato, but unwittingly echoing him. It's kind of like that another quote, this time from Keynes, about practical men being "slaves" to the opinions of long dead economists.
- rini17 9y agoCan we conceive of universe NOT made of math? Even in Harry Potter there's aritmancy...
- JadeNB 9y ago> Can we conceive of universe NOT made of math? Even in Harry Potter there's aritmancy... But there is a difference between a universe in which math exists, and a universe that is made of math; and the latter is, I think, a much stronger requirement. (Unless, indeed, every conceivable universe is made of math, in which case the requirements have exactly the same strength. :-) )
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoI don't think we can, but that may be because we're in a universe with math.
- imploder 9y agoNo. Math is made of the universe.
- JadeNB 9y ago> No. Math is made of the universe. Given that math can easily describe conditions that aren't realised in any obvious way in our universe, this seems like a proposition for whose meaningfulness it would be hard to argue. (Granted, the math we do is realised in the universe, but of course "the map is not the terrain".)
- waiseristy 9y agoIf you have yet to read Tegmarks book, I highly recommend it. It has a very layperson style of writing
- rocqua 9y agoIf there is such a thing as an external reality, is there even such a thing as 'meaning' that arises from anything other than relationships to other things? The only way to describe the human experience outside of the human experience is by describing all interactions and relations between the constituent parts. That ignores the issue of how useful this description is. It is easy to conceive of an external mathematical reality that cannot be fully described from within. Even with a full description, there is no guarantee the description is at all useful. If you consider how stumped we are by the goldbach conjecture, and how simple that is, you realize there are plenty of mathematical structures that defy understanding. And then there are the standard crises of maths. Incomputable problems, paradoxes in informal systems, controversial axioms in formal systems (axiom of choice), and that final bombshell of Godel's incompleteness theorem. All of these make math seem less rock-solid. Heck, if the universe is maths, we can't prove the universe is consistent from within the universe.
- sgt101 9y agoYeah, you need a ladder or something to climb up or pull up and then you will see things right. Or something.
- faragon 9y agoCan't wait for someone claiming the universe is made of Rust (the programming language), and how much better is than being made of C.
- demonshalo 9y agoThat all came about because Java/Swing sucks!
- kpil 9y agoHey! Java/Swing is one of the most respected platforms for running universe-type applications!
- nostrademons 9y agoElon Musk's efforts to break us out of the simulation [1] will be much harder if he can't find a suitable buffer overflow to exploit. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/janetwburns/2016/10/13/elon-musk-and-friends-are-spending-millions-to-break-out-of-the-matrix/#d7d13035ce17 https://www.forbes.com/sites/janetwburns/2016/10/13/elon-mus...
- rhapsodic 9y ago> Elon Musk's efforts to break us out of the simulation [1] will be much harder if he can't find a suitable buffer overflow to exploit It's astounding that someone as obviously intelligent as Musk believes in creationism.
- criddell 9y agoIf I have a big, fast computer and I simulate a universe by randomly defining a set of rules and then hit "go" over-and-over-and-over again, if life arises in one of them is that creationism? Isn't it more correct to say I am exploring the space of all possible universes to see which ones generate life?
- 9y ago
- sunstone 9y agoThe universe is made of information.
- twelvechairs 9y agoMy view is that the root of this is the quote 'All models are wrong but some are useful'. I dont think youll get something which descries the universe completely which is less complex than the universe itself. However maths can certainly describe parts of the universe more simply (but not completely).
- TelmoMenezes 9y agoThe question here is wether math is just a description or the thing itself, independently of the complexity.
- oldandtired 9y agoIt is funny to see this article today. Overnight, I was considering the question again of "Is the map the territory or not?" JadeNB refers to this in their comment. What a lot of people do not see, including many theoretical physicists is that mathematics is a "map". It describes reality in a simplistic way, but is not the reality itself. twlevechairs26 refers to the quote "All models are wrong but some are useful". This highlights the fact that all models are maps, incomplete, simplified descriptions that leave out specific parts or include things that are not part of the thing being described. When we get arrogant enough to claim the "truth" in mathematics or science we have moved into the realm of religion. Mathematics and science helps us get a handle on trying to understand the physical universe around us. But it will NEVER, and I repeat this, NEVER give us perfect understanding of the universe around us. For that perfect understanding would require that we become greater than the universe around (in effect raising ourselves by our bootstraps to be God or gods). So, in may ways, the first question here, "Is the map the territory or not?" before asking "Is the Universe made of mathematics?"
- jackmott 9y ago>But it will NEVER, and I repeat this, NEVER give us perfect understanding of the universe around us. How can you be sure? >or that perfect understanding would require that we become greater than the universe around (in effect raising ourselves by our bootstraps to be God or gods). shrug
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wcoenen 9y agoIf you are intrigued by this flavor of modal realism then the sci-fi book "Permutation City" might be a good read.
- posterboy 9y ago> In 2050, Paul Durham, a Sydney man having experimented on Copies of himself, offers wealthy Copies prime real estate in an advanced supercomputer which, according to his pitch, will never be shut down and never experience any slowdown whatsoever. Durham predicts that efforts to utilise chaotic effects will clash with Copy rights. > Copy rights is that a pune?
- ravenouswolves6 9y agoSkip the book (and the article), read the original paper: https://arxiv.org/pdf/0704.0646.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/0704.0646.pdf IMO, Tegmark has a solid argument that the MUH is more plausible than any of the other suggested possibilities (https://www.amazon.com/Why-Does-World-Exist-Existential/dp/0871403595 https://www.amazon.com/Why-Does-World-Exist-Existential/dp/0... is good for the PEQ and much more worth reading than Tegmark's book).