3 ms·
Our fear of short term pain might be the worst part of the modern political system. When people realize that they can vote themselves more money, they will. Go
by kiba 16y ago
Our fear of short term pain might be the worst part of the modern political system.
When people realize that they can vote themselves more money, they will. Government will then promise more than it can deliver and proceed to spend money like no tomorrow just like what happens to Greece and California.
But it's heresy to suggest that democratic institutions should be scrapped altogether. Everyone thinks democracy equal freedom, but it's really just majority rules.
- hga 16y agoWell, that gets into the question of "to whom to you extend the franchise to"? Cut that back (yes, I know, beyond hard), maybe limit it to a new class of Taxpayers, and things could change real fast. Of course the Social Justice types would be ... unhappy. Used to be in many states you had to own some land (one guy owned a doghouse sized plot of land to make a point) or pay a poll tax to vote. The latter's corruption by the Southern segregationists makes that right out for the time being, but ... well, republics tend to last only as long as they have the moral fiber to not vote themselves the treasury. We're obviously way beyond that point, but the game will run out at some point. And with so much of our debt in bonds (1 year or less maturity) is could have very quickly. Probably would already be happening if not for the Eurozone crisis.
- gaius 16y agoThis is exactly what happened in the UK under New Labour. However now it seems the voters have come to their senses.
- hnal943 16y agoWhen people realize that they can vote themselves more money, they will. I would agree had you said "When people think that they can vote themselves..." because who are they kidding? There is no "Obama Money." The government's money comes from the people, as the residents of Greece and California are discovering. I suppose you can vote yourself more money if you can vote and yet pay no taxes, which might be the true problem. Perhaps in order to have a say in the direction of the country, you need to have skin in the game. I don't think that chucking democracy is really the right reaction. I stand with Winston Churchill: "Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time."
- steamer25 16y agoPerhaps in order to have a say in the direction of the country, you need to have skin in the game. One of the original thoughts behind establishing a bi-cameral legislature was that only (real-estate) property holders could participate in the senate. The idea being to prevent the masses from voting the property to themselves. Eventually, it was settled to give the senate to those who were competent enough to organize themselves into local governments/states. Still, it would be interesting to have a house where one man == one vote and a senate where one dollar == one vote. I'm not sure human nature would allow the government to be primarily funded by power-mongering but it'd be a fun experiment to try.