4 ms·
> I'd really like to sincerely ask if you've had a run-in with it yet. reply Yes, I've met many people with borderline personality disorder. I helped the Engl
by DanBC 9y ago
> I'd really like to sincerely ask if you've had a run-in with it yet.
reply
Yes, I've met many people with borderline personality disorder.
I helped the English NHS create their KUF (Knowledge and Understanding Framework) for borderline personality disorder; I campaign for services to better meet the needs of people with BPD.
What you're saying is ignorant bollocks.
False accusations are not more common among people with BPD, and false accusations are rare.
- xor1 9y ago>Yes, I've met many people with borderline personality disorder. How many of them do you know extremely well? As in you've spent time alone with them for hours or even days on end? Are you a mental health professional who has treated them as patients? You don't really know someone with borderline until you do either of these, IMO, no matter how much research or campaigning you do. >False accusations are not more common among people with BPD, and false accusations are rare. Have you done research into what it's like to go through a divorce with someone who has BPD? If you have, how can you post this with a straight face? Do you yourself have BPD?
- DanBC 9y agoI have lived with people with BPD. I work with people with BPD. I've spent time alone with people with BPD. You appear to have gone through a messy divorce, but that doesn't give you any information about a large (one to two percent) part of the population.
- xor1 9y agoIt wasn't a divorce.
- DanBC 9y agoI don't care. You're misusing diagnostic labels to malign a large group of people who face significant and harmful levels of stigma. You insist that your narrow experience is true of everyone with BDP; you don't frame your discussion as what happened to you but as what anyone else can expect from people with BDP.
- xor1 9y ago>You're misusing diagnostic labels to malign a large group of people who face significant and harmful levels of stigma. Are you going to explain why you think that stigma isn't deserved? Don't try to deflect with a comparison to racism or other bigotry. The havoc that BPDs wreak on others' is well documented, and I've personally lived through it. I really don't see how you can defend people with BPD and their actions without inadvertently defending pedophiles as well. But please do try.
- tptacek 9y agoWe are way off the cliff of inappropriate conversations when we're: * Attributing mental health conditions to hypothetical strangers * Insinuating other commenters on HN have mental health conditions * Impugning entire groups of people based on hypothetical mental health conditions. That's before we reach the fact that the only reason we're talking about this particular mental health condition was the hypothetical that strangers, who we know nothing about, would be reporting sexual harassment incidents falsely because they might be suffering from that condition. This is way past uncivil and inappropriate and we can't be having threads here that look like this, something I'm so sure of that I'll say so despite having no formal authority to do so.
- xor1 9y agoHi Thomas, Just want to begin by saying I have a lot of respect for you and Matasano. I think the fact that you think that it's inappropriate to discuss mental health at all is very telling of the main issue I have with all of this. Mental health shouldn't be taboo. I think people should be more open and willing to discuss their issues and any traits that they recognize in broad diagnostic criteria, and to seek treatment. Other first-world countries have a much better approach to mental health, and I don't see why there isn't a broader push in the United States to get to a similar point. I knew three engineers who committed suicide, and I think they could have been saved if our current society didn't shame people for seeking treatment. I know most of my past and former coworkers work through their problems with self-medication or escapism, because seeking treatment is unthinkable and a sign of weakness. I think it's wrong to just pretend like this hypothetical is impossible, and to follow a plan of action that doesn't account for bad actors and leaves their victims to fend for themselves. My main bone to pick with BPD is that people with good intentions, either knowingly or unknowingly, enable those who have it because they belong to a group that they seek to protect, and can use that status as a shield to defend their irrational and abhorrent behavior. I think this is extremely dangerous. The root of this discussion was about the burden of proof resting completely on the accused. I don't know if anyone can even see that anymore since most of my posts have been flagged. That is the only thing I have a problem with, though I admit that I segued way too far towards posting about BPD simply because I used it for my hypothetical. I think the vast majority of people who participate in modern society could benefit from therapy and mental health services, including myself. Surely some people have observed my posts in this thread, and think that I could benefit from therapy after having a traumatic experience with someone who had BPD. I'm inclined to agree, and I don't really have a good reason for why I haven't followed through. Talking about it online and spreading awareness definitely helps me.