4 ms·
Lack of good government regulation is what created the mess you are in, the real world isn't like some Ayn Rand novel.
by tonyedgecombe 9y ago
Lack of good government regulation is what created the mess you are in, the real world isn't like some Ayn Rand novel.
- humanrebar 9y ago"Good" government regulation is what created the mess. Patents on prescriptions. When loopholes can be applied or not to offer generics. Licensing and certifications. What counts as "health insurance". What kinds of medical practices can be opened. What drugs can be offered across state or national boundaries. Who gets discounts on health insurance (employers) and who doesn't (employees). The list goes on.
- pm90 9y agoThis is simply not true. What you seem to be suggesting is that we leave the healthcare market completely open to market forces. This would be a disaster of epic proportions because, realistically, not everyone can afford their own healthcare costs. This is why we have health insurance, and regulations exist to protect citizens against predatory practices. Some of these regulations are misguided, and others are a result of lobbying by special interests. Most of them are OK.
- humanrebar 9y ago> What you seem to be suggesting is that we leave the healthcare market completely open to market forces. I suggested nothing of the sort. I said our current regulation regime is harmful, however good the intentions were when it was passed. > This would be a disaster of epic proportions because, realistically, not everyone can afford their own healthcare costs. I also never said the impoverished should be left to die in the streets. The government clearly needs to help people afford things. But the current regulatory approach is both too heavy and too complex. > ...regulations exist to protect citizens against predatory practices. And they're clearly not working, no matter the intention when they were passed. > Most of them are OK. Like the ones that let pharma companies keep generic drugs off the market? Or the ones that heavily regulate drug releases but could not prevent the opioid epidemic? There should be regulations. There should be welfare. They should both be simple (anything else is not fair, especially for the consumer) and they should use markets to figure out what the price of things should be (anything else is still not fair and is subject to special interests).
- EdSharkey 9y agoThere is an implication in your message here: government can do no wrong. Or, at the very least, "this government is the best we got and I'm willing to sacrifice a lot to see my government does its good works." But I just made a 360° slam dunk of an argument that pops your best/good-works bubble: 7 providers, no competition, no market forces, wildly expensive care - all demonstrably because of bad laws and cronyism in government. Will you un-360° slam dunk my argument now, please?
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoThere is no such implication in my message.
- EdSharkey 9y agoNo? My bad. I thought we were 1-dimensionalizing one another like tribalists rather than having a rational argument. Perhaps you do have something to contribute? I shall give you the benefit of the doubt that you are a razor sharp intellect and a force to be reckoned with. Here's how I was able to get there in a split second. Perhaps, JUST PERHAPS, you can analyze yourself for similar flaws: "He tossed out Ayn Rand, probably never read her. Ugh, what a bore he must be at parties! So he's a progressive thinker. His weaknesses are a bias towards government, a lack of critical thinking, and a victim mentality. Can't do anything about the victimhood, he needs a shrink for that. Okay, attack his center by opposing his faith in government with the epic fail that is the rigged U.S. health care system." I know nothing about you and did no research, so the chances any of those assumptions were right are close to nil. That kind of wretched thinking about someone I don't know is not only unproductive, but psychologically harmful to me. (Which is why I try to avoid it.) But as you can see, it's easy for me to let my brat out of his cage. I think your problem is you assume you're right and you're indignant when someone challenges your beliefs to the point of being emotional about it. You don't feel the need to present an opposing argument with any detail, which is a shame since you probably have wisdom to share. (EDIT: oops, my brat is still off his leash...)
- tonyedgecombe 9y ago