2 ms·
> Why, in this day and age, is the US military organized along a structure (Army, Navy/Marines) based on the Elizabethan English military organization (I recogn
by jcranmer 9y ago
> Why, in this day and age, is the US military organized along a structure (Army, Navy/Marines) based on the Elizabethan English military organization (I recognize the USAF was spilt off to avoid a battle between Army and Navy)?
The USAF was actually split off largely due to the efforts of the bomber mafia to promulgate strategic bombing as a useful method of war. The problem is that strategic bombing doesn't work, and never has, which kind of blunts the purpose of the USAF except as providing largely tactical support for the Army and Marines (note that the Navy runs their own carrier planes, and the Army and Marines also have their own close air support wings).
It's also disingenuous to suggest that the US military is largely based on Elizabethan military terms. The entire concept of the staff system only dates back to roughly Napoleonic Wars (and is most associated with the effective Prussian military). But even beyond that, the US military is largely organized in operational terms under unified (cross-service) commands based on geographical theater, a system that originates in WWII and is pretty much unique to the US (although, to be fair, it's the only country that has the need to work under such a system; however, similar concepts like the Joint Chiefs of Staff don't seem to be particularly widespread in the world).
- gumby 9y agoYes, the French Levée and the Prussian general staff were modernizing shocks to the system, no question. But the idea of a separate Navy and Army really go back to a pre-Enlightenment period when the Navy was centrally financed by the crown (and piracy) while the armies were raised territorially. Hence the Navy has aircraft and ground troops while the army has aircraft and watercraft. and, of course turf. It's also a ridiculous abstraction when you try to build a single "cross-corps" aircraft (F35) and see each service claiming different service-specific requirements when really you do indeed have different mission requirements, some of which are common to multiple services. I certainly understand the value of incrementalism but I consider it absurd that Cromwell would recognize the structure of today's US military even though its missions would be practically inconceivable to him.