4 ms·
Are we really at the stage that a country declaring cyber war on my thermostat has a higher likelihood than my furnace breaking? I am not saying that your exam
by slg 9y ago
Are we really at the stage that a country declaring cyber war on my thermostat has a higher likelihood than my furnace breaking?
I am not saying that your example aren't possible. I am saying it is a game of odds. I have no reason to believe the odds of a catastrophic failure are increased by the introduction of a smart appliance to a greater extent than other catastrophic failures are decreased by said appliance.
- mahyarm 9y agoA smart thermostat can cycle a furnace on & off at high frequency and cause it to break down. Same with smart light controls. If there are specific models that burst into flames when you do this, then you can cause half a town to catch on fire at once. You could also hack all the smart thermostats at once and cause annoying brownouts due to crazy simultaneous demand happening all at once. You can also cause peaker plants to go on and off at an annoying unpredictable frequencies by making these spikes short. But to be honest, I doubt anyone will do this, since most vital infrastructure is relatively easy to sabotage and nobody has done it. A group of 100 organized assholes could do horrible damage to the US power grid today by going out to the middle of nowhere and blowing up a bunch of high voltage power transmission towers.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThe reason your dumb thermostat isn't a risk, but an Internet-connected one can be is that Internet attacks scale. It takes one random person anywhere with a single exploit to affect millions of devices simultaneously. And while people are pretty decent in general, there are always those individuals who would happily watch the world burn. You can base the security of your system on the assumption that people are generally OK, but you can't base it on assumption that every single person is nice. See also recent ransomware attacks - it's hard to believe this is something else that some individuals trying to piss off the planet (and make some money on the side). See also PoC of a Philips Hue attack (with added fun of it spreading through ZigBee mesh): https://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/11/10/iot_worm_can_hack_philips_hue_lightbulbs_spread_across_cities/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/11/10/iot_worm_can_hack_p.... If people do that for fun (er, for Science!) to smart lightbulbs, you can bet someone will do it to a smart thermostat.