8 ms·
House panel votes to split Air Force, create new U.S. Space Corps
- ddrum001 9y agoCurious how this would affect private ventures like SpaceX?
- blackguardx 9y agoIt probably means more money for the space industry and other government contractors, which includes SpaceX.
- pavement 9y agoUh... what?! The bill would order the Defense Department to establish the new corps by January 2019. It would be a distinct military service within the Department of the Air Force, in much the same way the Marine Corps operates as a service within the Department of the Navy. The Secretary of the Air Force would oversee both the Air Force and the Space Corps, but the new chief of staff of the Space Corps would be a new four-position, co-equal with the chief of staff of the Air Force. DoD would have to deliver reports to Congress in both March and August of next year on the details of how it plans to set up the new service. Wow. Out of fucking nowhere.
- benmowa 9y agoif i had to guess, i'd guess this is 'out of' lobbying by big govt contractors who want another budget pool, and MIL insiders pushing for this. Right now airforce satellites for star-wars type initiatives and airforce refueling tankers all fall under the same budget, while serving very different organizational needs. conversely this is why 'innovation' arms/skunkworks get created... because the mothership moves too slow and has too many competing priorities and budgets to innovate and get out of its own way.
- omegaworks 9y agoWelcome to the militarization of space.
- Analemma_ 9y agoThis seems weird and premature. We will probably need a "Space Corps" eventually, but doing it now when the technology is still in its infancy, instead of being able to leverage the manpower of an existing service, seems unhelpful. Making the Air Force its own thing, instead of part of the Army, was a good decision in 1945 but would've been dumb in 1912 too.
- gorkonsine 9y agoActually, I think they should go the opposite way: they should eliminate the Air Force, and make it part of the Army again. The AF was split off because of the Cold War, and is just a relic of that time. No other modern military force has a separate "air force", because having it separate only complicates things when conducting a conventional ground war. For a while the Air Force even thought they were going to make the Navy obsolete, because they wanted to rely on ICBMs and long-range bombers for everything.
- rjsw 9y agoMost modern military forces have a separate "air force", can you list which countries don't ?
- tomjakubowski 9y ago> No other modern military force has a separate "air force", because having it separate only complicates things when conducting a conventional ground war. Besides the US: Turkey, Syria, Russia, Israel all off the top of my head have air force and ground army (along with, at least, a navy) separate under one "Armed Forces" command. What modern air forces operate as part of the army, rather than separately (as most navies do)?
- smacktoward 9y agoThe big one is China, where all the services are technically branches within the People's Liberation Army: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/People's_Liberation_Army https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/People's_Liberation_Army
- boznz 9y agoSciFi usually base military in space based on the navy, I wonder if this was considered or even makes a difference?
- dhd415 9y agoI'm guessing that the sci-fi practice was due to the sociological similarities between spacecraft crews and ship crews on isolated, long-term voyages. At present, the US Air Force has been responsible for most high-tech concerns including cyber warfare and space warfare, so it probably was the least organizationally disruptive to bring the new branch in alongside the AF.
- vpribish 9y agoplug for project rho! They have some discussion of sci-fi military organization (and nine thousand other things, seriously, it's the TV Tropes of sci-fi) http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/military.php#id--Organization http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/military.php#id...
- yohui 9y agoStargate being a notable exception: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stargate_Program#Stargate_Command https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stargate_Program#Stargate_Comm... Which reflects how in real life the Air Force does have more to do with space than the Navy.
- walshemj 9y agoI always thought that SG being an air force show was unrealistic once the USN RN etc found out "wait there are real star ships" they would want to take over. Let alone the CIA / SAD / SIS wanting to run intelligence opps of world
- manav 9y agoUSAF actually consulted a lot on the show and later in the series I believe the Stargate operation becomes a joint international civilian-military effort.
- dmichulke 9y ago... because we have to defend the ehh hmmm satellites against cough ehm ehhh other satellites. Nothing like a fourth branch of the armed forces to increase the biggest military budget in the world [1] by another few dozen percent. [1] From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_... 1. US 611 bn 2. China 215 bn 3. Russia 69 bn
- codyb 9y agoAren't those all about the same as a percentage of gdp?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fweespeech 9y agoChina is ~2%. US is ~4% once off budget spending is accounted for. The actual is ~3%.
- MaulingMonkey 9y agoFrom the same table: 1. US 611 bn (3.3% of GDP) 2. China 215 bn (1.9% of GDP) 3. Russia 69 bn (5.3% of GDP)
- dmix 9y agoYou mean instead of giving the much need financing to the talent that already exists in the thousands of branches that already exist in the US government they are instead pushing for creating a whole new group of administrators who will oversee the 10-20% of the staff who are the actual nerds who output the real value the agency was originally designed to do? If recent history has taught us anything is that the real issue is those nerds need extensive micro-management and predefined processes designed by committee (/s), and given how most of those nerds are hired through 3rd party contractors these days for 5x the cost, you also need thousands of people to oversee and manage the extensive contracts used to hire them and push out the ever expanding list of project requirements and legal rules to these companies. It's a perfect recipe for success. Why else would it be repeatedly used? The fact administrators see the solution to every problem is hiring MORE administrators (who often just happen to be companies staffed by their old friends from school) it's really not that surprising that western governments around the world (not just the US) are consistently failing to accomplish the most basic government projects which were previously a dime-a-dozen at comparable rates of private markets before the explosion of the size of government in the 1950/60s and it became standard practice for everything to cost 10x as much and/or result in endless delays. It's what happens when administrators take over. Aka the Iron Rule of Bureaucracy. When any failures happen instead of firing these people or holding them responsible, we turn to them to solve the problem, which always turns out to mean either hiring more people just like them or throwing billions more into the same agencies/contracts: http://www.jerrypournelle.com/reports/jerryp/iron.html http://www.jerrypournelle.com/reports/jerryp/iron.html According to the current mainstream narrative only greedy fiscal conservatives who hate governments are the ones who take issue with this approach. So my critiques are largely just going to be pigeonholed into a controversial political ideology rather than being a blatantly obvious issue with modern government agencies across the western world. The existing systems need to be broken down, critiqued, and lessons should be actually learned. Just throwing more people/money/power at the problem doesn't help solve it. Unless your goal is merely resource extraction and maintaining the appearance of doing something rather than actually solving problems.
- Animats 9y agoSounds like somebody at USAF Space Command wants a promotion. This seems decades late. The USAF has no manned space capability. The U.S. Government once owned the Space Shuttles. They had astronauts. The USAF once had a Space School. That's all gone. Now, they just buy commercial rocket launches. If anything, the reorganization the USAF needs is to lose the close air support mission, and the A-10 Warthogs, to the Army. The USAF keeps trying to kill off the Warthog, and doesn't want to get involved with smaller fixed-wing aircraft for close air support. The Army needs that low-level aerial firepower. They need it from affordable aircraft they can use in quantity, not rare, overpriced F-35s. There's an old deal between the Army and the USAF, the "Key West Agreement", that the Army would stay out of fixed-wing aviation and only use helicopters. That needs to be looked at again. (The Marines have their own air, and it works out well for them. Marine air and ground forces tend to coordinate better than USAF/Army combos.)
- logfromblammo 9y agoThe organization of the US military really should be mission-based rather than some weird afoot-afloat-aloft separation. There's no particular reason why air superiority fighters, long range bombers, aerial refueling tankers, and airdrop cargo haulers should all be under the same command just because they all fly. Clearly, two of those are for logistics, and two are for force projection. I suspect that the existence of the military academies don't help in that respect.
- nostrademons 9y agoInteresting how this mirrors the debate in many corporations between functional organization (eng/sales/UX/marketing/accounting/HR) vs. product organization (Search/Ads/Chrome/Android/GMail/etc.) The military is organized functionally. Recently, basically every major company other than Apple has found that product organization yields better results, because each individual product can better respond to competitive threats in their market. Makes me wonder if the U.S. military is the next big institution to be "disrupted" by thousands of tiny startups, we just don't realize it because fortunately, everyone would rather have peace.
- musachenko 9y agoMilitarization of space notwithstanding, this could be great news for the spaceflight industry as a whole. A lot more contracts handed out for launches and orbital infrastructure, as well as "normalizing" space travel would encourage investment in an industry that has been mostly dominated (and still is) by government entities.
- gumby 9y agoWhy, in this day and age, is the US military organized along a structure (Army, Navy/Marines) based on the Elizabethan English military organization (I recognize the USAF was spilt off to avoid a battle between Army and Navy)? For that matter why are dress uniforms based on obsolete English gentlemen's dress? A bit of rethink based on objective/mission seems well overdue. The 1940s reorganization that lead to the Department of Defense papered over the structural problems.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Why, in this day and age, is the US military organized along a structure (Army, Navy/Marines) based on the Elizabethan English military organization (I recognize the USAF was spilt off to avoid a battle between Army and Navy)? Because you make incremental changes (and even then, only based a on clear need, nor rejecting old because it's old) to critical systems unless you have a clear, compelling need justifying a specific more-radical change. Ground-up replacement based on speculative improvement and theorized benefits is a common recipe for failure. It's a fairly basic idea in software, but it applies for other kinds of systems as well (in many cases moreso; you can build a ground-up replacement for software on parallel while maintaining the legacy system to mitigate risk and only cutover when the replacement is proven to work; you can't practically build a complete replacement national military in parallel.)
- dctoedt 9y ago> For that matter why are dress uniforms based on obsolete English gentlemen's dress? This is getting way off topic, but can you give an example? The Navy officer service-dress blue uniform is basically a business suit with gold-colored buttons and gold sleeve stripes; it's been pretty much the same for probably a century now. [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniforms_of_the_United_States_Navy#Dress_uniforms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniforms_of_the_United_States_...
- dragonwriter 9y agoI think the reference is to the Formal Dress and Dinner Dress Blue/White Jacket uniforms, not the less formal Dinner Dress Blue/White or service dress uniforms.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoThis is a fall in line bill. In my office on Capitol Hill that was our name for legislation that leadership has agreed to, is all ready to go, and there's little to argue that will go anywhere so...just fall in line. Interesting footnote to history: The Republican leadership, from 94 - 06, steamrolled over everyone with legislation. When the Democrats took over from 2006 - 2010, they turned the tides and began ramming bills through without giving much, if any, time to read and analyze. A Republican pledge after they won big in 2010 was to mandate posting of a bill to the web three days prior to debate on the Floor, and other "time to read" ideas. I guess we've come full circle to Republicans preventing Democrats from reading. I'm afraid to see what the Democrats do when they eventually take over; the cycle of things.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoOK, now I totally want to go to what ever academy they open up for this branch and officially become a Space Cadet! :-) More seriously, this isn't much different that the Army Air Corps becoming the Air Force, logistically it opens up a branch that can have strategies and priorities that are not constrained by its original branch (the original Air Corps was constantly arguing with the Army over what was more important, tanks or airplanes, for example). It also opens up a bunch of jokes for late night comedians like "Look, it is a new customer for the F35 Joint Strike Fighter, now its required to operate in a vacuum!"
- Macsenour 9y agoMeetings and sub-committee hearings on Space Command... but no time for the same on healthcare... Not trying to start a discussion, just noting the irony.
- bobwaycott 9y agoThere’s almost always time for the military in Congress.
- Turing_Machine 9y agoNational defense is a constitutionally mandated function of the federal government. "Healthcare" is not.
- neuronexmachina 9y agoLooks like the Senate is in disagreement with the House on this: https://www.govconwire.com/2017/06/despite-disagreement-house-moves-forward-on-creation-of-u-s-space-corps/ https://www.govconwire.com/2017/06/despite-disagreement-hous... > The Senate Armed Services Committee isn’t calling for a Space Force in its version of the NDAA; and is instead stressing the importance of cyber warfare and a more conservative approach to spending.