4 ms·
It depends on what the #1 usage of batteries will be. Utility scale battery usage don't really care about the specifications. We just need a lot of them, cheap
by dragontamer 9y ago
It depends on what the #1 usage of batteries will be.
Utility scale battery usage don't really care about the specifications. We just need a lot of them, cheaply. Shear size can make up for a lot of problems.
But Car batteries are highly sensitive to power, weight, cooling... issues that require innovation and improvement. Its unlikely for any US Car company to buy cheap batteries from China. They'll instead build batteries as a competitive advantage over each other.
---------
I can't help but think of China's "Great Leap Forward". They believe that Steel is the future, but for large swaths of the country... the best "steel" that China makes is Pig-Iron (an intermediate product before Steel).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backyard_furnace https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backyard_furnace
If the "best" Lithium Ion cell that China mass produces has poor weight and/or power density, then it has no use in a Car. Cells and Batteries are the #1 issue for an electric car. (More weight requires more batteries to lug around). Cutting back on weight while increasing the power is how you make a superior vehicle.
- oblio 9y ago> Its unlikely for any US Car company to buy cheap batteries from China. They'll instead build batteries as a competitive advantage over each other. Just like US processor or SSD companies build things themselves? I'm being ironic but my point is that when China cranks up production I don't see why US (or any other companies) wouldn't buy their cheap products as long as they meet the required specs. Edit: Comparing Maoist China to post-Deng Xiaoping China is kind of silly :)
- dragontamer 9y ago> Just like US processor or SSD companies build things themselves? China doesn't deliver cheap, high-quality NAND Flash. Nor do they make Intel chips. Nor do they make Qualcomm chips. Nor do they make even AMD chips (I mean sorta, IIRC China has licensed an AMD design but they aren't making Ryzen). Micron Flash is made in Virginia: https://us.micron.com/micron-in-usa/us-jobs/college-recruiting/manassas-virginia https://us.micron.com/micron-in-usa/us-jobs/college-recruiti... Intel Chips are made in Oregon: http://www.infoworld.com/article/2672745/computer-hardware/inside-intel-s-d1d-fab----through-the-looking-glass.html http://www.infoworld.com/article/2672745/computer-hardware/i... AMD Chips are made in New York (Subcontracted to GlobalFoundries): http://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1327435 http://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1327435 As far as foreign companies go... Taiwan (TSMC aka Nvidia's contractor), Japan (Toshiba), and Korea (Samsung) are the other countries with 14nm or 10nm fabrication labs. Those are the US's rivals when it comes to high-tech. NOT China. Sorry to burst your bubble. I think some of those companies build plants in Israel. So Israel deserves an honorable mention. Singapore too. -------------- Ermmmm... yeah. The best of the best is made in the USA. I'm not saying "China quality is bad"... but the fact of the matter is that China does NOT own any 10nm fabrication facilities. China's manufacturing is a step behind the USA's technologically. Its a LOT bigger however, so that's a thing. China just has so many damn people that they manage to brute-force a lot of solutions. But unless they begin to push innovative designs, they aren't going to make the best. Most likely, China's cells will be a shock for the utility-space companies, who DONT require high-quality batteries to do important things. Again, there are plenty of uses of lower-tech MASS PRODUCED cells. Ex: stick thousands of them into shipping containers and then hook them up to the grid. That's damn useful. Its just not useful for cars.
- rhino369 9y agoHigh end NAND is made in China, but in factories owned by Korean, American, Japanese, and Taiwanese companies.
- oblio 9y agoIt's almost like China is still a (huge) developing country! :)
- dragontamer 9y agoErm, low-end NAND Flash is made in China. Lots of it, but its low-end. Intel, Micron, Samsung, and Toshiba are making 3d-NAND, which has superior specifications... allowing controllers to read / write them as Triple-Level without very many endurance problems. And the only locations for 3d-NAND are: * Japan: http://www.anandtech.com/show/10184/toshiba-to-build-a-new-fab-to-produce-bics-nand-flash http://www.anandtech.com/show/10184/toshiba-to-build-a-new-f... * (South) Korea: https://www.engadget.com/2013/08/05/samsung-ships-first-3d-vertical-nand-flash/ https://www.engadget.com/2013/08/05/samsung-ships-first-3d-v... * USA: Idaho for Micron's 3D Flash. IIRC they've partnered with Intel... which is primarily Israel and USA as far as manufacturing goes. --------- Now... name me a Chinese manufacturer of 32-layer (or more) 3D Flash. Toshiba hit 96-layers IIRC. Hint: You can't. China doesn't make high-end 3d NAND Flash. At all. Maybe they will catch-up in a few years, but at the moment, they are not.
- justicezyx 9y agoThe point is that the Gap is narrowing not that there is no Gap.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rhino369 9y agoI'm not sure I'd call 15nm 2D NAND "low end." But when those Chinese fab lines were opened, they were cutting edge. Nearly all the engineering is done somewhere that isn't in China, which was my point.
- kortex 9y agoTotally agree. Lithium cells, what with their necessary protection circuits and tendency to exothermically disassemble, seem like exactly the sort of product where certain use cases (e.g. EV manufacturers) greatly prefer the premium product with great QA, vs cheap quantity goods. An 85 kWh lithium fire in a passenger vehicle is a way different beast than a 15 WH phone fire. You do not want to be the car company with the reputation of explody vehicles. Look at "Ford Pinto" - it's basically an eponym for "exploding deathtrap". Even if these new Chinese batteries are of pristine quality, mass-manufactured Chinese goods inarguably have a reputation to combat.
- dragontamer 9y agoChina is fine for quality (see the iPhone). Its more about a technology thing. China doesn't have as good of an "innovation" economy yet. I think China has made major steps towards innovating in recent years, but they're still behind US / Japan / Germany / Korea.
- baybal2 9y ago>If the "best" Lithium Ion cell that China mass produces has poor weight and/or power density, then it has no use in a Car. Cells and Batteries are the #1 issue for an electric car. (More weight requires more batteries to lug around). Cutting back on weight while increasing the power is how you make a superior vehicle. FYI most non-Chinese EVs and hybrids with lithium cells use commodity cylindric cells that do have atrociously low weight/capacity ratio Chinese makers were using purpose built brick cells since around 2012, at the time first generation of Chinese hybrids hit the market