3 ms·
It's a sign of a "cognitive surplus", because we have more educated people now than we have jobs for them to do. Also it's a sign of how these sites get people
by sp332 9y ago
It's a sign of a "cognitive surplus", because we have more educated people now than we have jobs for them to do. Also it's a sign of how these sites get people to work for them for free, and concentrate huge amounts of other people's work for their own benefit. This poster got nothing for all that work, but SE still gets advertising revenue driven by interest in the content.
- logicallee 9y agoanother example that there is not enough work to go around is that if you go into any downtown anywhere in the world at 7 pm to 8 p.m. you will see people drinking beer in bars. These same people could still be working, since there is no reason they shouldn't be in an office, factory, etc, for a full 14-hour workday. Clearly there is just not enough work to go around, which manifests itself as people sitting around drinking or going on fun Internet sleuthing that nobody would mistake for work. (well, except that one guy.)
- YesThatTom2 9y agoChildren are the same way. All that time they spend playing could be spent in a factory making sneakers.
- mcphage 9y agoI don't know about your kids, but mine would make some shitty sneakers :-)
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThey'll be fine after a few days of training.
- sp332 9y agoI'm not arguing from first principles here. Workforce participation is down. This is just a symptom. I'm not against having free time, but against companies who ask you to work for them for free. If people had the ability to make money with their time and effort, that guy would be more likely to be paid for his post.
- jcarreiro 9y agoSo if HN added advertising to support the site, you would totally stop posting here, right?
- sp332 9y agoNot unless I could find a place that would pay better for my posts.
- beaconstudios 9y agoSE provides a venue for these types of discussions, and in exchange does a small amount of advertising to make the venture profitable. How is that exploitative in any sense of the word? Do you have the same attitude towards social clubs that charge fees?
- sp332 9y agoI don't go to SE for the "venue". I usually get there via a Google search, which means the only draw is the content. And hopefully Google would give me the same info if it were on any other site that paid their writers.
- beaconstudios 9y agoyou don't go for the venue, but others do - the asker and the answerer who generated the content in the first place. You're just getting the benefit of their exchange due to SE's existence. I don't understand why you have an issue with SE hosting content in exchange for permission to advertise on it. I have to pay amazon/digitalocean to host my content - if it costs something for a host to provide it then they can either make the money back somehow or constantly lose money.
- sp332 9y agoBut the only thing SE has to offer is other people's content. And I don't have a problem with them making money, but with not sharing any with the people who are the reason the site gets money. They're not even middlemen who take a cut, they're getting 100% of the revenue.
- jnty 9y agoPeople write all sorts of nonsense for newspapers and get paid for it. Just because you personally don't value some labour doesn't mean it's not valuable labour.
- blueside 9y ago> if go into any downtown anywhere in the world at 7 pm to 8 p.m. you will see people drinking beer in bars. Those people are still working, they just don't know it
- ComputerGuru 9y agoOh please. It's just someone enjoying a challenge and hunting down something for gratification. Let's not make it out to be more than it is. There have always been people that go above and beyond for intellectual gratification and out of nothing more than curiosity. There have always been people willing to do things like this for "no good reason" and for nothing in return since time immemorial. I don't want to live in a world devoid of such awesomeness. I've done it myself and hope to continue to do so, even being cognizant as I am that someone may benefit from my toils without my making a buck. If I spend a month developing an open source library that does something novel and release it under a liberal license (MIT, BSD) on GitHub, am I not doing the same sort of thing every day? This SE answer is awesome and it's helpful and insightful; but it isn't an example of capitalism at work and poor people being fleeced out of their time and money so the big guy can make a buck. Respect to the poster. That was some legit research.
- steve_adams_86 9y agoI agree. The stack exchange is a place I whitelist in my adblocker. They seem to take ads and ad quality seriously, they provided very useful and interesting content, and they employ a pretty excellent team. I don't see the problem. It seems like what you'd hope for from the situation.
- clarkmoody 9y ago> This poster got nothing for all that work Not all utility is money. The poster voluntarily spent time and energy creating that response, and voluntary exchange is mutually beneficial. So the poster got something for all that work, but it wasn't money.
- supergreg 9y agoAnd then there's a community discussing the work and it's motivations. Maybe people is driven more by curiosity than money.
- mindcrime 9y agoThis poster got nothing for all that work What's your basis for this claim? I can see saying "this poster received no financial compensation for all this work" but that's a different claim. It seems to me that the poster must have received somethingp[1], or they would not have put the effort forth in the first place. [1]: where "something" could be self-satisfaction, ego-boost, intellectual gratification, or any number of other non-financial rewards.
- esrauch 9y agoI think your line of thinking only implies the poster believed that he would receive a rewards, not that he did receive a reward (he may have regretted doing the work afterwards).
- piaste 9y agoIsn't that a bit like saying that night clubs get their cooler / more attractive patrons to work for them for free, by attracting the wider masses?
- sp332 9y agoNight clubs actually pay their DJs, bartenders, bouncers, etc. And they might comp more attractive patrons, which isn't quite the same as paying them but it's not nothing.
- gozur88 9y agoThere are nightclubs in Vegas that pay attractive women to show up and spend some time on the dance floor.
- panarky 9y ago> This poster got nothing for all that work @sp332, you've submitted 693 items to HN, and you've made thousands of comments. What did you get for all that work?
- sp332 9y agoWell they're not paying me. Why?