4 ms·
That's the story we hear occasionally, but according to TFA "starting and stopping natural gas plants is costlier and more difficult than shutting down [and, pr
by jessaustin 9y ago
That's the story we hear occasionally, but according to TFA "starting and stopping natural gas plants is costlier and more difficult than shutting down [and, presumably, starting up] solar panels" so they just leave those running without regard to daily peaks. I'm not sure how we ever got sold on a technology with those characteristics being a good "peaker", but hey! utilities execs are good at their jobs, when their jobs are correctly understood to be screwing over the customer.
Your anti-market bias is reversed in this case. The market [EDIT: for investments] doesn't want these new plants, because they're wasteful and bad for the environment. Therefore, they're bad investments that will only be made if the public is forced against its will to make them.
- spangry 9y agoHuh, well I definitely learned something today. As for anti-market biases, I suspect we might disagree on the definition of the phrase 'the market'. Admittedly, I mentally put the word 'free' in-front of the word 'market' when I hear it used without qualification. I feel like it's the only safe assumption to make. Otherwise, chances are, the regulated, distorted and interfered with market that I have in my head is very likely different to the one you have in yours. And unless we both explain what we mean exactly when we say 'the market', we're just kinda talking past each other.
- jessaustin 9y agoNo worries dude. It's cool to discuss, even if we don't agree. Markets may not be "free", but they can still function as we'd expect markets to function if there are multiple sellers and buyers. The market for utility bonds is like that, but the market for electricity often is not.
- baq 9y agoUnfortunately the free market is a purely theoretical concept and a model not unlike Newtonian physics - useful, but incorrect.
- c517402 9y agoThe turbines engines used for natural gas based electrical power production can be throttled up and down over a wide range. IIRC from maximum power down to about 15%. But, no you do not want to just shut them off. There are natural gas based diesel generators that can be turned on and off, but being Diesel engines they really only run efficiently over a small power output range and you control how much power is generated by how many you turn on. You need rows and rows of the Diesels to match the power from a gas turbine and each diesel needs to be individually matched into the power grid. So, there are reasons to go with gas turbine electrical power generation to meet peak power demands. OTOH, CA is tearing down recently built plants because of over capacity which is just crazy and obviously a boondoggle for the electric companies. But, building the plants was driven by the craziness that immediately preceded it; CA's NIMBY driven under capacity and being forced to meet peak power demands by buying outrageously priced power from out of state. Just bad planning, more bad planning, and certainly more bad planning to come.
- jjt-yn_t 9y agoInformative post but unsure of the meaning of the latter part... not in favor here of the teardowns, vs reserve capacity, say if some new technology comes along which needs a greater amount of electricity, or, less hopefully likely, some caldera-type event which isolates the California grid from out-of-state stable backup power as well as a significant amount of the power it uses...