6 ms·
Wow, the author is not exaggerating when saying it is a scam. Looking at the .feedback page for Stack Overflow, it says at the top, in fairly large letters "We
by wodenokoto 9y ago
Wow, the author is not exaggerating when saying it is a scam.
Looking at the .feedback page for Stack Overflow, it says at the top, in fairly large letters "We make Stack Overflow, where the world's developers get answers, share knowledge & find jobs they love. Also proud builders of the @stackexchange Q&A network."
Then at the absolute bottom, in small, washed out print it says "Disclaimer: This site is provided to facilitate free speech regarding Stack Overflow. No direct endorsement or association should be conferred."
So, users are not supposed to confer that a page claiming to be by the makers of stack overflow, are associated with SO? Beyond any reasonable doubt, the people behind that site are trying to scam visitors.
If the creators of the .feedback pages are also the TLD owners, it seems obvious to me that they should face legal charges and be stripped of the TLD.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoConsumers will eventually learn, as they always do. Try to educate anyone you meet that brings up .feedback. If anyone on social media talks about it, link them this article.
- manigandham 9y agoYou must be joking or have no experience beyond 1 or 2 people. The vast majority of the online population does not learn nor care about these details. The massive amount of scams that continue to exist and grow is evidence enough. If people did something as simple as confirming the domain listed in the address bar is the site they should be on, we would see a major decrease in malware, but alas the situation continues.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoThe flipside of this is that if nobody visits .feedback domains, they won't be able to scam anyone. Users don't need to learn anything to avoid them, because they probably won't ever hear about them in the first place. If they have no audience, they can be safely ignored. No reason to pay $600/yr for hypotheticals. All I meant was, the moment someone brings up a .feedback domain or "Google's new feedback service," just let them know it's a scam and move on.
- losteric 9y agoLet's hope they don't learn about this thing called "SEO"
- soneil 9y agoI'm not sure how much that'll really help. It doesn't take too much imagination to think that perhaps Google's heuristics will rank this TLD poorly. Trying to scam google over $600 feels like a poor strategy for a scam that depends on being discovered.
- losteric 9y agoThey aren't going to scam Google, or any legally capable entity. I imagine they will follow the Yelp scam model - post bad reviews against smaller companies, out so them, and charge to remove the malicious information.
- susam 9y agoScamming is a multi-million dollar sophisticated business. Scammers use various forms of advertisements from online advertisements to cold-calling potential victims to carry out their scams. That's how potential victims fall prey to scams and end up visiting malicious websites. That's how an audience for scamming is created.
- manigandham 9y agoThe amount of education you spread (and assuming it's remembered and trusted) will never match the advertising and other underhanded methods scammers will use to trick people into visiting and believing this is a real site. They work on the scale of billions of online users.
- repiret 9y agoIf that were really true, the BBB might have gone under years ago, and the Nigerians might stop asking for help in transferring great wealth. There is no shortage of suckers in the world - as the old saying goes, there's one born every minute.
- wyldfire 9y ago> So, users are not supposed to confer that a page claiming to be by the makers of stack overflow, are associated with SO? Yes, pretty clearly trademark infringement IMO. Confusingly similar, their websites purport to be run by the very organizations they're trying to extort. The disclaimer is IMO not sufficiently clear. SO is humorously classified as a "local business". NYC HN-ers, could you drop by the SO offices and ask a Python question for me? I keep getting these `ImportError`s...
- raysarebest 9y agoI haven't done too much looking, but that seems fairly common so far. Microsoft is also a "local business", and Google is an ISP. I mean, Google Fiber is really cool, but that's not how most people use it
- klodolph 9y agoGoogle Fiber is a part of Alphabet, though...
- gcb0 9y agowell, technically anyone with a stackoverflow account can claim that.
- Stratoscope 9y agoWell, the reviews on stackoverflow.feedback are quite informative! Dan Manny says: Stack over flow made me loose money!!! Bad code with security wholes in it crashed my clients site!! Warning warning for scammers and Antonio B. of Indonesia says: Best site for solving programming issue!!!11!one! The most user and newbie friendly site! 11/10 would recommend You know you can trust reviews like this!
- H4CK3RM4N 9y agoI think "Stack Overflow Admin"'s response to Dan Manny should speak for itself: > You fucking moron!!! You lost money because you were so stupid and not being able to differentiate bad code from good code. StackOverflow is not you free personal assistant. You should kill yourself for being so stupid.
- PietdeVries 9y agoFrom reading the "reviews" at http://www.stackoverflow.feedback/reviews http://www.stackoverflow.feedback/reviews, I get the feeling the entire .feedback TLD will soon be hosting all kinds of 4chan-alike pages and the owners will have to take the sites down because of the NSFW things that will be posted there...
- H4CK3RM4N 9y agoIm pretty sure they're all from here though(including the one I quoted), and the ones before today are somewhat civil.
- CPLX 9y ago> !!!11!one! Is there a word for the feeling you get when you see 15+ year old idiot message board / forum / usenet catchphrases apparently still going strong? It's a curious mix of nostalgia and revulsion.
- klodolph 9y agoThe German word for it is Beinaheleidenschaftsgegenstand, apparently.
- blazespin 9y agoIt is a scam, but the reality is nobody will ever go to these domains, they will never be ranked in google or bing. So who cares. I could create a site called myfeedbacksite.com/google or google.myfeedbacksite.com.. same thing.
- speedplane 9y agoIf you owned one of those sites, you'd probably be a bit concerned. You're probably wondering right now if it's worth it to take action, wait for another company to do so, or hope that it never gets traction, like you suggest. Also, the domains you suggested are quite different from the current situation. A site like myfeedbacksite.com/google is clearly not owned or operated by Google. Very few people would be confused. Whereas a site named google.feedback is far more confusing. Not sure anyone would know if it's an official Google site or not.
- victorNicollet 9y agoYou should only be concerned about people who know enough to tell that `google.com.feedba.ck` is probably not owned by google, but don't know enough to tell the same about `google.feedback`. I really don't think this covers a lot of people.
- speedplane 9y agoTwo points: - I do think they are concerned about google.com.feedba.ck, those lawyers need to fill up their day. - google.com.feedba.ck is far more sketchy looking than google.feedback. It's far easier to fool someone with the latter, and therefore far more of a thread.
- an_account 9y agoFor now. Give it 5 years and everyone will know that something.random_tld is sketch too.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nkkollaw 9y agoGood time to test those DDOS attack tools.
- a5seo 9y agoPretty much RipoffReport 2.0, except scaled to hyperbolic levels! Yay!!!!
- thirdsun 9y ago> Looking at the .feedback page for Stack Overflow, it says at the top, in fairly large letters "We make Stack Overflow, where the world's developers get answers, share knowledge & find jobs they love. Also proud builders of the @stackexchange Q&A network." Plus it also looks decently designed and not like an easy to spot scam. I could easily see the average, non tech-savvy users fall for that.
- bhartzer 9y agoIf someone puts up a site or page claiming to be a company or entity that they're not (i.e., "We make Stack Overflow, where the world's developers get answers...") then that's not a domain name or TLD issue. It's another issue altogether that should be dealt with legally.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- djsumdog 9y agoLooks like all their pages have the word "scam" on them somewhere now. I also see some script alert() and other stuff that suggest they've got a lot of security bugs and people, either on here or elsewhere, have taken it upon themselves to inject/change a bunch of content so people realize it's all scammy.