4 ms·
Well, patents only cover the patented claims, though the lawyers try to make them cover as much as possible, which is how we get these ridiculous overreaching p
by Natsu 16y ago
Well, patents only cover the patented claims, though the lawyers try to make them cover as much as possible, which is how we get these ridiculous overreaching patents. But maybe this can be said to show that those features are, on some level, generic (i.e. not innovative/novel), and therefore the sort of thing that shouldn't be protected by patents.
That said, I certainly hope that the Bilski decision is a reasonable one, lest we end up with patented novels, grocery lists and other inane legal "innovations." Because I just can't see the MPEG-LA sitting around while Google derails their gravy train. I don't know what they'll do, but FUD and litigation seem like the most likely options. If I had to bet, I'd say that they're gathering up whatever patents they can find and waiting to see how Bilski turns out, so that they don't get shut down right at the start.
- jrockway 16y agoOn the other hand, I don't see Google sitting around while the MPEG-LA derails their gravy train. Google stands to lose a lot if they have to use a format other than VP8 or H.264 (in bandwidth costs), or if they have to pay the H.264 licensing fee for every YouTube video, Android handset, and Chrome download. Sadly, I think Google has more to lose than MPEG-LA, because they are the company that is actually doing something useful. Patents encouraging innovation indeed...
- Natsu 16y agoOh, definitely not. I have to wonder what they can do, though? They don't offer legal indemnity (probably can't, who knows how much that would cost?) and it might not be easy for them to insert themselves into any lawsuit the MPEG-LA filed. Even though they're the obvious target, there's nothing stopping them from going after the small fry to set a precedent, or just doing a SCO-style shakedown (only they'd presumably be more competent ... at least, it'd be hard to be less competent). If I had to bet on what's keeping the other shoe from dropping, they either are still working on finding patents that might kinda-sorta read on VP8, or they're waiting for Bilski, with some possibility of both. But that's just my guess. I mean, who knows what they're thinking?
- mbrubeck 16y agoPatent lawyers working on standards like H.264 actually have incentive to make them cover as little as possible. Making the claims narrower may reduce the chance of invalidation in any potential dispute. Meanwhile, the patent needs only to cover exactly what's in the standard in order to participate in the licensing pool. As long as they match the standard carefully, implementers can't work around the patent while also remaining compliant. Gregory Maxwell points out that this is likely applicable to H.264 and VP8: "As we’ve pointed out before, many codec patents are exceptionally easy to work around: They specify every little detail because it makes it _much_ easier to get through the examination but doesn’t harm the patent’s ability to read on the final standard because the standard specifics exactly the patented behaviour... We can assume that in cases where VP8 looks similar to H.264 those would have been exactly the cases where care was taken to differ in the right places. I’d expect the primary risks for VP8 to be anywhere _but_ there." http://blog.gingertech.net/2010/05/20/vp8-adobe-is-the-key-to-open-video/#comment-5882 http://blog.gingertech.net/2010/05/20/vp8-adobe-is-the-key-t...