3 ms·
I don't think the author was trying to create a conversation about the misalignment of the lab's management and safety. The article goes out of its way to sensa
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I don't think the author was trying to create a conversation about the misalignment of the lab's management and safety. The article goes out of its way to sensationalize industrial accidents with "NUCLEAR RADIATION" to construct a narrative of uninformed fear of anything associated with nuclear material.
It reminded me a bit of some of the Discovery Channel's shows where they stress that if this multi-million ton container ship doesn't stay between the two entrance markers to the harbor, it kill everyone on board and probably destroy millions of dollars in goods. The entrance markers are 5 miles apart. The fact is accurate, the narrative is not.
If you want to be really scared go read the OSHA reports on any of DOW's chemical plants. I would be willing to wager that more people have died in the last 5 years of industrial accidents at their plants than all of Los Alamos. The Union Carbide Bhopal disaster killed over 2,000 people, one accident.
The point is the article was not written to compare the risk of accidents at Los Alamos to that of other similarly sized industries, nor was it written to highlight the misalignment of lab management with safety goals. It was written to characterize nuclear materials as scary and dangerous and carefully avoids any way for the reader to compare that risk with other risks they are both familiar with and are not concerned about.
In short, it is anti-nuclear propaganda.
- noir_lord 9y agoOn the topic of those shows I hate the false drama in "will they make it on time". Well yes, global logistics is incredible, the ship is working fine, the weather is good and there isn't a us destroyer for miles so of course they will. I wish they'd just focus on the engineering and logistics and cut all the bullshit. I'd also really love it if they'd take a swan dive on specific areas, navigation, maintenance, scheduling all that stuff. If they made documentaries I'd like they probably wouldn't have many viewers. Deadliest Catch was good in that regard, some interpersonal stuff (more in later seasons) but the barent sea is dramatic enough alone.
- crucini 9y agoOn the topic of scary chemical plants: check out the Chemical Safety Board's videos on Youtube. Mostly computer-animated recreations of serious industrial accidents.
- dmix 9y agoWow these are a great way to communicate risks in workplace safety. Here's an example video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=41QMaJqxqIo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=41QMaJqxqIo This is a great idea. I wish more of the more serious post-mortems were this thorough in our industry. But I guess people rarely die, they just have millions of peoples data leaked or result in serious service interruptions, so we don't have much of an incentive.