3 ms·
First up, strabismus implies you're primarily using your dominant eye, and ignoring input from the other eye. In this state, 3D vision based on different inputs
by barrkel 16y ago
First up, strabismus implies you're primarily using your dominant eye, and ignoring input from the other eye. In this state, 3D vision based on different inputs to each eye won't do anything for you. If you weren't solid on eye gaze coordination for 3D perception before viewing 3D video, I can maybe buy that it increases the risk that you don't settle in properly. But if you do have eye gaze coordination already, I would believe that 3D vision you can easily track - i.e. alter your gaze point appropriately to coordinate images from both eyes - would not impair this skill, and may even improve it.
I played around with stereograms a bunch when I was 12 or so. I got to making my own using graph paper, creating a random dot pattern, and then carefully repeating it with adjustments to generate the desired depth cues when viewed with crossed vision - the near approach - or parallel vision, the far approach.
So, I did this for many, many hours over a period of weeks. The most practical upshot - if you can call it practical - is that I'm now extremely good at "spot the difference" puzzles, as I can change the intersection point of my eye gaze at will, even to the point of infinity (parallel gaze) and slightly beyond (so that my eyes are actually looking outward in slightly different directions). The practice of conscious control also decouples corneal focusing from gaze direction as desired.
Another slight plus is that I find it reasonably easy to relax my eyes, putting on a "1000 yard stare", including distance-focusing my eyes. I often do this when I'm sitting by the computer, but caught up in thought. FWIW, I'm slightly short-sighted, but have experienced no loss in visual acuity in 20 years of almost entirely indoor, close computer work.
I feel pretty confident from my personal experience in saying that I'm not afraid that there will be any side-effects from 3D video. But I am only an anecdote, and I don't own a television, much less would I consider buying a 3D TV.
- cj 16y agoYour ability to control your focusing was something you learned how to do after your visual pathways were fully developed. For you, your stereograms didn't interfere with your initial development. As the article says, 3D in moderation for adults is fine. The article is mostly concerned about the development of children's visual pathways during their critical periods.
- barrkel 16y agoIf you read what I wrote, you'll see that I said that once you're already solid on gaze coordination, then I think 3D video that you could easily track wouldn't do harm. Those are caveats, and are probably related not just to age, but individual capabilities (as I said I'm just an anecdote). Secondly, if you read the article, you'll see that it's titled "3D video hazardous to your health", not "3D video hazardous to your kids' health". The article also conjectures that "one can surmise that it’s also never too late to learn bad habits that could create visual problems". So, if you read the article carefully, you'll see that it is not mostly concerned with the development of children's visual pathways, but rather is interested in promoting fear for adults too.
- JeffJenkins 16y agoAmblyopia is the condition where one of your eyes is ignored. Strabismus is a condition where your eye "turns", which can cause amblyopia if not treated. I had surgery a year ago for my strabismus, but the image from my weaker eye is still being ignored.