5 ms·
Or to be socially-connected to organizations that the health insurance company doesn't want to piss off. My family wasn't rich at all growing up, but we never
by nostrademons 9y ago
Or to be socially-connected to organizations that the health insurance company doesn't want to piss off. My family wasn't rich at all growing up, but we never had a problem with health insurance, because my mother worked for the government. The one organization that insurers will never piss off is the federal or state government, because then they will lose the right to do business in that state.
I do think that this increasing preference for the rule of power over the rule of law is pretty disturbing, and makes a mockery out of the claim that we live in a democracy. Sure we do...if you have leverage over the companies that would violate your rights. But that's the very definition of corruption, when you need to rely on inside information, relationships, or other proprietary tools to get people to do what you want, rather than your rights as a citizen.
- socrates1998 9y agoyes, insurance companies are very corrupt. I would say they are inherently corrupt given their place and power in our system. I don't have a solution other than don't get sick or have a car accident.
- nostrademons 9y agoI'll take advantage of us having the top commentthread to pose a question to the HN audience: Would you rather live in a society where everyone has a right to medical care regardless of their social standing or financial wherewithal, but some people will die because of bureaucratic incompetence or because the person who could've saved them has no incentive to? Or would you rather live in a society where medicine can work miracles, even the most debilitating ailments can be cured, but only if you happen to be rich? The former is (to a first approximation) what you get with European-style single payer. The latter seems to be where American health care is headed. There's no situation where everybody can be saved, simply because we're all going to die in the end anyway, but the distribution of who dies and from what can be changed by different policies.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> The former is (to a first approximation) what you get with European-style single payer Aside from the fact that most European countries - even those with government-mandated healthcare - do not have single-payer insurance, this is a false dichotomy that ignores the global market dynamics. Just as Medicare in the US could not operate in its current form without the existence of the private market to implicitly subsidize the public system, European countries would have a very different healthcare story in the absence of the US market. Nobody likes to admit it, but there's a reason that the US is the source of over half of all direct biomedical and pharmaceutical research worldwide, including research conducted by European pharmaceutical companies. These companies use sales on the US market as the source of funds for the research that all countries benefit from, and in the absence of the US market, either those costs would be borne by Europe, or that research would simply not happen[0]. They also pull funding from the US market via other, less direct means. Yes, the US system has massive problems, and yes, it could and should be cheaper. But you can't analyze these as binary options in isolation, because they're not binary[1], and they're not operating in isolation either. [0] If you want to make the argument that Europe could come up with a system that pays for this research in the absence of the US market, fine, but then you have to explain both why that would not simply recreate the same expenses, and explain the fact that, so far, that system has not been created even by the European pharmaceutical and biomedical companies. [1] The UK has four main payers; the Netherlands doesn't even have single-payer at all, and so forth.
- nostrademons 9y agoSo assume that the U.S. health system goes away and that no further medical research is ever conducted; we're left with whatever the state of knowledge is now, and it'll never get better. This is what I was somewhat obliquely referring to as "some people will die because the person who could've saved them has no incentive to". The question still stands - would you rather live in the world where everyone has access to medical care but it isn't cutting-edge, or one where the very best in care and the very best in research techniques are available, but only for a price? I'm honestly curious about peoples' answers, because it is a dichotomy. Not necessarily a sharp one - you could imagine several intermediate systems in between - but there's a tradeoff between universal access vs. incentivizing further research and new techniques.
- roywiggins 9y agoI do! End health insurance companies as we know them. Institute universal coverage, mandated by law. It doesn't have to be single payer or free at point of care, but it has to be universal coverage. It's not a trivial problem, but it's also largely a solved one. The US just hasn't implemented any of the models that work elsewhere.
- richmarr 9y agoThat addresses healthcare, but health insurance is just one slice of the insurance market. I'm not aware of a general solution that covers all cases, but in auto insurance we found that the model of replacing underwriters with crowdfunded groups works.
- raquo 9y agoHere in BC only the province is allowed to provide primary car insurance. Our current provincial government is incredibly corrupt and incompetent, including with regards to the provincial insurer specifically, but I'll still take it over private insurers I've had to deal with before.
- backpropaganda 9y agoThe solution is AI. Self-driving cars and AI healthcare has the potential to make the insurance industries associated with both. I only recently learnt about the horrific healthcare in the US, and am doubling down on developing AI for healthcare. If I replace one doctor's job with an AI, I've probably saved 10s of lives.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 9y agoHow do you intend to ensure the fruits of your research will be used to benefit people rather than the large organizations who will (at least initially) control healthcare AI?
- dreamcompiler 9y agoDoctors per se are not the most critical problem in US healthcare. Premature optimization is the root of all evil. Find the real tentpoles and start there.
- lr4444lr 9y agoInsurance company executives pull the political marionette strings via campaign finance (in the U.S.). I would surmise the worry of "pissing someone off" dynamic is exactly the reverse.
- nostrademons 9y agoPossibly at the federal level. At the Massachusetts state level, the teacher's union (which my mother was part of) pulled the marionette strings; basically all local politicians were in the pocket of the MTA.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoDon't forget the police union.
- jobu 9y ago> Or to be socially-connected to organizations that the health insurance company doesn't want to piss off. This is definitely true, and it seems like social media and sites like this or Reddit have the potential to bring this power to many more people. Companies behaving badly stokes online lynch mobs like nothing else, just look any recent stories of Uber on HN or United on Reddit.
- nostrademons 9y agoThe challenge is that these mobs are essentially random, and the public's attention span is short. So if your company does something evil, there's basically a 1% chance that you will face a company-ending event, and a 99% chance that it will never come to light. And even if your company doesn't do something evil, there's still maybe a 0.25% chance that you will face a company-ending event, because online lynch mobs don't really care about facts. So it doesn't act very well as an incentive. Just look at the recent Monsanto news, where they knew that Roundup causes cancer, sold it anyway, and paid off the EPA to bury the investigation. There've been news stories, but no major social media outrage. Probably we've just been conditioned to expect no better of Monsanto. The advantage of a real legal system that's accessible to all is that there're procedures for finding out the truth of any accusation, and then if it is true, there's enforcement teeth behind it. (Or used to be, at least; I think many companies are now using the bankruptcy/reorg shield to avoid court judgments.) Mobs are a poor substitute for that.
- aisofteng 9y agoSome more info about the Monsanto thing, which I hadn't heard about; I believe this is what the parent is mentioning: https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/03/14/business/monsanto-roundup-safety-lawsuit.html https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/03/14/business/monsanto-roun...
- TimPC 9y agoThe other challenge here is that it's hard to vote with your feet in insurance because you might have employer provided insurance that gives a specific company a monopoly, have fewer options for other reasons, or face turning a condition acquired while insured into a pre-existing condition (might be relevant under Trump's attempt at reform).