3 ms·
Someone could still create a single app that plugs into many cities' existing ride services. It may not be as uniform an experience, but it saves the headache
by SilasX 9y ago
Someone could still create a single app that plugs into many cities' existing ride services. It may not be as uniform an experience, but it saves the headache of downloading and setting up a new app for each city.
- kbenson 9y agoYes, a ride share arbitration service would solve a lot of the problems. The question is, does Uber have enough market in enough places or enough of a name that they can resist fully tying into a service like that. Think Apple. They have enough market share (even if not a majority), and enough brand loyalty, that they don't need to adhere to existing standards if they think they can resist them and use that to their advantage. Think iChat, and compare to the original XMPP google chat. It was trivial to talk to gchat friends on an iPhone, but hard or impossible to talk to friends over iChat from an Android phone. By resisting making iChat open, Apple created an advantage for iPhone users. Eventually Google redoes google chat with Hangouts, and guess what? They close the protocol. Sharing is only beneficial for you if it's reciprocated. Does Uber have the clout or loyalty to get away with this? I doubt it, especially since the bar for drivers to drive for multiple services is so low. But if the arbitration service was created without provisions to account for this (e.g., you must partake in the system to use it as a provider), it would be trivial for Uber to fill gaps in their coverage through the service while preventing other apps from doing the same with Uber drivers.
- linkregister 9y agoIs there no Hangouts app for iOS?
- kbenson 9y agoThere is, but it's completely controlled by Google now. It's not integrated into an app that can offer multiple chat systems as it could be previously, and they can control exactly how it's used since they control the app.
- SilasX 9y agoI don't follow. I wasn't suggesting that Uber would be forced to tie into such a service, only that this would eliminate their advantage in that respect.
- kbenson 9y agoMy point is that unless locked down correctly, and depending on the specific market conditions, a service like that could be used by Uber to their advantage. If the Uber app gives you rides from Uber or from other providers when an Uber isn't available, but the other app only does other providers, it's beneficial to use the Uber app instead of the other ones, and Uber can then provide better placement to their own drivers. It's a common problem between open and closed systems in markets.
- SilasX 9y agoThat would explain how Uber would mitigate some of the resultant competition, not why it would eliminate their "only need one app" advantage.
- kbenson 9y agoI think we are addressing slightly different things. I wasn't specifically addressing the concern of one app, but what that implies (the service that aggregates ride providers). A service like that does mean a single app might yield good results in the majority of situations. That lessens the advantage Uber has. I was just noting that Uber might still be able to play that into an advantage for themselves, so while it might lessen the advantage, it wouldn't eliminate it, in that case (since Uber's app would always be at least as good in that scenario).
- Doctor_Fegg 9y ago> Someone could still create a single app that plugs into many cities' existing ride services Probably called "Google".