3 ms·
In the years leading up to World War I, the Royal Navy was convinced that rate of fire was everything. Every ship drilled to maximize their rate of fire. Comma
by vkou 9y ago
In the years leading up to World War I, the Royal Navy was convinced that rate of fire was everything.
Every ship drilled to maximize their rate of fire. Commanders of vessels who could not keep up with their peers were sacked.
When the Battle of Jutland came around, the Royal Navy greatly outnumbered the Kreigsmarine, and caught it unaware. The engagements were incredibly in the United Kingdom's favour.
Numerically, the battle was a disaster for the Royal Navy. Its losses were double that of their opponent. One of the reasons for it was that a number of RN ships exploded after taking a single hit - while German ones took shell after shell, and stayed afloat.
In their zeal to optimize their firing rate, the Royal Navy did away with the simple precaution of installing airlocks between their ammunition storerooms, and their gun rooms. You see - opening and closing an airlock every time you needed to get to and from the ammunition room wasted too much time.
Hitting a German gun room would destroy the gun. Hitting a British gun room would destroy the entire ship. But boy, did those gun crews shoot fast.
Unless your competitive process rigorously accounts for every form of cut corners, you're going to get what you measure... With some shortsighted optimizations thrown in.
- keithpeter 9y agoJutland: there were issues around the culture of waiting for signals (flags!) from the flagship and also around the personality of the Commander in Chief and some of the other admirals as well as the issue you mention. See The Rules of the Game by Andrew Gordon if you have an interest in naval history or how large organisations respond to change.
- Nomentatus 9y ago"Finally, there is a brief summary of the findings which assert that the loss of the British BCs, contrary to conventional wisdom was the result of over sensitive British propellant charges rather than the tendency of the crews to ignore safe ammunition handling practices to increase rate of fire." Review of https://www.amazon.com/Jutland-Analysis-Fighting-John-Campbell/dp/0870213245/ https://www.amazon.com/Jutland-Analysis-Fighting-John-Campbe...