4 ms·
[EDIT] Many here are acting as if TFA were about the noise of sonic booms, and it is not. From the actual amendment: (3) specifies a noise standard for landing
by jessaustin 9y ago
[EDIT] Many here are acting as if TFA were about the noise of sonic booms, and it is not. From the actual amendment:
(3) specifies a noise standard for landing and take-off of civil supersonic aircraft that is no more stringent than large subsonic aircraft in use for transporting passengers in the United States on January 1, 2017. [0]
That is, Boom are claiming that their engines could be narrower, if they were allowed to make as much noise taking off and landing as large passenger jets make taking off and landing. Perhaps TFA could have been clearer on this, but the reading comprehension is not strong on HN this morning.
[0] https://www.commerce.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/0238c447-3e61-475b-bbb1-27eeb54c3831/A8CDC5A8788C7557D876E4B78421F805.s.-1405-lee-3.pdf https://www.commerce.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/0238c447...
- idlewords 9y agoYou're ignoring section 2, which says the sonic boom can be as loud as other things the public tolerates (like jackhammers).
- jessaustin 9y agoIt's fine to be suspicious, but one should at least read carefully while in that state. TFA is about "amendment -> more noise on takeoff -> narrower engine -> fuel savings -> lower costs". Literally one paragraph mentions the sonic boom restriction, while the rest is about fuel savings. Lots of comments here are skipping that entirely, which indicates some confusion. Perhaps Boom will publish something else with more detail about flying jackhammers? To address that issue, ISTM we trust FAA to get many things right, but previously the thoughtful regulation of supersonic civil aviation was not one of those things. If this amendment passes, it will become one of those things. Is there a particular reason not to trust FAA thoughtfully to regulate this sort of flight?
- idlewords 9y agoBoom is writing about narrower issues of engine noise and fuel economy because they don't want to discuss the intractable problem they're named after. That doesn't mean we can't discuss it. I think the status quo (no shattered windows in Chicago) is desirable and worth preserving. The FAA may regulate it sanely, but then again, given the current political climate, they may not.
- jessaustin 9y agoIt has been several months since I visited Chicago, but that was not my impression of the status quo? This is a very hypothetical concern, however. It's quite unlikely that any passenger flights will pass the sound barrier at an altitude of 200 ft. [0] Then again, if Vladimir Putin wants to break some American glass in a really roundabout way, who are we to oppose him? Perhaps he needs to brush up on his Bastiat? [0] https://military.id.me/aircraft/can-a-sonic-boom-break-glass/ https://military.id.me/aircraft/can-a-sonic-boom-break-glass...
- tptacek 9y agoI don't know what that quip about Chicago was meant to accomplish, but I don't think you can complain about other people's "reading comprehension" while misapprehending that comment so thoroughly. Obviously, the point being made is that sonic booms break windows (some people near airports that saw supersonic traffic used to buy special windows), and Chicago is a major air transport hub.
- idlewords 9y agoSonic boom strength scales with aircraft size, and you know this. Your footnote is in bad faith.
- sbierwagen 9y ago? On the very first page of the PDF you linked: paragraph a, "Not later than one year after the date of the enactment of this Act, the Secretary shall publish in the Federal Register a notice of proposed rulemaking that permits the development, testing, manufacturing and operation of civil supersonic aircraft in the United States." I mean, it's right there. S. 1405 is about operating supersonic aircraft in the US, aircraft that by definition make sonic booms.
- cameldrv 9y agoThis is somewhat misleading. What they are asking for is to be able to certify their plane under stage 3 noise regulations. Currently, it's legal to fly a stage 3 plane, but any design for a new plane submitted to the FAA after 2006 has to meet stage 4 regulations. Any design submitted as of the end of this year needs to be stage 5. Effectively this is like a car manufacturer asking to only be required to meet fuel economy/emissions/safety standards from 10-20 years ago for a new vehicle. IMO this is reasonable. Stage 3 planes are fairly quiet, at least compared to what was flying around in the 70s and 80s. If regressing a bit on airport noise is the price we pay to go twice as fast, that's OK with me. I'd love it if we talked about this honestly, and shamed the people who whine about every tiny negative impact of human progress.