4 ms·
I live in Baltimore, and have seen some of the described research work going on. I also spend a lot of my free time tramping deer trails and generally wandering
by throwanem 9y ago
I live in Baltimore, and have seen some of the described research work going on. I also spend a lot of my free time tramping deer trails and generally wandering all over creation. Those who don't are regularly surprised to learn just what extent of wildlife our city supports!
To the author's question of how city dwellers find green space and ecodiversity improvements of this sort - I think it's going to be hard to find anyone who feels these efforts and their results other than a material improvement in quality of life.
What concerns me, though, is that we're recently seeing a pattern, in a lot of neighborhoods, where formerly vacant - and thus vegetated, if not always ideally so - spaces are being bought up cheaply from the city by developers who proceed to fill them to the edges with housing that does not fit the neighborhood, is not welcomed by established residents, and is priced out of reach of anyone save the sort of rich formerly urban professional who has found downtown life insufficiently welcoming once a first child comes along.
That such people do not wish to move to soulless suburbs, I understand - but they seem fine with converting long-extant neighborhoods, with their own unique microcultures and community lives, into exactly that which they seek to avoid. And they seem unconcerned with inflicting the closure and privatization, of what have been de facto common spaces for in many cases decades, to whatever extent is necessary to achieve this short-sighted, ill-conceived, and universally destructive goal.
If anyone has a suggestion on how to deal with that problem, I'd love to hear about it...
- brianzelip 9y agoLove finding deer in the city! Druid Hill Park is great for it, especially in the early morning.
- throwanem 9y agoWyman Park, too, although perhaps not so much and not so friendly, I think because people let their dogs run loose. I was out there this last weekend and ran across a fox who'd fallen lethally foul of something, at any rate, and a dog seems by far the likeliest candidate - I keep hearing about coyotes, but it doesn't seem likely they would be much more difficult to observe than foxes, of which I've seen a goodly number. In any case, it's not as though whitetail are hard to find around here in general! In spring and fall, I often cross paths with them during my commute, and it's a rare peregrination on which I don't see at least one or two. If you really want to see wildlife, don't go to a park - put on your sturdy shoes and go find you some woods that don't look like they have people in them often, and it won't be long before you start finding deer trails to follow. (I know some very good places, but I hesitate somewhat to mention them publicly, because we have a fair number of fellow Baltimoreans here - while the local whitetail don't much care about people, foxes most certainly do, and they're hard enough to spot and photograph as it is! If you're interested enough, hit me up at the email in my profile, and we can talk about it some more.)
- rb808 9y agoDont you have Lyme disease in MD yet? Deer look pretty until you see people end up crippled by tick borne diseases. We need a serious cull in the NE.
- cafard 9y agoLyme disease has been around Maryland for years. I have known people to get it in the DC suburbs, one in his own back yard, one in a park. The US Park Service has culled deer in Rock Creek Park (Washington, DC) the last two or three winters. The neighborhood email list gets an invitation to join a candlelight vigil against this each fall. (No, I don't join.)
- throwanem 9y ago> The neighborhood email list gets an invitation to join a candlelight vigil against this each fall. The venison from deer so culled goes to feed homeless folks in their town. From [1]: After reduction operations, the National Park Service tests the deer to make sure they don't have Chronic Wasting Disease before the venison is donated to local food banks. The NPS has donated approximately 7,300 pounds of venison to DC Central Kitchen since beginning deer management in 2013. I wonder if the vigileers know that. Or whether they care. Or whether they'd even approve. [1] https://www.nps.gov/rocr/learn/management/white-tailed-deer-management.htm https://www.nps.gov/rocr/learn/management/white-tailed-deer-...
- cafard 9y agoYes, they know. I doubt they approve. Are those at the vigils all vegetarians? I have no idea.
- throwanem 9y agoWe do, and I've heard rumors of Rocky Mountain spotted fever as well. Don't get me wrong - I'm not in favor of letting whitetail breed explosively, unmolested by hunters; quite aside from the issue of tick-borne zoonoses, it's a waste of good venison.
- theandrewbailey 9y agoPittsburgh has lots of wildlife as well. There have been so many rabbits this year. Almost any park is full of them, bike through and see them scatter. I've seen lots of turkeys around, and even walked up on one on the sidewalk.
- mabbo 9y ago> If anyone has a suggestion on how to deal with that problem, I'd love to hear about it... My knee-jerk reaction is to call you an anti-development NIMBY, but that's not actually solving any problem. So let's set that aside. Your neighbourhoods have benefited from the existence of this vacant land. The city, meanwhile, has costs to maintain that land, police it, etc and have even more costs to maintain the infrastructure of low-density housing in such neighbourhoods. Cities need to increase density, and they need to be able to afford to maintain themselves[0]. Selling vacant land removes a cost and creates desperately needed income in times where all a politician is allowed to do is lower taxes (or else their opponent next election will say that they will lower taxes and get elected). If you want to have low-density residential areas with lots of green space, you need to petition your government to raise your taxes so that you can pay for it. Campaign for politicians willing to invest rather than lower taxes. Have them convert the land into a local park, using your increased taxes to maintain it. [0] See everything on https://www.strongtowns.org/ https://www.strongtowns.org/
- xkcd-sucks 9y agoDoes policing and maintaining vacant lots actually incur any meaningful costs on a city? Do undeveloped zones within a high density area help mitigate any externalities of high density development, by providing habitat for predators of urban wildlife, dense plant growth to improve air quality and soak up stormwater, etc.?
- mabbo 9y ago> Does policing and maintaining vacant lots actually incur any meaningful costs on a city? Vacant, unmaintained lands tend to attract crime. I say this from first hand experience- I was a teenager once, and we went to vacant, unmaintained land to commit crimes. We were good kids, mostly, but we weren't the only ones there. > by providing habitat for predators of urban wildlife, dense plant growth to improve air quality and soak up stormwater, etc.? I'm all for having dense forests near high rises (more birds! more plants! yes!) but that land is expensive to buy, expensive to maintain, expensive in terms of lost tax revenue. I simply argue that someone has to pay those costs, and getting mad at the city of being fiscally tight when politicians are elected promising exactly that is silly. You want to have a park/forest/whatever? Fine, but acknowledge that it's expensive and then pay your fair share of it.
- Mz 9y agoIf anyone has a suggestion on how to deal with that problem, I'd love to hear about it... I am an Environmental Resource Management major who had plans to become an urban planner, and then life got in the way. Have you attended any local board meetings? Do you know what the policies are? Have you looked up any not-for-profits or think tanks that have an interest in such issues? This is going to tend to be solved by things like zoning laws, good review processes and advocates actively trying to preserve open space, build parks and protect neighborhood character.
- throwanem 9y agoNot gonna lie, I have no idea about any of that; I've only very recently become aware of the problem. But now I know where to start, or at least one possible place, and I thank you very kindly for that!