5 ms·
Why didn't the fundraise work? Maybe because your business model doesn't appear to be working at your current scale, you're not scaling fast enough to make it w
by taneq 9y ago
Why didn't the fundraise work? Maybe because your business model doesn't appear to be working at your current scale, you're not scaling fast enough to make it work any time soon, and you didn't seem to have any clear plan to change this.
I don't mean to be harsh, it sounds like you gave it a shot and it went pretty right. But you got caught up in the unicorn-chaser Silicon Valley mindset:
1) Do something that only works if you're huge
2) Raise lots of capital based on the idea that you will one day be huge
3) Use that capital to become huge enough that your thing actually works
Sure, planning for your startup to be a unicorn is great if it works, but "big or bust" almost always ends up in "bust".
- nerdponx 9y agoI was wondering about this too. Why does this product only work if you're huge? It sounds like something you and a programmer buddy could have started as a side project and grown organically.
- jeffjose 9y agoVC's are only interested in high growth startups. That means they'll have to pass up on a lot of good ideas such as OP's. The whole thing boils down to power law that guides investment. VCs are hoping that out of 10, at least 1 would be a super-duper hit (think facebook, google) that'll offset the losses of the other 9. In short - go with "disrupting" world-changing ideas to the VCs. If your idea is good, but not great, you're better off finding money on your own and growing it organically.
- mysterydip 9y agoWouldn't an investor want a "diverse portfolio" divided between low yield low risk (such as OP pre-unicorning) and high yield high risk such as you mention?
- ghaff 9y agoI'm not sure there is such a thing as "low risk." Most small businesses fail even if their attempts at "disruption" begin and end with selling pizzas to the local college students.
- austenallred 9y agoAn angel investor would want a diverse portfolio. A VC wouldn't. VCs make all of their money from the one startup that becomes a billion dollar company and lose or break even or make a little on the rest. So they're really only looking for huge swings with enormous returns. If you're a seed stage VC you're where a larger fund has allocated a portion of its capital to play insanely high risk/high reward investments.
- goodJobWalrus 9y agoNo, because people who give the money to the investor (limited partners) can optimize their own portfolios. It is not the VC's mandate to do that. From the LP's point of view, investment in the VC fund is the risky component of their portfolio.
- mcguire 9y agoFor the same reason Berkshire Hathaway isn't investing in your lemonade stand: they have billions to invest, so if you're only making hundreds of thousands on the best day, you're not worth the required effort.
- nerdponx 9y agoBut that's my point. Why go the VC route instead of building a user base organically, eventually getting a small business loan, etc.?
- rainbowmverse 9y agoThe company I use to distribute my music is like that (DistroKid). Three employees and they turned the music distribution game on its head. I think the founder is active here on HN.
- bbrizzi 9y agoReminds me of DHH's talk about having just a "nice italian restaurant" : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0CDXJ6bMkMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0CDXJ6bMkMY
- chongli 9y agoSeriously. I kept thinking about YouTube when reading the story. What Hardbound tried to do is get VC money for an early stage YouTube channel. That's just silly. The business model for a YouTube channel is to start with nothing, make a video, nobody watches it, so then you make another video. Thousands of videos later you have a few people watching. You get a few of those people to give you a couple bucks on Patreon. You invest the money in better equipment and polish your videos up a bit. It's just a long, slow grind. It requires direct communication with your audience. You have to listen to what they want and meet their needs.
- nbashaw 9y agoYou're right -- it takes a long time for most media companies to get off the ground, and it's often near-impossible to raise money in the early days. But how many youtube channels that get ~7,000 weekly unique viewers are able to convert ~1,200 into paying monthly subscribers? Consider this: you might not already know everything there is to know about my business by skimming one blog post!
- ryanwaggoner 9y agoA piece of friendly advice: I get that you're in a pretty low place right now, and that this is your baby, but don't take comments on HN so personally. You're coming across as pretty defensive, which is understandable, but probably not helpful. People here can see this from a perspective that you can't, and if you're defensive, you're missing out on learning something. Otherwise, why are you bothering to interact here?
- nbashaw 9y agoI was in a really low place a couple weeks ago, but I actually honestly feel pretty fine now. I've given myself the space I need to process it. I definitely wouldn't have been able to publish this post when it first happened. Also, I totally get that it seems like a total waste of time to engage with the comments here. A lot of people have told me the same thing on Twitter. But the thing is: I think it's really special that someone on the other side of a computer screen read this thing I wrote and is thinking about what they would do in my shoes. Even if they express it in a way that's kind of rude or condescending, it means something to me! I'm sorry if it seems like I'm being defensive. When I think of what the word "defensive" represents, I think of someone who is totally unwilling to consider other points of view and is trying to shut out the world. I don't think that's what I'm doing. Nothing is more important to me than learning from what happened and growing into a better, smarter person. I totally appreciate the fact that I am just too close to the thing to really understand what happened. I need help from objective third parties to learn the most from this. That's actually why I'm replying to the comments. There's the naive DHH-cheerleading reply to anyone who is "yet another dumb unicorn chaser". But I want to go one or two levels deeper than that. I don't think those replies are particularly helpful, but I think the people that write them totally could be helpful. They just need to actually have a desire to understand in more detail what my business is/was doing. I accept that most people here will never care enough to really dig in. But I think the probability is high that some people here actually might really care. So I'm engaging here while it's on the front page of Hacker News, because I won't get another opportunity like that for a long time. Thanks for giving me the opportunity to think that through more. I hope it answers your question.
- ghaff 9y agoAs a general principle I pretty much agree with your comment. But, in this case, the post is throwing around figures like 7K readers per week. That just isn't a lot for just about any sort of content creation that needs to pay its own freight. These days I'd be really skeptical about just about any business model built around selling content to individuals.
- dracodoc 9y agoTo scale, I think you need to go either organic or mechanic: - mechanic is scalable with more resources. Throw in more computers, programs and get more output immediately with a much higher rate compare to human - organic is good but it take time. If you need quality work of human, it doesn't scale easily. It's possible to grow slowly with low cost.
- nbashaw 9y agoOP here. I'm curious, what makes you think that you know anything about what our plans were? You're absolutely right that we weren't profitable at our current scale, and that our goal was to raise funding from VCs, and since we couldn't do it we had to make really tough changes. But this was a risk that we all accepted! Would I do it exactly the same way again next time? No, of course not. I learned a lot from this experience. But do I regret going for something big that I believe in, even if it wasn't a plan that was easily bootstrapped? Absolutely not. You are smart, and you make a lot of good points. I could learn a lot from your way of thinking! But--you're also being a bit of a condescending know-it-all. This is a perfect example of why everybody makes fun of Hacker News comments. You can see that, right?
- Semiapies 9y agoI think many, many more people make fun of the startup mentality. Which is harsh, but justified. It's nice that you chased your dreams. The problem is, this is how almost all startups end up, with the last guy wondering what to do next. If you get struck by lightning, you get acquired. If you get struck twice, you get VC money. That you "accepted" the risk just means you took a very bad bet. If you learned from that, great. No shame in that. But it's not something people are going to be impressed by, especially this late in the game.
- nbashaw 9y agoYou're right that the probability of any individual "unicorn" type idea succeeding is ridiculously slim. But I think you're not appreciating the larger context. Consider this: 1) I have never had more job offers in my life than the past 24 hours. Like, really good jobs. Obviously that wasn't the goal, but it's not like I'm out on the street or really in any way worse off than I was before. 2) I learned more in the past two years than I have any other time in my working life. So again, I'm not in that bad of a spot. It wasn't a waste of time at all. 3) Even though there are very few massive hit VC successes, they do happen dozens of times a year. Just because something is low-probability doesn't make it stupid. Do you think people are dumb who write novels? Or become actors? Or open food trucks? Nobody should try anything that probably won't work? That's a really sad life outlook.