3 ms·
Yes. Let's look at more examples: Chat: Open: XMPP, Jabber, Adium, Tox, Jitsi. Closed: WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, Apple Messages, Line, Skype, WeChat. Soci
by FabHK 9y ago
Yes. Let's look at more examples:
Chat: Open: XMPP, Jabber, Adium, Tox, Jitsi. Closed: WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, Apple Messages, Line, Skype, WeChat.
Social: Open: ? pump.io, Diaspora? Closed: Facebook, Google+, LinkedIn.
App Stores: Open: F-Droid. Closed: Apple App Store, Google Play
Authentication: Open: FreeOTP. Closed: Authy, Google Authenticator
Office: Open: LibreOffice. Closed: Microsoft Office.
Cloud: Open: ? buddycloud, GitLab. Closed: iCloud, Dropbox, Google Drive, Microsoft OneDrive.
OS: Open: Unixes. Closed: OS X, Windows
Browsers: Open: Firefox. Closed: Chrome, Safari, IE
Maps: Open: OpenStreetMap. Closed: Google maps, Apple maps
I realise these are mostly not "protocols" (depending on what layer we're talking about). Nevertheless, can hardly say that "Open protocols are already much larger than closed systems".
- mintplant 9y agoThis is a Bad Comment that tries to disguise itself as a Good Comment by going for quantity over quality. Cherry picking, misinformation, and apples-and-oranges comparisons can all be found here. For example: > Google Authenticator ...is open source and based on open standards. > Chrome Chromium > Safari WebKit (originally derived from KHTML) > Cloud: Open: ? buddycloud, GitLab. Closed: iCloud, Dropbox, Google Drive, Microsoft OneDrive. The open and closed products here aren't even in the same spaces.
- hdhzy 9y agoGoogle Authenticator, the one that you download from Play Store, is not open source: > These apps are not on the app stores, and their code has diverged from what's in the app stores, so patches here won't necessarily show up in those versions. Source: https://github.com/google/google-authenticator/blob/master/README.md https://github.com/google/google-authenticator/blob/master/R...
- MysticFear 9y agoTrue, but the developers of those open protocols have no or little financial incentive for the success of their standard. Traditionally closed protocols had the financial incentive. Blockchains are different in that way.