3 ms·
> Should every court and country have the right to demand that things are de-indexed worldwide, now that Canada has done so? Canadian legal precedent doesn't a
by naasking 9y ago
> Should every court and country have the right to demand that things are de-indexed worldwide, now that Canada has done so?
Canadian legal precedent doesn't apply in other countries. This isn't like setting a precedent within your own country.
- oh_sigh 9y agoSure, but China would then have a good suspicion that they could coerce Google into doing this
- naasking 9y agoChina already has just as much leverage against Google as Canada: do what we say or you can't operate in our country.
- qb45 9y agoYes, but IIRC Google got kicked out of China for failing to comply with Chinese regulation in China, not for failing to comply with Chinese regulations in the US, Europe or Antarctica. Also, it didn't happen without some level of pushback from the American government. Now imagine the drama if China tried to impose their court orders on the US soil that way.
- jussij 9y agoBut which court order would China site to back up that coercion? For example no court is ever going to find Tiananmen Square never happened.
- blazespin 9y agoNo but judges are absolutely influenced by foreign decisions. Why wouldn't they be? Smart people on the supreme court, similar laws, why not consider what they arrive at?
- qb45 9y ago> Canadian legal precedent doesn't apply in other countries. Legally, yes. I bet Chinese courts don't recognize Canadian precedents. However, China is now free to claim that if Canada chooses to enforce censorship in China, they will be free to enforce censorship in Canada by similar means, if they ever feel like doing so.