3 ms·
> If we take the 2012 estimate to be true, Facebook’s server capacity outstrips Moore’s Law. As well as inflation, and all manner of other totally irrelevant c
by OJFord 9y ago
> If we take the 2012 estimate to be true, Facebook’s server capacity outstrips Moore’s Law.
As well as inflation, and all manner of other totally irrelevant concepts.
- jxramos 9y agois it really irrelevant? It's a well understood benchmark for tech growth rate is it not?
- positr0n 9y agoIt's a benchmark for transistor density, nothing else. Of course a single company could grow faster than transistor density can scale. The only possible insight, if you can call it that, is that facebook owns more square centimeters of transistors now than they did in 2012.
- jxramos 9y agoThat's the original inspiration, but I thought people adopted the exponential rate from the original context as a bench mark for all sorts of stuff. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moore%27s_law#Other_formulations_and_similar_observations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moore%27s_law#Other_formulatio.... At best I can figure the problem with the auhtor's usage is that it's not relative to a per unit performance but rather a per enterprise performance, ie not a faster server but more of them over a unit of time. I'm not entirely convinced the restriction to a per unit basis is valid, but maybe that's a more meaningful definition than just arbitrary exponential growth.
- jxramos 9y agoI'm a bit mystified by all the downvotes, am I mistaken in understanding that Moore's law can be understood in a generalized context with respect to the rate not the quantity the rate was originally measured from? Basically he observed a particular rate constant or exponential growth profile. The quoted wiki page states: "Several measures of digital technology are improving at exponential rates related to Moore's law, including the size, cost, density, and speed of components. Moore wrote only about the density of components, "a component being a transistor, resistor, diode or capacitor,"[102] at minimum cost."". So essentially when comparing the growth of one quantity vs another it's not the quantities that are being compared but the rates.
- tyingq 9y agoIt could be relevant if there is some fixed refresh cycle of servers. That is, newer servers can serve more end users because of the faster cpu, drives, etc. The author seems to have skipped the concept though.
- puzzle 9y agoYeah, I looked through the article, but never does he mention that one rack of today's server vintage might have an extra order of magnitude more RAM, if not cores, than one from 5 years ago. Ten years ago, four-core Barcelona Opterons were so hot and in high demand that, if you wanted to be on the latest servers, you had to show a performance boost worth the premium. Sometime this year you'll be able to buy dual processor Naples systems with 64 cores (128 threads).
- jjeaff 9y agoI assume that their assumption is that the facebook application has grown in complexity to keep pace with better servers. There is certainly a lot more going on as they had several years ago.