5 ms·
In a completely objective, hyper-rational sense, this seems fair to me. Islam is a choice and a set of beliefs (or many competing sets, since Islam isn't monol
by smt88 9y ago
In a completely objective, hyper-rational sense, this seems fair to me. Islam is a choice and a set of beliefs (or many competing sets, since Islam isn't monolithic). Gay is a biological reality.
There can be a substantive, intellectually justifiable debate about whether Islam is good, bad, or a mixture. It may be repugnant, or it may be practiced by repugnant people, but it's not any different from debates about whether political parties are good, bad, or a mixture.
There cannot be a substantive debate about sexuality the same way because it's not ideological, nor is it changeable.
- tghgffeee55 9y agoUnchangeable can be said about a persons religion too, yes? Humans acquire biological predispositions via development of neurological structures, among others. Reinforced over time by their local community giving them pats on the back for living up to the rules Sure people do break away from their culture of origin, but that many (most?) do not seems to make the notion that it's simply "choice" nonsense It's no easier for Muslims to ditch their beliefs than it is for me to ditch capitalism
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jwilk 9y agoHalf of the things in the "Who we don't protect" are not (easily) changable.
- mamon 9y ago> Gay is a biological reality. Actually, there's no definitive proof for that, and it probably never will be as any research on the topic is now way too risky - if your research produces a politically incorrect result then you'll be held in contempt as a "hater", even if your methodology is flawless.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoThere's no conclusive proof, but the evidence is strong. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2016/03/15/homosexuality-may-be-triggered-by-environment-after-birth/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2016/03/15/homosexuality-... "Researchers identified nine areas in the genome where genes functioned differently when a twin was homosexual. And the scientists say that they can predict with 70 per cent accuracy whether a man is gay or straight simply by looking at those parts of the genome."
- mamon 9y ago70% you say? I can do even better, about 98% accuracy by saying "straight" every single time :) And what about other 30% of cases, when that genome predictor fails - isn't that an indicator that there are actually multiple causes of homosexuality?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoGenetics of course are not the sole determining factor in expressed traits or conditions; they contribute heavily though, as do environmental factors.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tghgffeee55 9y agoThat's interesting as a data point for biologists or other scholars When it comes to social policy, the only valid position is "who gives a shit?" If a culture is going to concern itself with notions of free assembly and association, and the right to both, there is no room for such distinctions
- shallot_router 9y agoI think the evidence shows the vast majority of cases of homosexuality are genetic in origin, but my understanding is there's some evidence there could also be an environmental role (be it exposure to certain substances or perhaps even how a child is raised) for a certain subset of cases. Research there risks treading into dangerous territory very quickly, since the study could be sensationalized to suggest the researchers are trying to claim that homosexuality is voluntary (which is very different from "environmentally-caused" or "environmentally-influenced"). Same reason why it's dangerous to study what genes may contribute to IQ.
- i386 9y agoI don't care if it's a biological reality or not. I'd like for people to stop scrutinizing my being. My existence is a reality, my reality, and I want people to stop talking about a personal characteristic that is as boring as liking the color green or having red hair.
- hypoctossah 9y agoThank you. I'd wish people would stop scrutinizing my existence as a white male.
- i386 9y agoCool burner account bro
- jameslk 9y agoCensorship is censorship. Biology plays no role in that matter here other than to attempt to justify the censorship. This is not an objective matter, it's subjective. And Facebook has designated themselves as the central authority of what needs to be censored on their platform, thereby controlling speech. We can stop using it sure, just like we could stop using the Internet I guess.
- pulse7 9y agoRegarding homosexuality & choice: How about people going into prison straight (their declaration) and coming out gay (also their declaration)?
- ue_ 9y agoI'd also like to mention this, which may cast doubt on the "gay people are born gay" idea: Children who experience parental divorce are less likely to marry heterosexually than those growing up in intact families; however, little is known about other childhood factors affecting marital choices. We studied childhood correlates of first marriages (heterosexual since 1970, homosexual since 1989) in a national cohort of 2 million 18-49 year-old Danes. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17039403 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17039403
- smt88 9y agoI don't get how your quote (or studies of marriage in general) have anything to do with whether people are born gay.
- ue_ 9y ago>Children who experience parental divorce are less likely to marry heterosexually than those growing up in intact families This would suggest, save for "correlation does not equal causation", that parental divorce has some effect on one's sexuality, or less likely in my opinion, that those who experience parental divorce are more likely to marry homosexually (not because they're gay), though I'm sure we'd both agree that's more far fetched.