3 ms·
Here’s a related experiment: Try counting without “talking.” That is, without saying the numbers in your head. Try tapping on the desk or your lap an arbitrar
by Razengan 9y ago
Here’s a related experiment:
Try counting without “talking.” That is, without saying the numbers in your head.
Try tapping on the desk or your lap an arbitrary number of times without going “1, 2, 3..” and see if you can still know how many times you tapped.
——
Follow-up question: Is language necessary for thought?
Try forming thoughts without forming any words in your head.
You might notice that there’s a much faster “higher priority process” in the head that already “knows” what to say before you “hear” the words of that thought forming in your head..
But there WILL be words. It may seem almost impossible to suppress the formation of words while thinking.
Do “feral children” that grow up without any human contact have the ability to “think?”
——
Also, during inner monologues or what have you, do you refer to yourself in the singular or plural?
e.g., do you go “I should [do that]” or “We should [do that]?”
- bllguo 9y agoYour last question intrigues me. I say "I." I'm curious whether other people use "we"
- Razengan 9y agoI’ve always said “we”, since I was a child, and assumed it was normal.. :)
- mysterydip 9y agoI've heard "you" before as well. As in, "you should go talk to that person before they leave," for example.
- ajkjk 9y agoJust in case it's interesting to anyone: As far as I can tell, the internal 'talking' I do when counting in my head (I was unable to disable it, though I could tap numbers on my fingers without talking just fine) is like a 'test activation' of my speech muscles. The same way you can.. Imagine moving an arm, say, and it feels like it involves a communication with the muscles in your arm but they don't actually fire. Counting feels like it's imagining activating the muscles to say the words for the numbers, without actually doing it.
- mabbo 9y ago> Follow-up question: Is language necessary for thought? Try forming thoughts without forming any words in your head. For three years at University, I studied American sign language (ASL). It changed how I thought. There's a spectrum of how people sign, from straight transliteration of English words to signs, to the other 'pure' side where ASL has a very different grammar and way of communicating. The school I went to taught the 'pure ASL' side, figuring we already know English grammar. When signing, my internal voice was much quieter, or if I did hear it, it was using far fewer words and more ideas. Thinking felt different to me. After I graduated, I moved cities and have rarely needed to sign much since then. But I still sometimes dream in it, strange as that sounds.