11 ms·
Walmart banned alcohol and swearing from Jet's offices and it was a big mistake
- taude 9y agoOur company was acquired by old-school finance firm. They banned alcohol and happy hour beer-Friday's we used to have. It doesn't sound like a big deal, but all the millenials work elsewhere now (especially given the competitive nature of the Boston market for technology talent). I'm not going to put all the blame on the banning of alcohol Fridays, but there was definitely a culture shift, of which this was one thing. Which sucks, because we had some really good coding talent.
- openmosix 9y agoIt happened to us too - acquired by a Finance company, no more alcohol in the office when we had weekly "beer-o-clock" on Friday. I honestly fail to understand why that would be a big deal for people. We still re-group on Friday at 5pm and we all go down to a local bar. I believe company culture is bigger than alcohol and ping pong in the office. As a group, we have maintained our "identity" (and culture) even though our toolchain has changed and we can't have a beer at the desk.
- triangleman 9y agoThe pervasive drinking culture in this country is a problem. More than 5% of the population suffers from alcoholism, and the more drinking is encouraged in the culture, the more likely someone will have a small problem turn into a full blown problem. Young people especially are unlikely to judge their own propensity for alcoholism, so "encouraging a fun workplace culture" is not a good enough reason to use alcohol to attract a younger generation of workers.
- plandis 9y agoWe do Friday happy hour because it's been a reliable method for having multiple teams interact, spread ideas, talk about what they have been working on, etc...
- walshemj 9y agoAmericans drink less then the UK and virtually every eu country - let alone places like Russia. Don't try and project your biases onto 320 Million Americans many of whom come from different cultures
- triangleman 9y agoFine. Can we at least agree that Americans are bad at drinking? Possibly because of the drinking age of 21? It just seems like a foolish idea to put drinks in the hands of 20-somethings who just got out of college and are starting their first or second jobs. I remember investment banks recruiting my business school friends by promoting their heavy drinking culture. I know I'm sounding like a nanny-stater here. But there is a dark underside to this relaxed attitude towards drinking that you ignore at your peril.
- walshemj 9y agoalways struck me as very odd that you could both vote and join the forces but still not be considered adult enough to have a beer
- ck425 9y agoI'd argue the dark underside comes from your puritanical attitude towards drinking. I went to Uni here in the UK with a lot of Americans. What always stood out was how stupidly drunk they got and how proud they were of it, as if they were 14/15. Most of them matured out of it after a year or two. The reason for this as far as I can see is that the US doesn't have a culture of sociable drinking. Drinking is something you do to party or on a date. The concept of social drinking doesn't exist in the US like it does in the EU. No one goes to the pub (you don't even really have pubs or cafes - bars are not the same thing) for a drink or two with friends or colleagues. So young people have no examples of what moderate drinking looks like. People either don't drink or get proper wasted, thus re-enforcing the BS slippery slope argument, thus people drink moderately even less, and a vicious cycle continues.
- triangleman 9y ago
- taude 9y agoI agree with you. But I do think casual drinking affects socializing a lot more than people think. I think most people here now just want to head home at 5 on a Friday. I wonder what would happen if we did something at 2 or 3 instead of end of normal business hours, though. The younger people had more spare time to hang out later, so that probably affects things, too. Edit: the concept of cross-departmental conversations that someone mentions later in this thread is completely gone now, too.
- rorykoehler 9y agoDrinking isn't inclusive. That's why it's a problem.
- ecshafer 9y agoI find it very strange they banned drinking. I work at a large finance company that you have probably heard of, and happy hours are very common and practically encouraged since it helps with team bonding, relieves stress, etc. We even are allowed a beer at lunch if we go out per policy.
- kafkaesq 9y agoWhich sucks, because we had some really good coding talent. On the other hand, you're still in business - right?
- justin_vanw 9y agoSad, grey, big company people can't imagine that anyone could ever be any other way.
- WillPostForFood 9y agosad, grey big company vs drunk cursing bro culture. Maybe there is a middle ground.
- doWhatNow 9y ago...sad, grey, drinking, cursing bro culture?
- munificent 9y agoWell, it is in New Jersey...
- overcast 9y ago'Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.'
- draw_down 9y agoAs the "Elves Leave Middle-Earth - Sodas Are No Longer Free" post mentions, it's not enough to just undo the change. Because the change itself is enough to get people thinking about whether they should stick around. For now, you can drink and swear in the office (I guess). But who knows what other weird changes are looming...
- mabbo 9y ago"Welcome to the family, please change who are you". It's not that they're necessarily wrong- alcohol at the office has a lot of consequences, liability, etc, and discouraging swearing can foster a less aggressive environment. It's just that they should know who and what they were buying. Jet had a culture of its own, and that culture included alcohol and swearing. I read the other day that the founder owns a vineyard, and is a big wine lover, sharing his love with his company. Culture is hard, and critical to any company. Coming in and saying "change your culture" is dangerous, especially with things as visible, noticeable and enjoyable as alcohol. It leaves the question of "what will they change next?".
- Terribledactyl 9y agoBut, does Walmart actually care? I'm not super familiar with the details of the acquisition but I thought it was more landgrab to extend their online presence than acquihire.
- joatmon-snoo 9y agoThe general consensus, I think, is that the acquisition of Jet is Walmart stepping into the online retail space to fight off Amazon.
- gm-conspiracy 9y agoCounterpoint: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Walton#Automobile_incidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Walton#Automobile_incide...
- Someone1234 9y agoI legitimately don't understand the odd obsession in the US with swearing. Do you arbitrarily categorise words as "bad," then you ban such words in a lot of everyday circumstances, and therefore such words are made pointless. Why even have swearing if it cannot be used? Elsewhere in the English speaking world, these are commonly used words with specific emotional attachments, in the US you "offend" people or get gasped at if you utter the forbidden phrases. At least with certain racist phases I can understand the rational. Because you want to "discontinue" those words from existing. Not so with regular swearing.
- jxramos 9y agoI didn't think it was a big deal until I spent significant time around swearers and non-swearers. There is just an ugliness in swearing both in the harsh consonants that intrinsically reflect the ugliness of the words and the general attitudes surrounding the spewing of the words. I remember a non-swearer who shared with me the misperception she often felt was falsely accused on her. This surrounded her use of other words to express frustration or pain or anger or what have you that the underlying emotions of those softer words were curse oriented, just sugar coated or something to that extent. She told me that was a perennial confusion with her, that it just was not the case, her emotions did not reflect the harsh swearing attitudes/content. Pretty interesting thought, I used to think that internally they had all the rage/etc but just repressed it or whatever. I learned apparently cursing does reflect an internal state of one's heart that could very much be lacking entirely in others.
- lbebber 9y ago> There is just an ugliness in [...] the harsh consonants that intrinsically reflect the ugliness of the words I won't comment on the rest of the post, but come on. What is the ugliness in, say, "shit", that is not present in "shot" or "sheet"?
- jxramos 9y agothe logic here is "if curse then harsh", not "if harsh then curse", which raises an interesting question is there a soft curse word? Come to think of it, it's like an emotional mapping to auditory expression, similar to this concept I heard about many years ago https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bouba/kiki_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bouba/kiki_effect
- accountyaccount 9y agoSure, if you want to ban drinking in the workplace I can understand (but don't agree) — it can be a liability. There will be always be a slight risk there, and it's hard to trust everyone in a larger sized company. If my employer tried to enforce a rule as puritanical as "no swearing" my response would be "fuck you."
- WillPostForFood 9y agoThe value of some self control at work isn't puritanical. Replace "fuck you" with "nice ass" or "Have you met Jesus." You don't need to say it, people don't need to hear it, and it can make work more pleasant.
- accountyaccount 9y agoAlright, let's consider that I'd generally not recommend saying "fuck you" to a colleague. What if I say "that's fucking weird" or "that's bullshit" — not really comparable to sexual harassment or pushing religion.
- kafkaesq 9y agoI agree: "Sorry, this is bullshit" is vastly, vastly preferable. Has the advantage of depersonalizing the issue and avoiding the (completely unnecessary) sexual/aggressive overtones -- while still sending an unequivocally clear message (that you also wouldn't necessarily mind being quoted for in the press or in a book, some day).
- chillwaves 9y agoBut curse words offend my god. By not being tolerant to my intolerance, you are the one who is intolerant!
- cirgue 9y agoYou are 100% correct. However, that is something that should be enforced by the norms and values of the human beings on the team, not HR. Cursing isn't bad, it's that cursing can be used to express sentiments and intentions that are bad. If you police words and then say 'ok, my job here is done', you have succeeded in removing a symptom and done nothing to address the cause. Moreover, this gives shitty people a policy wall to hide behind.
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoRelevant blog post from 2009 shared on HN from time to time: "The Elves Leave Middle-Earth - Sodas Are No Longer Free" https://steveblank.com/2009/12/21/the-elves-leave-middle-earth-–-soda’s-are-no-longer-free/ https://steveblank.com/2009/12/21/the-elves-leave-middle-ear...
- jdmichal 9y agoI see this same pattern over and over with talking to people who are leaving a company. There's almost always that "wake up" moment: one singular item which pierces the veil. But it's rarely ever just that one item that causes people to leave, and that one item would probably be tolerated if there weren't other reasons. And the set of those reasons for any two people leaving are not likely to be the same. So, given that: * Leaving is actually an accumulation of these items, * Individuals will have their own distinct list of such items, * Individuals will have differing tolerance levels for waking up... Is there actually any actionable information here other than: "Don't make unpopular decisions?" I mean, sure, in hindsight, on this particular and possibly unusual scenario, a bunch of people woke up with a singular item which had minor impact to the bottom line. Easy to look back and say, "Maybe that was a silly decision." But an employer will always have to make decisions, and some individual will probably find that decision distasteful and add it to their list, and maybe that's finally the item that wakes them up... At what point do you just factor that into cost of making decisions and move on?
- careersuicide 9y ago> Is there actually any actionable information here other than: "Don't make unpopular decisions?" Make sure you actually do a cost-benefit analysis, even if it's just quickly in your head. Decisions like this are the result of seeing a metric and thinking about optimizing just that one metric. It's not easy to sum up costs and benefits of connected policies. And it can be very hard to a priori determine what the costs and benefits are. But when people come to you and complain about a new policy you should probably listen.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoI just don't get that logic: saving $10,000/yr is important, but docking my benefits isn't a great way to do it. If I have 1 soda per day, it's less than 1% of my salary, and I don't necessarily miss it for monetary reasons, but why would I see it as anything besides you slashing my salary/benefits package by a fraction of a percent? Any time your plan to save money is to slash my pay/benefits without warning or negotiation, it's a good sign that I should start looking for employment elsewhere. It's also a fiscally poor choice: the time lost to me debating if I should have a soda (5min; since the choice is non-obvious now that it involves a trip) and going to purchase a drink during the work day (10-15min) costs more than just preemptively buying me a can of soda costs by an order of magnitude. If half of the devs spend 5 minutes a day thinking about drinks now that they're not provided, at a 50 engineer company that's costing 2 hours of developer time a day. Developer time is between $40-100/hr, so you're talking about ~$100/day in lost work because you're not buying 25-50 sodas. Whatever you're saving in soda costs doesn't offset that. (And if they actually leave the office to go get a drink instead, you're tripling that cost.) I just find it odd that they're so focused on what a benefit costs, they don't analyze what it's providing to the company in value (by, in this case, alleviating a related cost).
- TravelTechGuy 9y agoI have no problem with banning alcohol at work. Even though it was present in almost every office I worked at, I failed to see the benefits, and I did witness some of the drawbacks. I have nothing against consuming it, just do it somewhere else, and not near people you'd be embarrassed to work with the next day. As for swearing, I never really understood the PC approach in offices. English is my second language, so English swear words were used daily when I grew up. When I just started working in the US, I had to train myself to avoid uttering 'shit' when something hit the fan. But the I found out some people are offended by 'damn', and 'hell' (will never get that. Do they think they won't go there if they avoid saying it?). So everyone has words that offend them - big whoop. I'm offended by words like 'synergy', 'disrupt' and 'scrum' but I never told people to avoid them near me. However, in certain contexts, swear words can create a negative work environment. Uttering 'fuck' when something hits your foot is completely different than using it as a verb in a story, in front of other employees. As with alcohol - do use, but in moderation, and at the right time and place.
- kelukelugames 9y ago>Uttering 'fuck' when something hits your foot is completely different than using it as a verb in a story, in front of other employees. Maybe the employees didn't demonstrate the same level of judgement. Act like children, get treated like children. Another possibility is they want people near clients and visitors to be more proper. I don't know I hope it's more than just not trusting the employees.
- smcg 9y agoThey probably didn't demonstrate the same level of judgment. Most people are clueless. I have a coworker who uses "fuck you" as a casual insult or joke. Can't get him to stop and no one will make him stop because "he doesn't mean any harm by it".
- ck425 9y agoTo play devils advocate if he doesn't mean any harm by it and everyone's aware he doesn't, is it still an issue?
- Animats 9y agoI'm amazed that companies allow alcohol at work. It has to affect product quality and safety. Nobody in manufacturing allows that.
- serg_chernata 9y agoManufacturing is a tiny bit more dangerous than typing on a keyboard.
- jaclaz 9y agoBanks (where people type on keyboards most of the time) are also AFAIK alcohol-free. And so are Lawyers firms, accountants, and more or less every kind of work involving mostly typing, exception made for some start-ups, possibly limited to the US. A glass of wine or beer at lunch may of course be OK, but surely not drinking in the office or happy hours.
- Falling3 9y agoWhat's the distinction you're drawing between having a drink at lunch and having an office happy hour? The latter certainly seems preferable if we're forced to choose since the workday is essentially over at that point.
- user5994461 9y agohappy hour = unlimited free alcohol for everyone
- derekp7 9y agoThe other exception is advertising firms.
- munificent 9y ago> And so are Lawyers firms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-martini_lunch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-martini_lunch
- bauer 9y agoCached version of the page to get around BI's anti adblock bullshit http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://www.businessinsider.com/walmart-banned-alcohol-and-swearing-from-jets-offices-2017-6 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...
- SmellTheGlove 9y agoI'm not going to even address whether drinking and swearing in the office should or shouldn't be allowed - it's irrelevant. Walmart basically decided that they wanted to buy Jet because Jet had capabilities and talent that they wanted in order to compete with companies like Amazon. It's a major failure on Walmart's part to either not discover, or not understand, that those capabilities and talent exist within a specific corporate culture. The fact that they think they can change it without impacting what they sought to acquire indicates a real lack of understanding of corporate culture. You don't need to drink and swear in the office to do what Jet does, but Jet was built with that as part of its culture, and changing it is going to impact its workforce. Don't acquire a startup for the value of the startup-y things that it's done unless you're in it for the whole package. Otherwise, license what Jet does or become its customer/client in some other way.
- gervase 9y agoI didn't find anything in the article that indicated that the decision was a "big mistake", just that some employees were annoyed. Did this affect their employee turnover? Productivity? Any objectively measurable effect at all? I don't necessarily agree with the decision one way or the other, but this article seems like its pushing a narrative with very little evidence to support it either way.
- pfooti 9y agoI have no strong opinion about the alcohol rule. Personally, I don't drink at work (or work functions) as I have seen the deleterious effects of same. Feels like a liability issue as well. I'm also super-supportive of a harassment policy that prohibits language that is used to harass, be it "profanity" or not. (case in point, many people don't consider the R word to be an official profanity, but I will object to its casual use every time, as it is pretty terrible). All that said, I swear in general, because profanity is really interesting. I moderate my language around people who object to it, sure. But I also do things like use words that sound "dirty" but are not in fact official profanities, or perhaps are marginal. Referring to someone as a "turd hurler", for example, skirts the line. I find it an interesting challenge to develop insults that can be applied to a specific person without pulling in old racist / imperialistic / patriarchal (&c.) tropes. Further, actual semiotic disruption is also fun. I've trained myself that the phrase "man cave", for example, is a profane reference to a portion of a gentleman's anatomy. "Let me show you my man cave" is a much more hilarious and interesting phrase these days. The creation and evolution of profanity as a socially-negotiated construct (especially those profane words that are titillatingly transgressive but not so inherently evil that they mark one for immediate ostracizing) is pretty amazing. This is kind of related to my own walmart experience. As a teenager, I worked for a warehouse club (pace) which was bought out by sam's, the walmart of warehouse clubs. Suddenly I had to cover my earrings with a bandaid (as I was male with earrings, and such couldn't display such a terrible thing to the clients). I quit instead, but spent a lot of time thinking about dress codes since - they (and fashion in general) are another fascinating (and frankly under-appreciated by the tech crowd) channel by which meaning is negotiated. I may think a dress code is stupid, but the person who puts stock in it is instead thinking I think that person is stupid. Which isn't my intended meaning, but communication is a two-way street and only possible when both sides understand the shared context. Anyway. It's possible to ban a list of words, but it is not feasible to ban profanity as such. It is a far better strategy to build a code of conduct that is predicated on respect and mutual support. Ban harassing and insulting behaviors, rather than certain words, and you'll show that you care about the central concept rather than the surface features.
- laurentb 9y agowhat's the R word you mention? (serious question)
- Lord_Zero 9y agoSurprised to see all the comments about how alcohol should be banned at work. To be fair most of the commentors that said this said "I've witness its drawbacks." I have a beer at my desk during lunch every now and then, especially if I am working through my lunch as I eat. And every now and then if I know I have to work late ill crack one at 5pm while I work. The other company in my building also has frequent at-work happy hours (after office close at 5pm, sometimes at 4pm) and everyone seems to be responsible and have fun. In the end I think its all about showing you can be an adult, and not holding up the intern for a keg stand or slamming tequila shots.
- slavik81 9y agoOne of the more memorable articles from The Economist was on this topic. "The boredom of boozeless business: The sad demise of the three-Martini lunch" http://www.economist.com/node/21560265 http://www.economist.com/node/21560265
- mattkevan 9y agoHa, I'm not surprised. Walmart seem to have a tin ear for any culture not their own. As a student I worked for ASDA, a UK supermarket chain, while it was bought by Walmart. Management decreed we had to do a team power huddle at the start of each shift, like we were American Football players or something instead of bored teenagers on minimum wage. It was excruciating. Everyone hated it, from management down. I think the policy lasted a week before everyone gave up in sheer embarrassment.
- anth1988 9y agoI get alcohol, that's reasonable. What the frack kind of software place won't let you swear.
- nibstwo 9y agoDoes this affect customers? Alcohol somewhat, swearing in office but not with customers no. Therefore, no swearing is a stupid policy to change, limited cultural benefit high cognitive tax. Alcohol in the office has really harmed one company I worked at, and no one missed the omission when it is not there. I understand when you are a two person team and your kitchen fridge has beers, but a giant company pretending to be that instead of people just getting alcohol when out makes no sense. Just go to a bar and pay for it yourself.
- noonespecial 9y agoIts like buying a Ferrari because its fast and cool and then filling it with diesel because that's what all your other delivery vehicles run on.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoLast time I was in Hoboken, "Thank You" and "Fuck You" were used interchangeably.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoFunny story, when IBM acquired Blekko one of the things we had to do was show them we weren't keeping any alcohol on premise[1], even in the machine room. Apparently they didn't have a problem with copies of 'Modern Drunkard' on the coffee table in the lounge area though :-). [1] There was an excellent scotch collection that had to go, and some Corona's that had been providing thermal mass in the drinks refrigerator for years.
- Nelkins 9y agoThis is basically a non-story. And also a horrible click bait headline. There was extremely minimal chafing during the brief ban on alcohol in the office. Prior to the Walmart purchase I very rarely saw anyone drinking in the office when it wasn't a company sponsored happy hour, and NEVER saw anyone drinking before 5PM (still haven't). People were a little miffed because no one likes having privileges taken away, even if they aren't using them. I also think that people were barely aware of the no-swearing rule...I didn't even know it existed until I read this article! Seriously, how is it even enforceable? Edit: Last thing. Even if either of these things had been strictly enforced, it wouldn't have changed things much around here. We don't have a culture of heavy drinking/swearing. We DO have a culture of trusting people though, which is what bothered some employees. Source: I am a Jet employee.
- everdayimhustln 9y agoFuck Walmart, booze afterhours on Friday is de rigueur.