4 ms·
> I think this is a really thorough mea culpa which is quite impressive It took almost 6 months of badgering for that to finally happen though, despite an exte
by masklinn 9y ago
> I think this is a really thorough mea culpa which is quite impressive
It took almost 6 months of badgering for that to finally happen though, despite an extensive and widely signed (by experts) op-ed pointing out how wrong and dangerous it was barely a week after the original article was published, and calls for corrections/retractions started within days if not hours.
> given the frequent failure of other newspapers to publish a prominent apology when they have got things far more wrong than this.
Getting things "far more wrong" matters less when it doesn't put lives at stakes, and you don't need to believe me on that, this correction article makes that point:
> During the review I independently confirmed that a Turkish government official had used the article when, in effect, attempting to deter users from WhatsApp.
- Osmium 9y ago> It took almost 6 months of badgering for that to finally happen though, despite an extensive and widely signed (by experts) op-ed pointing out how wrong and dangerous it was barely a week after the original article was published, and calls for corrections/retractions started within days if not hours. Completely agreed, but they do fully concede this in their retraction: >This made a relatively small, expert, vocal and persistent audience very angry. Guardian editors did not react to an open letter co-signed by 72 experts in a way commensurate with the combined stature of the critics and the huge number of people potentially affected by the story. It might have taken a while for their internal review to complete but, honestly, what more can we ask for but an honest admission like this? If more media outlets could meet this standard we'd be in a much better place.
- shallot_router 9y ago>what more can we ask for but an honest admission like this? We can ask people to simply not trust traditional newspapers for reporting on stories concerning highly technical and scientific fields.
- blowski 9y agoWho should we trust? Business Insider? TechCrunch? They all get it wrong sometimes. We should be equally sceptical of all sources of news.
- shallot_router 9y agoYes, we should be skeptical of all news sources, but from my experience, traditional newspapers tend to consistently misreport information security news. I personally only trust security blogs and Twitters operated by certain security experts when it comes to news about security. I have a list of about 30 or so experts I trust. I know that's not really practical advice for a typical person, though. I think the Guardian handled the retraction and apology as best they could, and they deserve props for that, but it seems the hit-miss ratio for infosec stories is very poor for most "mainstream" sources out there (as much as I despise the "MSM" term).
- Angostura 9y agoWhich other infosec stories did the Guardian screw up?
- shallot_router 9y agoI don't read it, but just from a quick glance, this headline is misleading: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/jun/07/russian-hackers-qatar-crisis-fbi-inquiry-saudi-arabia-uae https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/jun/07/russian-hacker... >An investigation by the FBI has concluded that Russian hackers were responsible for sending out fake messages from the Qatari government, sparking the Gulf’s biggest diplomatic crisis in decades. >It is believed that the Russian government was not involved in the hacks; instead, freelance hackers were paid to undertake the work on behalf of some other state or individual. They could've easily made the headline "FBI: Qatar hackers of Russian nationality". By making the first 2 words of the headline "Russian hackers", they're obviously trying to take advantage of the recent surge in reports over Russian state-sponsored hacking. Most readers who see that headline are going to assume they meant "Russian state hackers", until they read the second paragraph. That said, I don't see any factual errors in the article itself.
- idlewords 9y agoIt's not a retraction.
- misterhtmlcss 9y agoAgreed! Could they have come back to us faster, yes, but an honest, well thought through apology with all these details included is a really strong response and I'm not going to complain. We can always complain about why not this or that, but it seems we are never satisfied even when we get what we want.