4 ms·
C-f Jaynes Nothing. Modern psychology needs to come to grips with The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind. A trove of riches for an
by bitwize 9y ago
C-f Jaynes
Nothing.
Modern psychology needs to come to grips with The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind. A trove of riches for anyone interested in practical psychology.
- lukasb 9y agoIt's uh ... speculative to say the least. But it's a fantastic read.
- Cozumel 9y agoNice! Was going to leave this comment myself.
- Phemist 9y agoOne of my thoughts as well. Also _hallucinations_ by Oliver Sacks.
- Mediterraneo10 9y agoThat's like saying that archaeology needs to come to grips with Erich von Däniken. It's not as if modern scholars are oblivious to Jaynes’ ideas. They have been examined, but they have been found wanting.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoDo you know of any specific critiques of Jaynes' ideas? I'd be very interested to read them.
- anigbrowl 9y agoHis (tentative and ancillary) neurological conjectures haven't worked out. The main ideas have not been engaged with or found wanting;there is no prevailing theory of consciousness, and psychology as taught and practiced in the US is laughably reductionistic and has never shaken off the influence of behaviorism. Western science treats the brain as an organ amounting to little more than a set of synaptic reflexes to be either drugged or trained. A 'healthy' mind is is equated with an untroubled economically productive one, and there's no real theory of experience or identity. Thinkers like Sacks, Dennett, and Hofstatder are well-respected but have little visible influence on the practice of psychology, and the field as a whole is treated as a sideshow in the intellectual carnival. Admittedly the Us does not have a strong public intellectual discourse so I may be looking innovative thinkers who are confined to the academy and have difficulty reaching a wider audience.
- bllguo 9y agonever a fan of people saying "X field is missing out on Y book" it's naive, and it's disrespectful to the field and its experts to claim that a book intentionally written to be accessible to laymen can invalidate the work of specialists.