3 ms·
Indeed, that's the single best book to start with. E.g. the very first chapter, the "One Lesson" (on the Broken window fallacy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Br
by hga 16y ago
Indeed, that's the single best book to start with. E.g. the very first chapter, the "One Lesson" (on the Broken window fallacy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_window_fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_window_fallacy) will right off explain to you why "Cash For Clunkers" was such a clunker.
(Ignoring the solid principle that accelerating future economic activity fails when the future inevitably arrives, something we're seeing right now in US residential real estate.)
- mkramlich 16y agoA lot of people think that the Cash for Clunkers program was actually the single most effective element of the recent US stimulation bill. It really did contribute to a burst in actual buying of products, thus, economic activity. Whereas despite all the money made available to financial institutions there did not seem to be a follow-on rise in new or extended credit for businesses and individuals; if anything, it got worse afterward. What is the argument for why the CfC program was bad or ineffective?
- hga 16y ago"It really did contribute to a burst in actual buying of products, thus, economic activity." Which it took from future sales. Whether it's better or worse than financial institution measures has nothing to do with whether it was good or bad. If they were both bad and it was less bad, it's still bad. The argument that it was bad is ... the broken window fallacy. Perfectly fine working cars that could have been sold to people who can't afford new ones were destroyed (the engine oil replaced with a chemical solution that destroyed it after running for a short period of time).