4 ms·
> You spend less time gathering and eating and free up time for thinking. I think it's the other way around. We got bigger brains in the first place because ou
by ekianjo 9y ago
> You spend less time gathering and eating and free up time for thinking.
I think it's the other way around. We got bigger brains in the first place because our ancestors discovered fire and were able to eat cook foods that provide more calories. Therefore they progressively were able to sustain larger and larger brains. A gorilla for example has one of the largest brains for primate and they need to spend most of their days foraging in order to function. A human brain would be impossible to sustain without cooked foods.
- ccozan 9y agoIndeed, the brain consumes about 20-25% of the energy and dissipates around 40% of the body heat. ( I swear I need of of those [0], my head - short hair nonetheless - is sweating like hell in the night ) [0] https://www.amazon.com/Mediflow-1006-06-Original-Waterbase-Pillow/dp/B003J372NS/ https://www.amazon.com/Mediflow-1006-06-Original-Waterbase-P...
- mysterypie 9y ago> A human brain would be impossible to sustain without cooked foods. How do we explain the survival of people that eat only raw foods even today? Wouldn't that argue against your theory? I suppose we're speaking about a population and that there will be individual exceptions. But even in a population, shouldn't raw food eaters die sooner or be worse off than cooked food eaters on average?
- CuriouslyC 9y agoOne problem with that is the fact that people (at least in the west) who choose to eat raw food are usually health conscious and comparably affluent. This biases the sample. Furthermore, the issue is complicated by the effects on adults vs children.
- steve_adams_86 9y agoI guess it could be argued that raw food dieters now have access to rich foods like oils, avocados, sprouted legumes and grains, nuts and seeds, etc. That makes the diet far easier than it would have been even 100 years ago, I think. I'm not in favor or opposed to the person you're responding to. Just thinking about how humans eating a raw diet are different from other animals doing so.
- ac29 9y agoRight, humans have a massive global supply chain available to them. The variety of foods available to a raw food dieter probably come from multiple continents and travel hundreds or thousands of miles to get to them. Obviously the energy expenditure required makes this sort of diet (and really any modern diet) unsustainable on just the calories consumed by eating.
- lostmsu 9y agoThe "even today" part destroys the entire question. Obviously, you would not survive on uncooked food 400 years ago as there were no refrigerators (unless you were a king or something, and even then).
- InitialLastName 9y agoPeople don't tend to survive on a raw diet, in the evolutionary sense. I don't see anything scientific at the moment (because studying diet is hard + pre-coffee apathy), but an internet search for "raw food menstruation" indicates that the most common next word is "stops". "Survival," in the evolutionary sense, doesn't just mean "living into old age" but "reproducing successfully", which paused menses preclude.
- alphydan 9y ago> Therefore they progressively were able to sustain larger and larger brains. As far as I know, that's not how evolution works. You don't get a feature just because you can sustain it. There's a random mutation and everybody who doesn't get it dies or fails to have offspring. So in your theory, what was the mutation (or phenotype) and what was the environmental pressure that killed off the non-mutants? And how does it relate to using fire?