6 ms·
"A fire department permit worker told Tortosa that it would take him two to four weeks to even look at Robin’s paperwork — or, for $536 ($134 per hour of overti
by jjeaff 9y ago
"A fire department permit worker told Tortosa that it would take him two to four weeks to even look at Robin’s paperwork — or, for $536 ($134 per hour of overtime with a four-hour minimum), Tortosa could pay for him to look at it right now."
Can someone please explain to me how this isn't extortion and bribery?
- phonon 9y agoThe SFPD would be happy to look into it in two to four weeks... or for $536 ($134 per hour of overtime with a four-hour minimum), they can look at it right now... /s
- techsupporter 9y ago> Can someone please explain to me how this isn't extortion and bribery? Easy: it's part of the "pay per use" idea that a lot of people seem to think that government should have. Just like express toll lanes or a $7 express bus along side a $3.25 local with three times as many stops, if you want something and don't care how long it takes, choose the low- or no-cost option. If you want it RIGHT DANG NOW, choose the high-cost option. It's not bribery, it's just business...and people seem to think that government should operate like a business, so we get this fee-for-service setup.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoWell then there should be competition. Lol. We could write software that would probably handle that way more efficiently.
- chillydawg 9y agoAnd it would never get deployed as you'd get union'd into nothingness.
- curiousgal 9y ago>It's just business It would be that if your tax money wasn't already paying for the guy's job. I see it as blatant bribery.
- xapata 9y ago> paying for the guy's job The taxes pay for a certain pace of work. Faster work requires more parallelism (more employees or better software) and thus more taxes.
- dragonwriter 9y agoTax dollars are paying for the regular work on the FIFO queue; satisfying the expedite request without impacting the regular work on the FIFO queue requires additional hours of work to be done in the same time, which costs money that the taxpayers, through representatives, have elected not to pay for. Rather than prohibiting such extra work outright, they permit it to be done, at the requesters expense. It's a two-tiered system that favors those with more resources to expend, but it's not bribery.
- jjeaff 9y agoI'll be very surprised if anyone is actually pulling overtime to get your paperwork done. My guess is they just put it to front of the line and work continues as usual, overtime or not.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoEven a business won't allow that. We are not talking about a business or a government agency charging more for expedited service. We are talking about individual employees doing it. You think a company will allow the sysadmin to personally charge people $500 extra to get their work done faster? They would be fired immediately.
- xapata 9y agoBut a sysadmin who frequently upsells customers for a $500 higher-tier service agreement might get a raise. To wit: "Would you like fries with that?"
- yongjik 9y ago...Or we could raise tax so that a fire department can maintain enough personnel to handle paperwork in a timely fashion, while still doing the primary job of keeping people from dying. Either way, somebody's gotta pay the bill.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Can someone please explain to me how this isn't extortion and bribery? Charging a service fee directly based on the additional cost to the agency, that goes to the agency to pay the costs rather than benefiting a decision-maker personally isn't extortion or bribery. Now, one can certainly debate whether such user fees are a good idea, but that's a different question.
- ant6n 9y agoThe decision maker is getting the juicy overtime pay.
- dragonwriter 9y agoI am presuming that the decision-maker instituting the policy is not the one doing the work, even if the individual informing you of the policy is. (And, generally, decision-makers authorized to make policy of this type wouldn't be eligible for overtime pay, in the first place.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mjevans 9y agoIt's more tragedy of the commons. (Though yeah, it's right up to the line.) I guess that's another way of describing NIMBY. Focusing only on the short term pennies society misses the overall value in actually having proper capacity for growth and spike uses. It's that same kind of decision that tries to use overtime from other shifts to cover the gap of a worker's vacation (instead of actually having enough coverage that vacation is built in). I suspect the same effect also contributes to shafting part time workers who "can't get hours" or who get massively screwed (because they're not friends with the boss doing the scheduling).
- pc86 9y agoThis has nothing to do with NIMBY.
- cossatot 9y agoI agree with the comments stating that paperwork is not the fire department's main task they may already be at capacity, therefore this is a way to expedite the process. Furthermore almost any endeavor that requires permitting takes a lot of time and a lot of waiting. Paying a few hundred dollars to make it happen 2-4 weeks more quickly is a screaming deal, especially for a business.
- crazy1van 9y agoIt depends on if the employee is truly too busy to handle this permit within the next 2-4 weeks or whether he just puts an arbitrary hold on all permits unless they pay the overtime fee.
- andrewfong 9y agoFWIW, this isn't a one-off sketchy employee thing. It's actually an official city-sanctioned process. You can find the form for this online. http://sf-fire.org/file/2156 http://sf-fire.org/file/2156 (PDF). SF's not the only one that does this either. Delaware, for instance, offers one-hour expedited filing for some things if you're willing to pay $1000 ( https://corp.delaware.gov/expserv.shtml https://corp.delaware.gov/expserv.shtml).
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoThanks for posting the link. I am actually fine with this. In my reading of the article it seemed to be a sketchy one-off employee thing. I will amend my previous posts.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoWell, honestly, that doesn't seem all that unfair. If the department is busy - or is known to have emergencies that drain resources - a 2-4 week timeframe for looking at it seems reasonable. The very way they move someone up to the front of the line is by pushing other things aside, and possibly having folks work overtime to finish those very things no time. It would be reasonable to charge for such a thing. It really isn't much different from paying an extra fee to get a package more quickly or paying an extra fee to skip lines at airports or theme parks.