6 ms·
During a team review last year, I remember mentioning that I wasn't "excited" by work per se, but that I didn't expect nor desire excitement from work. For me,
by klodolph 9y ago
During a team review last year, I remember mentioning that I wasn't "excited" by work per se, but that I didn't expect nor desire excitement from work. For me, books, traveling, and music are exciting, and I get a sense of value and self-worth from the relationships I build with other people. But I work in a big tech firm. A coworker of mine actually questioned whether I was in the right field, saying that a lot of the successful people in our industry are excited by work. I can't remember his exact wording.
Maybe I'd be able to work harder if I wrapped my self-worth up in my work, but I saw what that kind of attitude did to my father. He would come home drained and tired, and wouldn't be available during the week to do something like watch a TV show together. On the other hand, my mother had a fulfilling job, but she didn't have the same kind of emotional stake in it. She turned down a promotion because while it would have advanced her career, it wouldn't have served her interests as an individual.
"I understand it’s very unhealthy, but I base my self-worth off the success of my job." That's the quote at the bottom of the article. There's a gulf between knowing something is unhealthy and building a healthy life for yourself, something I wish more people would respect.
- JusticeJuice 9y agoHonestly, I think it's healthy to not view work as part of yourself - but I think the people who do, know that as well. I've got a job offer for a very nice job, doing software development next month. The pays great, the people, the are great. However, I'm desperately looking for a product design job - because it's 100% my dream. I am fully aware that it's not healthy to tie my self worth to my job, and I should focus on financial stability, and work / life ratio. But i'd just feel so unfulfilled, and at the end of the day, I just can't help it. Being excited to get up in the morning and go to work, also means getting hurt when it goes wrong.
- klodolph 9y agoIt's a perfectly valid decision to make, but I have a couple reservations. First, when you say that it's 100% your dream, I can't accept that assertion at face value. Maybe this is cynical on my part, but the fact that your dream lines up so neatly with our cultural definitions of what it means to be successful is too suspicious to be a coincidence. So my cynical take on it would be that much your dream was given to you by other people, and only a small portion of it is truly yours. (There are rabbit holes here, for sure.) My second reservation is that it's meaningless to "accept" that something is unhealthy without a solid understanding of the consequences of unhealthy behavior. I can accept the unhealthy consequences of eating a donut, because they're broadly familiar to me (an expanding waistline, elevated risk of heart disease in my future). I know people who have had heart attacks, I know people who are too heavy to comfortably hike the trails I love. But it's meaningless to accept that pouring yourself into your work is unhealthy unless you understand what the consequences are. I have friends who can barely enjoy being retired, even though they didn't really "enjoy" working, either. I have friends who have been depressed and unable to enjoy life for months after project failures. And I know people who have had panic attacks at school or work, panic attacks bad enough to call an ambulance. There is no definition of free will that everyone can agree on, but in my book, understanding the consequences of our actions, and the ability to change our decisions as our understanding of consequences changes, are requirements for exercising free will.
- resu_nimda 9y agoPeople have a tendency to project themselves onto others and poorly conceive of the fact that it's ok for people to be different. Someone that "lives to work" and someone that "works to live" should be able to work together without thinking something is wrong with the other.
- metaphor 9y ago> He would come home drained and tired, and wouldn't be available during the week to do something like watch a TV show together. Have you ever sincerely asked him if he did it because he had to or because it was his genuinely wanted to? Some people may find the latter to be absurd, but I'm usually the same way during the weekdays.
- klodolph 9y ago> Have you ever sincerely asked him if he did it because he had to or because it was his genuinely wanted to? The line between "had to" and "wanted to" is hard to see, because we internalize extrinsic motivation. However, I don't think the distinction between "had to" and "wanted to", or the distinction between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, is a useful distinction in and of itself. Rather, I would like to understand the reasons people have for their decisions, whether they had foreknowledge of the consequences, whether they had false beliefs that contributed to the decision, and for what reasons they think they made the right or wrong decision. Perhaps that's just my perspective, but if I think he made the wrong decision, the fact that he wanted to make the wrong decision doesn't change that. And my judgment that a decision is right or wrong is based on decades of experience and earnest conversations that we still have to this day. And underneath all that is my own system of values, which in my experience outlasts all my wants or desires. Rather than understanding whether I want to pour a bunch of energy into my work, I would rather understand how I judge the value of work compared to other things in life, because that judgment will stick with me longer than a fleeting desire. And to further clarify things, I don't think it's wrong to make a decision on the basis of your own desires, but just that desires are an inferior basis for decisions. I'm sure I haven't answered your question, but I hope this is a satisfactory explanation.
- metaphor 9y ago> ...just that desires are an inferior basis for decisions. Inferior in what sense? I don't see that there's any other sensible basis for the decisions we make, regardless of outcome. Adhering to a reasoned system of values sounds fundamentally like a driving desire in itself; some desires are simply less tangible than others.
- Mikeb85 9y agoA chef is a kind of artisan. It also pays poorly for the amount of training that goes into it, the amount of work required daily, and all the risks. It definitely takes a certain type of individual, and is a pointless career if you don't care about job satisfaction. But also keep in mind, job satisfaction means you provide a service where you make people happy, and can interact with your guests and see their happiness every day. You're not just a cog in a giant machine extracting money from advertisers or whatever.
- klodolph 9y agoThe only real difference here is that software engineers make enough money and have enough stability that they can overlook an unfulfilling role or other problems. There's nothing about the roles that makes one or the other more satisfying or more like a cog in a giant machine. Speaking as someone who's worked in both roles professionally.