5 ms·
I was just reading about stellarators in the book "A Piece of the Sun" [1] about the history of fusion. I find it fascinating (and a bit worrying) they are stil
by dmix 9y ago
I was just reading about stellarators in the book "A Piece of the Sun" [1] about the history of fusion. I find it fascinating (and a bit worrying) they are still basically attempting to optimize the same two approaches that were developed in the 50s/60s, tokamak and stellarator.
I respect the scientists who continue to work on this. Many people have spent their whole careers on it and have died without making significant progress. It's inherently challenging because it's super expensive and working at super high temperatures. But the potential of the end goal might be enough to keep people working on it perpetually.
[1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/1468304933/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/1468304933/
- dom0 9y agoFusion is simple — practically primitive — whereas plasma physics is insanely-mind-numbingly difficult. To sustain a fusion process, plasma physics have to be tamed. That's the hard part. The Wendelstein 7-X, which the article is about, can't even do fusion, it's entirely about plasma physics.
- msie 9y agoThe old guard has to die off before a new approach can be tried.
- colordrops 9y agoWhat are the new approaches being ignored or staved off by the old guard?
- benpbenp 9y ago> But the potential of the end goal might be enough to keep people working on it perpetually. Working on it perpetually, you say? If only we could somehow harness that energy...
- lovemenot 9y agoWe can in principle. But so far the energy to operate their harness matrix exceeds their work output.
- saalweachter 9y agoI am fascinated by the class of problems it is worth spending your life working on only to fail.
- lovemenot 9y agoPerhaps you could research these a little deeper ...
- Sir_Substance 9y agoThere are a bunch of other interesting ideas out there as well. There's the polywell, my personal favorite, which uses a powerful electric field to confine the fuel: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polywell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polywell (You can make a kind of shitty version of this in your garage with two microwaves, some thick wire and a healthy dose of personal risk: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusor ) There's the Dense Plasma Focus, one version of which is being developed by Lawrenceville Plasma Physics. They're cool dudes, I once donated $10 to help them get a new Beryllium cathode about three years ago, they still send me periodic and detailed updates on their progress. You can read about their approach here, complete with radical 90's theme and pretty good video: http://lppfusion.com/fusion-power/dpf-device/ http://lppfusion.com/fusion-power/dpf-device/ Sandia National Laboratories is using a massive Marx generator [1] to power the Z-Machine, a Z-pinch that uses powerful magnetic fields generated by high current to squeeze matter in the middle of a conductor: http://www.sandia.gov/z-machine/research/fusion.html http://www.sandia.gov/z-machine/research/fusion.html This approach is known as ICF, and is also being pursued by the National Ignition Facility, who use lasers instead: https://lasers.llnl.gov/science/icf/how-icf-works https://lasers.llnl.gov/science/icf/how-icf-works So there's a few different ideas out there. However, if you really want to know why no significant progress has been made[2] you need only look at this graph: https://imgur.com/sjH5r https://imgur.com/sjH5r Note that it has a citation at the bottom, you should follow it and read the article to see that this isn't a bullshit internet chart. In the US at least, fusion has been consistently funded at a rate that the US government /knows/ is too low to see significant progress. You're welcome to make your own guesses on why this is the case. [1] My second favorite thing in HV equipment after the explosively pumped flux compression generator: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx_generator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marx_generator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explosively_pumped_flux_compression_generator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explosively_pumped_flux_compre... [2] I'm not sure this is really the case. I think that the fusion research community has made admirable progress under trying circumstances.
- dmix 9y ago> (You can make a kind of shitty version of this in your garage with two microwaves, some thick wire and a healthy dose of personal risk: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusor ) This reminded me of that guy who tried splitting atoms in his apartment in Sweden in 2011. Turns out last year in 2016 the police came back again because someone told them off he had Uranium. They shut down the whole neighbourhood and didn't let him come home for a full day while they searched it with a bomb squad and radiation team: https://richardsreactor.blogspot.ca/2016/04/20160401-and-again.html https://richardsreactor.blogspot.ca/2016/04/20160401-and-aga... Risky stuff to do in this age of over reaction.
- petters 9y agoBoth the article and that book compares "human fusion" to the sun. But there are surprising differences. In fact, the sun generates less energy per volume than a compost. It's all about the scaling of the surface area vs. the volume.
- AnimalMuppet 9y ago> In fact, the sun generates less energy per volume than a compost. Though the sun can keep it up far longer than a compost can... > It's all about the scaling of the surface area vs. the volume. If I understand that statement correctly, would it be easier to create a fusion reactor if we made it bigger?
- nnfy 9y ago>would it be easier to create a fusion reactor if we made it bigger? Absolutely-but only when you approach mass scales on par with small suns. So not in a practical sense. To elaborate, plasma in stellar bodies is essentially contained by gravity, as opposed to complex electroomagnetic fields that have to be painstakingly engineered and tend to be unstable.
- ajuc 9y agoWhat if we made a small black hole and put plasma in orbit?
- petters 9y agoA small black hole would probably glow very bright by itself, so it could be a useful energy source in orbit (for a while, until it crashes into Earth).
- dredmorbius 9y agoObjects in orbit don't suddenly stop being in orbit. There's no reason a black hole would de-orbit into Earth. And if it did, it would largely continue to orbit through the Earth, or what bits of it remained following passage. That said, I don't suspect the approach would be particularly viable.
- theothermkn 9y ago> I find it fascinating (and a bit worrying) they are still basically attempting to optimize the same two approaches that were developed in the 50s/60s, tokamak and stellarator. This would be a bit like worrying that aerospace engineers are still optimizing wings. Like wings, tokomaks/stellarators are the best tools for the job, as dictated by the underlying physics of the systems in question. Basically, donut-shaped magnetically-confined plasmas "leak" into themselves, rather than out into the world. > Many people have spent their whole careers on it and have died without making significant progress. This is a popular view that is entirely wrong. The figure of merit, which is the triple product of confinement time, density, and temperature, outpaced Moore's law right up until a gain of about 0.95, when the magnetic technology of the day caused the necessary size increase to put ITER in the realm of international cooperation. ITER absolutely will produce more power than it consumes. The plasma physics are just that well understood. The problem is size. MIT have recently worked out that a new breed of superconducting magnets can more than double the available field strength, resulting in a 16-fold reduction in reactor size (due to a 4th power gain in confinement strength as a function of field strength). They hope to achieve a gain of about 2 with a university-scale reactor before ITER, designed with the magnets available at the time, is complete. Most, if not all, of the above comes from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0KuAx1COEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0KuAx1COEk. ARC and SPARC, the MIT reactor concepts, are the most exciting thing I've heard about in...gosh, I guess my whole life. They could pull it off. If they do, we could save the planet with fusion-powered CO2 scrubbing. We could avert disaster.
- Razengan 9y ago> Many people have spent their whole careers on it and have died without making significant progress. I wonder... if there are entire domains of technology that simply -cannot- be achieved without AI – machines building and improving themselves. We have already seen problems that simply cannot be solved within the lifetime of humans or in terrestrial environments, like telescopes in space vs. those on ground, or crossing long distances in "generation spaceships.."
- wiz21c 9y agoyou seem to mix the time it takes to bring a solution to the problem, with the invention of the solution itself. For me, AI is just another tool on top of others. You can't build an AI to, say, control a plasma without a thorough understanding of plasma physics (acquired without the use of AI)... So I'd say AI may be useful, but not in the sense that it will bring a breakthrough...
- dredmorbius 9y agoI'm not entirely sure that's the case. It's occurred to me that AI might actually represent a form of nonscientific capability. That is, the ability to achieve results but without the understanding or structured knowledge that we consider to be part of science. That's not saying that AI will solve the problem, just what the situation might be should it do so. I'm still trying to wrap my head around what it actually does itself.