3 ms·
> That is probably what HN was trying to tell you (well, I hope it was IIRC, the push back was against taking what his dad assumed was the cause as gospel with
by kbenson 9y ago
> That is probably what HN was trying to tell you (well, I hope it was
IIRC, the push back was against taking what his dad assumed was the cause as gospel without actual evidence. It's tricky, you want to respect the person that was ill knew something about what was going on, and respect their memory after they are gone, but there's really no reason we should provide them more factual relevance than previously. Human beings are often not rational creatures, and I see no reason to believe that the stress of illness and possible impending death would make them more rational in general (even if it may make certain individuals more or less rational).
- pc86 9y ago> you want to respect the person that was ill knew something about what was going on > and respect their memory after they are gone Dead people can be wrong. That's totally okay - it doesn't tarnish their memory in the slightest. And just because you're the one that's ill doesn't mean you suddenly have greater medical insight or training. Me getting cancer doesn't give me the slightest idea what caused it.