4 ms·
For the requirements you correctly identified - very long service times, very strict reliability requirements, etc, I think it's insane to rely on a closed sour
by adrianN 9y ago
For the requirements you correctly identified - very long service times, very strict reliability requirements, etc, I think it's insane to rely on a closed source operating system in the first place. With open source you can always hire some programmers to fix bugs. With Windows you're at the mercy of Microsoft.
- Silhouette 9y agoIf ever there were a situation where that argument didn't apply, surely this is it. This is a multi-billion project, in the defence sector, for a major US ally. So for one thing, it seems very likely that someone involved in the carrier project does have access to all the relevant Windows source and build infrastructure, one way or another. Relevant Microsoft staff have probably been checked as well. In any case, obviously you can't install some OSS and then just "hire some programmers" to fix bugs in this environment. Using Windows on naval vessels is not unprecedented. The US Navy "Windows for Warships" situation showed that it is already done, and sometimes problems are then found in trials, and those problems do then have to be fixed.
- eli 9y agoMicrosoft makes the source of Windows available to partners and big customers. Just not for free.
- dom0 9y ago> With open source you can always hire some programmers to fix bugs. That might work for changing the text on a web site running Drupal 6 ten years later, but thinking that this sentence makes any sense when you're talking about a huge distributed system ported from probably some commercial Unix-like or even bare-metal Ada or whatever to NT then that's just a very naive sentiment.
- adrianN 9y agoIt's expensive, sure, but it's at least possible.
- maxxxxx 9y agoPossible maybe, but highly unrealistic.
- kijin 9y agoSpeaking of which, a commercial Unix might actually be the best choice for these kinds of systems. The Royal Navy has the budget and bargaining power to sign a multi-decade support contract from the likes of IBM, HP, and Oracle. The latter already offers 24 years of support for the latest series of Solaris; maybe they can add another dozen years on top of that if you throw enough money in their general direction. By contrast, no version of Windows has been supported for more than 13 years (though they might also offer special long-term contracts), and most flavors of Linux only get 5-10 years.