8 ms·
> (...) connecting our users with thousands of advertisers, large and small, in ways that are useful for both. We truly live in the age of spinning, of euphemi
by andrepd 9y ago
> (...) connecting our users with thousands of advertisers, large and small, in ways that are useful for both.
We truly live in the age of spinning, of euphemisms, where words lose all their meaning. All-pervasive advertising, the most insidious technique of consumer capitalism, is now an idealistic connecting of people (why, rather than fining us indeed they should be thanking thanking us for that, they seem to say). Complete invasion of privacy and control over content and information reaching the person is "enhancing the user experience", etc etc.
- tfcata 9y agoAnd as Apple 're-defines' a couple of things each year.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hoorayimhelping 9y agoI'd encourage you (and everyone) to read the comments in the other thread happening today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14643712 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14643712 You'll see people baffled by this decision and generally happy with the service and products google offers. It's just a reminder to remember that what doesn't work for you may be pure bliss for other people.
- walterstucco 9y agoMob in Italy is pure bliss for a lot of people. It's still a bad thing.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoYou seem to have replied to the wrong comment. I've read through the other thread, I couldn't find a comment that agrees with "connecting our users with thousands of advertisers, large and small, in ways that are useful for both."
- jasode 9y agoTo me, the comment from theBobBob agrees with the convenience of Google search connecting users to advertisers: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14644022 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14644022
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoIt could be just me, but could you point out where the comment says he likes to be connected to advertisers? The thing is, personally I prefer getting integrated results from Google's other search services when I do a Google search. I like getting Google Maps results when I search for a location, I like getting Google Flights results etc. When I do a Google search I am not just using it as a simple website search. I want it to use it to search the whole Google suite of services. If they are forced to stop doing this it will make my search experience worse for me. Random, maybe silly idea. Maybe they could start providing two search streams. One would just be a simpler website search while the other would be a more involved google services search as well as a general website search. This way search users could explicitly say that they want to see direct integrated results from the whole Google ecosystem.
- jasode 9y agoMaybe you're not seeing it because you're looking for literal exact words. Instead, look for meaning ... such as the one embedded in this sentence: >I prefer getting integrated results from Google's other search services when I do a Google search. One example of "other search services" is Google Shopping. It's the retail advertisers that sponsor their ecommerce buying links to Google Shopping. Hence, the "advertisers connection to users". Btw, there are also other posters making similar comments about the convenience of Google "connecting users to advertisers". Like the previous example, you won't see it if you're looking for that exact phrasing. E.g. another comment by cyxxon: "Currently Google's services just so damned conveniently integrated": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14644100 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14644100
- TeMPOraL 9y agoGP wasn't complaining about product issues (which were discussed in the other thread), but about the doublespeak used in Google's response.
- weberc2 9y agoDoesn't doublespeak imply a self-contradiction? At any rate, I thought the OP was complaining about "spin", in which case the reply is valid, as it isn't spin; there's just multiple valid ways of interpreting Google's behaviors, and which interpretation you choose depends largely on how satisfied you are with their business model.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoNo. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doublespeak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doublespeak "Not to be confused with Double-talk. Doublespeak is language that deliberately obscures, disguises, distorts, or reverses the meaning of words."
- xg15 9y agoI take deliberately leaving out crucial facts - such as that Google's "beneficial for both sides" product ads are paid by one side - as a pretty creative way of "interpreting".
- flexie 9y agoOn the contrary, in the other thread I see people mainly being supportive of the decision to fine Google for the abuse of its dominant position.
- anonymousab 9y agoI think that is more that some people find great value in Google's product integration, such as getting map or flight results from the main search, and they are unsure as to how Google can continue to offer such a convenience in light of this decision.
- surak 9y agoIf I understand the decision correctly it does not ban Google delivering other search types, but does limit its right to inter-connect search services on their search platform.
- Freestyler_3 9y agoHaving a monolopy comes with great disadvantages. Suddenly you can't bundle services (or push down other results in favor of your own). Anyhow, I like google shopping (when I click the google shopping tab, not when im actually on the search tab), I can trust it more than other comparing sites. Also just like other comparing sites, it doesn't have all sources.
- autokad 9y agoI'm going to get down voted out the wazoo for saying it, but I will voice my opinion anyways. The EU has long used 'anti trust fines' as a way of levying tariffs against US companies.
- glenndebacker 9y agoIt's not the first time that I see this being described as "anti-US". And that while the reality is that there is a list of European companies/kartels receiving high anti trust fines as well for their behaviour. The "problem" is that this never receives any interest in the states which only contributes to this blurred image that only US companies are getting fined. That is frankly untrue.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoUpvoted. FWIW, companies in the US have long used 'anti trust complaints' as a means of harming companies they can't compete with (e.g. Microsoft, back in the day).
- mattmanser 9y agoYeah, like that pesky Netscape that totally screwed over MS and almost stopped the golden age of web browsers between 2001 and 2006. /s
- duncan_bayne 9y agoHey, I had a 'best viewed with any browser' icon on my sites at the time (in fact http://dougal.sourceforge.net/ http://dougal.sourceforge.net/ still boasts one ...). Doesn't alter the fact that Netscape was incapable of competing with Microsoft (in fact I think you sort of made my point, there) once the latter got their arses into gear. Edited: Wow! The "Viewable With Any Browser" campaign site is still up, in 2017. I wonder if they're keeping it handy for the forthcoming Webkit monopoly ...
- mattmanser 9y ago
- coldtea 9y ago>It's just a reminder to remember that what doesn't work for you may be pure bliss for other people. What's pure bliss for some people might also be dangerous and cancerous for society. Segregation was "pure bliss" for lots of folks.
- interfixus 9y agoYou'll see people baffled by this decision and generally happy with the service and products google offers You'll also see people (me) baffled by this decision and generally disgusted by the services Google offers.
- baq 9y agoconsumers were happy when standard oil had 90% market share a century ago, too.
- xg15 9y agoHow many belong to the first and how many to the second category? Saying "yes, but in this particular edge-case, my actions will be beneficial to society" is a pretty old way to do spins. Also, as I've said in a different thread, the main problem is not with google's users but the amount of control Google has over 3rd parties (in the case price comparison sites). Of course it's convenient for the users, but's that not the point.
- saurik 9y agoSure, and there were tons of people who were very happy with Microsoft's products, and if you think about it: they were seriously fined for having the gall to believe that web browsers should be free and that the web rendering engine should be a component that could be used for the UI of things like their file manager; in an age when every operating system comes with a free, first-party web browser that you can't uninstall, are you prepared to say that Microsoft did nothing wrong as well?
- euyyn 9y agoYeah that's not what happened. People were very happy indeed with Microsoft products. Back when Netscape Navigator was better than Internet Explorer in all respects, people were very happy with NN too, and would have been happier if they could have bought Windows computers in which the software preinstalled by the OEM included Netscape. Do you know why they couldn't? MS told the OEMs "you put NN on your computers, you don't get any more Windows licenses at all". People were also happy with the Java applets NN could execute, but MS made its own incompatible version of Java so that they wouldn't be cross-platform. Same with their version of web standards in IE. All this is publicly documented by the courts, including the internal communications in Microsoft about it being a deliberate strategy to preserve Windows' monopoly. So, please, don't go up in arms to defend that cause, or imply that history made them justice.
- saurik 9y agoDid you read the comment I was replying to? I ask, because it sounds like you did not. I am going to quote the entire thing to make this extremely blunt, as I don't trust you will read it otherwise :/. > I'd encourage you (and everyone) to read the comments in the other thread happening today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14643712 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14643712 > You'll see people baffled by this decision and generally happy with the service and products google offers. > It's just a reminder to remember that what doesn't work for you may be pure bliss for other people. Read that, then read my comment, and then read your comment... it makes no sense at all. The person I replied to was defending Google using what I consider to a bullshit argument: using the apparent benefits of the monopoly to defend its existence; this (bad) argument also applies to Microsoft. In my post, I demonstrated that if that posted truly believed that, then they had better be prepared to defend Microsoft as well. Then you come out of nowhere and try to attack me, as if I was the one making the argument, rather than replying to it? WTF... I absolutely think that both Microsoft and Google are clearly abusive. This is particularly interesting and annoying as you seem to be going around this thread making the exact same mistake in multiple contexts. As an example, in reply to this other comment from someone else trying to compare the PR spin from Google to that of Microsoft. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14646873 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14646873
- 659087 9y agoAre we going to pretend Google and similar companies don't have employees and reputation management firms astroturfing sites like this one when bad PR strikes?
- kome 9y agoahahah! it's heartwarming that the first comment on HN is this one! Thank you, andrepd. Finally something different from the HN crowds of liberals, libertarians, corporate apologists and tech fanboys. I had the same feeling when I read that line "connecting our users with thousands of advertisers, large and small, in ways that are useful for both" ahaha, bugger off, google.
- HenryBemis 9y agoAlthough Google has done plenty for Technology and Humanity, when it comes to ads-marketing-tracking they are simply ruthless. Perhaps that penalty will make Google reconsider their stance on respecting everyone (and not just the ones who give them billions). Next horror story to come to your monitors over the next 5 years is monetising on the below: I search for "Item A". One week later I purchase "Item A". 2 days later Google reaches out to the retailer claiming $ for sending me to that specific retailer.
- rf15 9y ago> reconsider They will not reconsider unless it hurts them more than when they don't act this ruthless. Therefore: needs a heavier fine still :D Crime and exploiting monopolies must not pay.
- dontnotice 9y agoIt's weird that someone commenting here never read corporate PR before, I guess it's not any weirder than the proliferation of anti capitalist sentiment in a startup incubator community section. Still it's not nearly as nonsensical as this case in which a website operator is being fined billions for not featuring other website some more.
- pulse7 9y ago"for not featuring other website some more" => for not featuring other website equally as own ones...
- dontnotice 9y agoMy point is that it's nonsensical that they would have to feature anyone at all.
- andrepd 9y agoThey are by far the preeminent search engine of the Web. They use that position to promote their own services to the detriment of others. This is against antitrust law and thankfully the European commission stepped in.
- pulse7 9y ago"This is against antitrust law" in the market they operate on.
- andrepd 9y agoI don't see your point. It's odd to call out the corporate doublespeak because... everyone does it? And I'm thankful that the all-pervasive Google behemoth is subject to some regulations, thank you very much.
- coldtea 9y ago>It's weird that someone commenting here never read corporate PR before You seem to confuse having never read PR releases with still being outraged by their BS. Something being familiar doesn't make it right -- or means that only people that have never seen it would ever be enraged by it. For pointing out "nonsensical" stuff this was a very nonsensical argument. Not even wrong.
- staltz 9y agoThis kind of rhetoric is coming often from tech giants, travestying words and claiming the exact opposite of what they do in practice. There is an interesting parallel to make here with the Soviet Union: they used to set up puppet states which were nominally sovereign, independent, "people's republic", etc, while in practice were obviously just colonies. I guess extremely powerful institutions founded on abusive practices end up having to cover up their abuse, and an effective way is to confuse the common person into thinking that maybe they're not that bad after all. Another tactic is to dress your institutions with good causes as much as possible. You could see this in Google I/O, they often used examples such as curing cancer as applications of their AI infrastructure. If your institution is 10% good and 90% bad, you can downplay your bad acts and loudly campaign about your good doing and you may be able to shift the public perception of your monopolistic institution to look more like 70% good, 30% bad and win the support of majority of the people, which usually have a neutral stance.
- coldtea 9y ago>There is an interesting parallel to make here with the Soviet Union: they used to set up puppet states which were nominally sovereign, independent, "people's republic", etc, while in practice were obviously just colonies. So just like "wars to spread democracy" when it's just oil/control of land/etc?
- jimmywanger 9y ago> This kind of rhetoric is coming often from tech giants, travestying words and claiming the exact opposite of what they do in practice. You have provided exactly zero (0) examples of this happening - just accusations. You accuse "tech giants" (whatever that means) of being abusive and deliberately confusing the common person, then you bring up Google's AI infrastructure as an "institution" dressed up in good causes. When you have examples or really anything besides a huge bias and wild accusations, please contribute to the conversation. Your comment adds exactly nothing except for letting all of us know you don't like large tech companies.
- staltz 9y ago"Tech giants" mean very large tech companies, basically these: Facebook, Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Apple. This term is found often in the media, and is quite unambiguous. Examples of rhetoric from those companies where they do the opposite of what they say: they often claim "you [the user] are in control". For instance 1. https://privacy.google.com/# https://privacy.google.com/# ("put you in control") 2. https://www.facebook.com/facebook/info https://www.facebook.com/facebook/info ("make the world more open and connected") While it's debatable what "in control" is and what "open and connected" means, they make a bold claim without revealing the subtlety of the topic. Not being honest about user data collection in NSA PRISMA is not exactly putting the user in control. Google has a track record of deprecating services that were used by a sizable user base, such as Google Reader or Picasa. Shutting these down without even giving them out as open source or providing some migration path is not really letting the users be in control. Google's core strategy is shifting towards suggestions, away from search. Page and Brin said this. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GpjOZGxKhRM&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GpjOZGxKhRM&feature=youtu.be While it could be argued that suggestions just create assistance like a personal secretary does, Google doesn't just assist on demand, it proactively suggests (and will do more of this, according to Page and Brin), and also shapes users' perception of reality (through Google Search results, which is the topic of the fine). So an entity has pervasive information about a person, does proactive suggestions and shapes their perception of reality is not exactly what I would call a mere assistant. I would compare that role to parenthood, which is consistent with Google's strategies: to know more about you than you know yourself, and to take care of you (which is aligned with their "Don't be evil" / "Do the right thing" motto. It seems they genuinely believe they are benevolent). That is, arguably, Google in control. Now onto example 2, Facebook has long said it makes the world more open and connected. The mere fact that Facebook holds massive amounts of relevant content locked up behind a login wall means content is not accessible to search engines. This is the exact opposite of an "open" scenario. It's also debatable what they mean by "connected". It sounds like "people connected to each other", but in practice it is "people connected to Facebook", and incidentally also connected to each other. If their goal was to connect people to each other, they would pursue P2P, mesh networks (e.g. https://www.scuttlebutt.nz/ https://www.scuttlebutt.nz/ is one implementation), etc that allow local communities to connect with each other and with the external world despite the lack of internet infrastructure. In practice, their internet.org program is widely known to have dropped net neutrality when it was implemented in India and other countries, favoring Facebook's walled garden. This is the opposite of open and connected (e.g. it eliminates interaction with other people on different social networks like forums, Reddit, etc). They have plans to provide internet to regions that lack internet infrastructure through drones and satellites (http://www.computerworld.com/article/2855979/why-google-and-facebook-need-balloons-drones-and-rockets.html http://www.computerworld.com/article/2855979/why-google-and-...) but the priority here seems to be getting those people connected to Facebook first, and then connected to other people. Cheaper and quicker solutions could be implemented simply with phones and P2P, allowing people to connect to each other first, and share data in a gossip style which is also scalable. So there you go, two examples at least. It should be enough to confirm that I am contributing to the conversation, and I'd appreciate if no ad hominen comments are made, they just distract.
- a3_nm 9y agoYeah, see also: > When you shop online, you want to find the products you’re looking for quickly and easily. And advertisers want to promote those same products. No, Google: advertisers don't want to promote the products I am looking for. Advertisers want to promote the products they want to sell. They may happen to be the ones I'm looking for, but probably they are not; probably I don't even want to buy anything and you still want to show me ads.