4 ms·
First - If workers hours can be cut arbitrarily by employers in a response to an increased minimum wage, then FIX that. Even peoplel paid by the hour obviously
by alkonaut 9y ago
First - If workers hours can be cut arbitrarily by employers in a response to an increased minimum wage, then FIX that. Even peoplel paid by the hour obviously need contracts that ensure them an amount of work - ideally a guaranteed full time (40/h week) and any less than that should be the choice of the employee.
I think increased minimum wages are a good thing but it seems like an attempt to cure the symptoms rather than the cause.
- ubernostrum 9y agoLast election, Santa Clara (county, IIRC) had a ballot proposition up to change their labor law so that a business which needed additional hours worked would be required to offer them first to existing employees (potentially putting them over thresholds for things like full-time employment status) before they could hire any additional employees to work those hours. It's a game of whack-a-mole, but if you want to get to living wage + benefits for everyone, that's kind of how you have to go about it, since businesses will always hunt for loopholes.
- alkonaut 9y agoIt's also a race to the bottom if you allow counties or even states to have local more "business friendly" employment laws. If every employer in the country was required to offer full time and 20 days paid vacation, then it wouldn't be a competitive disadvantage to do so.
- randyrand 9y agoexcept for global markets...
- nkristoffersen 9y agoNot a very viable solution: but you can apply for unemployment for those missing hours.
- qeternity 9y agoThen employers will simply wholesale fire other employees. The point is that when costs go up, the demand curve shifts. Forcing businesses to do otherwise would wreak havoc.
- alkonaut 9y agoHaving employers that can't provide decent workplaces and decent pay go under is a good thing. That's the goal of these regulations. It's sometimes incorrectly seen as an unwanted side effect of more labor friendly regulations - but it's not. Employers that can't pay a living wage should simply go under. Having fewer employees work better hours (full time) is also a desired effect.
- chillydawg 9y agoI think you've mixed up employees and employers a few times there, makes for confusing reading.
- alkonaut 9y agoHaha thanks, I sorted it I think. If "e" and "r" makes any difference to a word then why are the keys right next to eachother?
- edanm 9y agoWell your theory kind of flies in the face of most economist's views, which should be a red flag. I don't think forcing companies to go out of business because they can't "provide wages" for employees makes sense. For one thing, that's not remotely the goal of the business. For another, nothing guarantees that these companies will go under, rather than (as most are doing) simply cutting back on some hours and some jobs. You seem to suggest that the natural state of the world is a bunch of businesses paying a high wage, and that if we just get rid of all these businesses that are paying lower than that, we'd find jobs for everyone in higher-paying places. The truth is that some people simply can't provide more than $15 an hour in value to any business, for whatever reason, and no business will ever pay them more. These people will simply remain unemployed.
- Broken_Hippo 9y ago"Even people paid by the hour obviously need contracts that ensure them an amount of work" I wish this were the case everywhere. I've just signed my first job contract in Norway, and I gotta say I prefer it. Folks working here have a right to a job contract. Even if you are part-time or temporary/seasonal. Even if you work fast food. Even getting paid hourly. It does take care of things like getting wages cut and having trouble getting unemployment for it. You have proof in your contract. That said, the contracts really don't really make wages more fair, merely affects some of the reactions to a rising minimum wage. There really isn't anything about a contract that would stipulate a better wage offer. Instead, it forces folks to be a lot more upfront about the job, wages, and promises of pay hikes/time off. The employee can sign it or not, the same as they can accept or deny a job now. I'm gonna guess you can do away with minimum wage laws, but only if you actually have a balancing force against employers, even in times of economic downturn. Laws do that, especially if updated and adjusted to make sense for the times, but I don't know of anything else that could do that. Theoretically folks can just change jobs, form a union, or get schooling/training, but this doesn't realistically work for many minimum-wage workers. A strong safety net might make those sorts of things more possible, though.