6 ms·
It is too bad that the graph doesn't include the USA. That would clearly show how much better social mobility is in Canada than the USA. Which is an important
by btilly 9y ago
It is too bad that the graph doesn't include the USA. That would clearly show how much better social mobility is in Canada than the USA.
Which is an important but under-appreciated fact.
- 13of40 9y agoI'd be interested to see that, and another axis for race. I'd imagine the opportunity for social mobility for most Canadian First Nations people, for example, is pretty grim.
- btilly 9y agoI would love to see that as well, if you can track down the data. And I expect that your theory is right. :-(
- evgen 9y agoProbably so, but I would be willing to bet that it is better than the social mobility of Native Americans.
- jeromegv 9y agoWhat is it with this idea that things are always better in Canada? Without any data to back it up? Considering Canada has been blamed at the UN for their treatment of First Nations, I wouldn't race to this conclusion. Considering how terrible it is in Canada, it would be good to question what can be done in Canada instead of trying to diminish the problem by "betting" that at least we are better than Americans ??!
- hackermailman 9y agoI live in a heavily native populated area in Canada, the anecdotes I hear from them is it is far better to be an American Native than a Canadian one because of the Indian Act which doesn't grant them title to their lands, so they legally can't own a house on a reserve and use it for collateral to obtain loans or pass it to another generation as a way of transferring wealth. Americans also have much more freedom to do what they want on their own land such as building casinos or whatever they want, here it requires navigating the ancient Indian Act.
- mthoms 9y agoI vaguely recall learning that the collective ownership of the First Nations lands was at their own request. Before Europeans, First Nations had no concept of individual land ownership. Your point still stands of course, I just thought that should be pointed out.
- 13of40 9y agoAnecdotally, I had high school friends in rural Oregon who were something like 1/4 native American, and they all got a free college education because of it.
- sdm 9y agoFor Canada ethnicity would be relevant not race. Racial normativism not a significant part of our culture like it is in the US.
- refurb 9y agoWhy would you say social mobility is better in Canada vs. the US? Do you have any data to back that up? You also have to remember that social mobility can be skewed by wealth distribution. Let's say a person goes from earning $75K to $100K in Canada. That might mean you moved from the 3rd quintile to the 5th quintile. But the same person moving from $75K to $125K in the US might only move from the 3rd quintile to the 4th, even though the US person overall improved their situation more.
- btilly 9y agoIt was a tidbit that I ran across in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9UmdY0E8hU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9UmdY0E8hU which had some other interesting data points as well. Such as the fact that when you look at rich people per capita, it seems that social democracies like Canada, and Scandinavia create rich people more easily than the USA does. For example if you look for people worth $30million+ per million people, Canada has 186 while the USA has 126. That's about a third more per capita. And watching the video, you find that 42% of the children of the bottom 20% in the USA wind up in the bottom 20%. Very little of Canada does anything like that poorly.
- refurb 9y agoWhoa, wait a second, now it's better if Canada has more people per capita with >$30M in wealth? That would suggest less income equality, not more?
- eastWestMath 9y agoNot really, a lot of the income inequality comes from having a large underclass stuck in a cycle of generational poverty for various reasons (often/mostly related to structural racism).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- trackofalljades 9y agoThere's plenty of "data to back that up," and the delta is getting bigger every year. Fire up any search engine or look on any reliable media source (doesn't have to be a Canadian one). They've even talked about it on CNN (if you consider that journalism).
- havetocharge 9y agoIt's hard to draw such conclusion without data. My income more than doubled after moving from Toronto to NY. Adjusting for cost of living, the gap is paradoxally, even larger. I'm not extraordinary, bit the opportunities in the States are just better (for me).
- aianus 9y agoIt's better because we have the opportunity to move to the US and Americans don't have anywhere better to move. I'm only partially kidding; all the best people in my class making the most money moved to the US immediately upon graduation.
- xiaoma 9y agoIt really depends on how you define social mobility. Immigrants in the US often jump from the bottom to top income quartiles within a single generation. For those born in the US, there's less movement and that's exactly what would be expected in a system that has been relatively meritocratic for multiple generations. Regardless of whether of the previous generation excelled due to cultural or hereditary reasons, their children will likely inherit both. Children also inherit money, which is a factor. However, if money were the primary factor, poor immigrant families would tend to remain poor and they don't. The times when there's a great deal of mobility between generations of native populations is when there's a change in structural obstacles (or benefits). This can be seen especially clearly in Jewish populations in the US when various discriminatory regulations were removed early last century or with (ethnically) Asian Americans later in the century. In both cases, many families made rapid gains in relative income and wealth. In the subsequent generation, children of the winners generally kept winning and metrics of "social mobility" displayed a decline, even though society had become objectively fairer than it had been two generations before. This isn't to say society is "fair" now, only that simple inter-generational economic mobility comparisons poorly answer the question of where a conscientious person with no money would have the best chance of success.
- coldtea 9y ago>However, if money were the primary factor, poor immigrant families would tend to remain poor and they don't. Well, tons of poor latinos and other would argue otherwise.