4 ms·
For books, you have to generally read them like 5 times. The first pass might take me like an hour, it's mostly to establish a general mental framework for what
by adamnemecek 9y ago
For books, you have to generally read them like 5 times. The first pass might take me like an hour, it's mostly to establish a general mental framework for what's in the book (actually try to read the table of content, and like familiarize yourself with the words you might not know). On the second pass, you will actually try to read the book and retain like 20% of what you read. On the next one try the next 30%.
This approach has the advantage that it lets you decide what's important. I also like to believe that it establishes better connections between the single ideas.
I would say that goals are counterproductive until you are somewhat comfortable but not when starting out. Like yeah sure, you should make some progress but you are in an uncharted territory, the best thing you can do is to walk around a bit and make sure you stay engaged.
If you move to a new city, you probably walk around the neighborhood for a bit, then to the neighborhood next to yours etc etc.
- mikegerwitz 9y agoThis was on HN quite some time ago: http://pne.people.si.umich.edu/PDF/howtoread.pdf http://pne.people.si.umich.edu/PDF/howtoread.pdf I find it valuable for another reason: I'm always constrained for time, so I might not get through an entire book. If that book is deeply technical, it discourages me from continuing, because I have to take the time to re-skim what was read previously. I somewhat recently started trying the above method. With multiple iterations through the book, I can get an idea of the information and at the very least know where it find it and that it exists. Depending on the iteration, I'll have some notes to fall back on, or have some important concepts underlined.
- function_k 9y agoGreat PDF on how to read.
- cma 9y agoThis is also why you shouldn't just watch beginner tutorials on complex software like 3d modeling packages or digital audio workstations. Those are good, but you should also watch professionals use the tools on really complicated projects in person or in screencasts. While you won't be able to follow along fast enough and will be in way over your head, you will learn what's possible and be able to remember in the future when you run into a problem that needs complex radial symmetry, or whatever, that there a way that is much faster. It also broadens your notion of what is possible in the application, rather than trying to reason from the ground up of the simple tools you have learned in a beginner tutorial.
- sevensor 9y agoThat's a good guide, but one thing I think it doesn't emphasize enough is the preface. If a book has a preface, that's usually where the authors make their case for why the book exists in the first place. It's worth paying extra attention to the preface, because it establishes the context of the entire work. The ToC tells you what's in there, and it might hint at why, and the intro might give you more historical background, but the preface is almost always short and sweet.
- cs-student 9y agoHow does this work for mathematic books?
- tigershark 9y agoIt is extremely inefficient to just read a book 5 times, it is like throwing mud to the wall hoping that it sticks. It's much more effective to focus on each topic and try to remember and repeat the informations just read. Having a general mental framework on the book on the other hand is very helpful.
- adamnemecek 9y agoNot it's not. It's not like each pass takes as long as if you were doing it in one pass. I would actually say that this approach is faster as it lets you focus better and on the things you want to get. > it is like throwing mud to the wall hoping that it sticks I must have not explained it well because that's the exact opposite of what I'm talking about. It's not about what sticks, it's about creating the connect-the-dots > It's much more effective to focus on each topic and try to remember and repeat the informations just read. Effective for what? Assuming that a neural net is a good approximation of the human learning model, why do nns tend to be be trained over multiple epochs?
- tigershark 9y agoTo create the connections you have to consciously think and recall not only the topics, but also understand how they are connected and practice them. Seriously, I thought this was the last place on earth were I would have found people saying that to learn something the best way is to read a book 5 times. Because if you want to learn Java obviously the best way is to read a Java book 5 times, instead of reading one concept at a time, understanding it, recalling it, putting it in practice with exercises without looking at the book and connecting all the concepts. I will continue learning in my way that for you is for some reason so alien, good luck in learning reading 5 times.
- adamnemecek 9y agoYou are misunderstanding what I'm saying.
- pdog 9y ago
- 1001101 9y agoI do a bit of a twist on this : I get as many books on the same subject as I can and read them all at least once. I typically find that each one has valuable nuggets, one really clicks with my brain, and all contribute to scaffolding a solid internal representation.
- adamnemecek 9y agoHaha same here. It's becoming a bit of an issue, as my apt is getting filled up.
- kowdermeister 9y ago> The first pass might take me like an hour How do you fast read it? It's more like skimming it rather than actually understanding it. It would be frustrating for me, I'm more like a perfectionist who hates to leave behind not understood paragraphs. The idea is neat though, I lean the same way, but it's not true how I read books.
- adamnemecek 9y agoVery quickly. I would say I'm only scanning for terms that occur a lot and that I'm not familiar with. And in what order they are introduced.